Making way for a new house on South Water street in Edgartown.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Residential Construction Is Booming on Island

Martha’s Vineyard towns are seeing a boom in residential construction projects, as building demands soar both up-Island and down. The majority of the activity is in renovations.

Martha’s Vineyard towns are seeing a boom in residential construction projects, as building demands soar both up-Island and down. And while the majority of the activity appears to be in renovations — some of them massive — new construction is on the rise in some places too, Island building inspectors told the Gazette in recent interviews.

Renovations — sometimes massive — account for much of the activity.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Renovations — sometimes massive — account for much of the activity.
Mark Alan Lovewell

The driving force behind the surge is the booming real estate market on the Island, inspectors said.

During the early days of the pandemic, a months-long construction ban halted nearly all work Islandwide for much of the spring. But when the ban was lifted near the start of summer, the demand for building permits fairly exploded and has continued with no letup, according to a wide array of reports, both data-driven and anecdotal. Residential building permit applications began to surge beginning around July, while throughout the summer downtown streets could be seen lined with construction vehicles and pickup trucks, a trend that continues into the fall.

Numbers tell part of the story.

Edgartown building inspector Reade Kontje Milne said during the height of the lockdown from March to June, the town issued 159 building permits, 121 fewer than the same time period last year. But by mid-summer, activity had picked up and has remained steady ever since, Ms. Milne said.

From the start of July through the end of September, Edgartown issued 200 building permits, with 51 issued in July, 48 in August, and a staggering 101 in September. By contrast, the town issued 172 permits during the same period last year, recording 40 permits in July, 53 in August and 79 in September. 

The mid-summer surge came as a surprise to Ms. Milne, who said the annual influx of seasonal residents and renters has historically made summertime somewhat of an off-season for building.  “The pattern changed a little bit because of the construction ban, it just pushed everything back,” she said. “Normally we would see some quiet time in July and August, we just really didn’t feel that.” Tisbury building inspector Ross Seavey reported a similar trend. Mr. Seavey said he issued an unusually high volume of building permits this summer, beginning with 30 permits in July, followed by 31 in August and 45 in September. Last year, he issued 20 permits in July, 32 in August and 28 in September. Mr. Seavey also estimated that applications for permits were up this year by about 10 permits in the months of June and July respectively.

Island building inspectors say they see no letup in sight.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Island building inspectors say they see no letup in sight.
Mark Alan Lovewell

“It’s rare for this department to be issuing over 30 permits a month for months in a row,” Mr. Seavey said in an email. “In the past, an uptick month is usually followed or preceded by a lower month or months.”

West Tisbury building inspector Joe Tierney said the summer surge in his town was intensified by a pile-up of projects already in progress prior to the pandemic. 

The town issued 64 new permits over the months of July and September, including minor work permits and gas and wiring permits. But many permits from 2019 — 400 building permits were issued between March 1 and Sept. 30 of last year — have just now reached the building stage, pushing the total volume of building activity higher still, Mr. Tierney said. 

“We could have anywhere from 100 to 150 active permits at a time,” he said.

Mr. Seavey said the activity includes new construction as well as renovations. “I would say new dwellings and residential renovations are the two areas that have spiked,” he said. “There is an increase of single family dwellings compared to year over year, but by far the majority of work that’s being done in Tisbury is residential renovation . . . the numbers for renovations are definitely up,” he said. 

Mr. Tierney said West Tisbury too is seeing activity across the board.

“There’s been a real smattering of

things — people putting in decks, basements, recreation rooms. It’s a little bit of everything,” he said. 

The scale and scope of building projects have also been larger on average this year, building inspectors said. 

As homes change hands at a steady clip, renovations, additions and new construction are on the rise.
Mark Alan Lovewell
As homes change hands at a steady clip, renovations, additions and new construction are on the rise.
Mark Alan Lovewell

“What feels the most dramatically different to me is the scale of project is really changing,” said Ms. Milne, noting a trend in Edgartown toward larger, more involved projects that has grown over the past few years. 

“We have more enormous, complicated compounds that are that are going in . . . And with something like that, while it might look like one more permit, the building, the plan review, every inspection, actually takes up a lot more time because of the scale of these projects,” she added.

Meanwhile, commercial construction activity has been slim, with Edgartown issuing only 18 commercial permits from March to September — compared with 37 for the same period last year. West Tisbury issued three commercial permits compared with eight last season.

As for the residential construction surge, it is a direct outgrowth of the recent burst in real estate sales activity on Martha’s Vineyard, inspectors said.

“What we have is a lot of inquiries from real estate agents because there are a lot of transactions happening,” said Ms. Milne, who expects requests for renovation projects of all kinds in

the coming months. “I think we’re both kind of anticipating that kitchen remodel, bathroom remodel — all of those things are probably coming down the pipeline,” she said.

Edgartown has issued permits for 35 more residential additions or alterations this summer than last, according to department reports. 

Mr. Tierney echoed Ms. Milne’s comments. “There’s more to come this fall because of the real estate market,” he said. “People will want to do alterations and renovations.”

Most towns report a sharp increase in outdoor renovations and expansions in particular, such as guest houses, deck repairs — and most notably, installing pools.

Contractor vehicles line downtown streets in Edgartown.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Contractor vehicles line downtown streets in Edgartown.
Mark Alan Lovewell

In West Tisbury, Mr. Tierney said he saw a marked increase in the number of pool houses constructed this summer, while in Tisbury, Mr. Seavey speculates that the number of pools installed surged from a typical one per month to about three or four a month this year. In Edgartown, 11 new pools were installed in the month of September alone, compared with a single pool installed last September.  Island contractors and landscapers are on the front lines of the demand, scrambling to keep up with it all. Fred Fournier, who owns Landscope, an Edgartown-based landscape design company, estimated that business is up 40 or 50 per cent this year from last year. Employees in his company’s maintenance and construction teams are working on anywhere from 15 to 20 projects each day, he said. And work on some larger scale and longer-term projects is expected to continue through 2023, he added. 

“We’re extremely busy,” said Mr. Fournier. “The real estate market is gangbusters, people are buying houses, people are buying second homes, and third homes. And with that, they do interior restorations, they do additions, but they also do major exterior work . . . People are expanding on their exterior spaces, absolutely, a thousand-fold.”

Building inspectors said there appears to be no letup in the horizon.

“There was that initial increase and we’ve kind of stayed at that plateau, things haven’t dipped back down to kind of our normal levels,” Mr. Seavey said.

Ms. Milne agreed. “I think there’s steady growth going on in the construction industry. That’s what it feels like,” she said. “I don’t see it slowing down, just from looking at what’s out there, it seems like it’s going to continue.”

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 10/08/2020 - 21:48

Permalink

Curious MV

Really good story and valuable information. Why did you leave Chilmark and Oak Bluffs out of the story? Impossible to reach the building inspectors? Gotta figure double the business happening there. Note to self: don’t buy any new or remodeled property in either of these two towns if work was done during this period. Realtors should take note as well.

local tradesman Edgartown

Talk to anyone who has taken the contractor's course at the high school. The code books outline the MINIMUM standards for building and that's all building inspectors can enforce. As the instructor told my class, "If you're house is built just to code then it's probably not a great house". If I were a homeowner on this island I would be much more concerned with who is performing the work given this market, the amount of construction work on this island, and the lack of SKILLED labor we have here. There is zero barrier to entry for carpenters on this island. I would argue island wide, from high end new construction all the way to small cape/ranch remodels, the level of craftsmanship has been steadily declining over the past few years while this island experiences a construction boom. Most GC's on this island don't even have their own crews anymore, it's all subcontractors, and why would you try to focus all your attention into the details of one house built perfectly when you can build 3 or 4 homes quickly and double or triple your profit. Construction is a for-profit business at the end of the day. Just my opinion, although take it with a grain of salt seeing I'm just some local yahoo who works in the trades.

Mack and the boys

This is consistent with what I've heard from people in the trades. Foundations poured wrong, brand new houses already deteriorating during the construction process, unbelievable waste. Most of these new "compounds" will not outlive their present owners.

fact checker edg

I agree with many of the comments about quality and mass-production of homes. One of my best friends here is a well respected builder in partnership with his brother with his own crew, and only focuses on one or 2 projects at a time. As such, he is on site, banging nails himself and supervising the job. He personally looks at every piece of lumber before installing it for perfection. Every floor is screwed and glued. When subs are necessary, such as foundation, electrical, or plumbing specialties, there are only a select few that are acceptable. He's not beholden to any architect (as a GC usually is) and won't hesitate to refuse to build some sort of 'imagination' conceived by an architect. As a trained engineer, he knows more than they do. ALSO... he has never ONCE advertised. All business is on a referal basis. Think about this when you choose a GC or a builder... if they have plastered their names all over advertisements, chances are their work doesn't bring referalls. Especially in this hot market where if you can tell which end of a hammer to use there will be work. And I want my builder to show up to the job in a pickup truck and have dirt on his hands... not some fancy foreign SUV..

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 10/08/2020 - 22:03

Permalink

Mark Edgartown

Can we please slow down new construction, the island is overbuilt already. Hopefully the MVC can control this going forward.

Mark Edgartown

Some things are for the greater good, we need to cut to net zero carbon emissions and reducing construction on our island is part of that.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 10/09/2020 - 07:26

Permalink

fact checker edg

This is a beautiful place surrounded by water. Its comical to see how these people all insist upon installing a pool.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 10/09/2020 - 12:37

Permalink

Bob Edgartown

Everyone is trying to get their projects in and approved before the new DRI rules take effect by the MVC. Soon many more projects will have to go to the MVC first. More time more money for the public.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 10/10/2020 - 08:45

Permalink

Beth West Tisbury

Hopefully when the Towns are issuing these new permits for repairs and expansion, they are addressing the issue that the current sewage plant. Expansion and new building permits should not be allowed until they deal with the fact that the sewage waste plant is not able to handle the current sewage on the Island. Right now we can't get the maintenance pump which impacts the current home systems. This should be the priority. This affects all aspects of the Island homes and it's environment.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 10/10/2020 - 11:27

Permalink

KD Edgartown

Solid and remarkably POSITIVE article about the boom. Would be interested in more analytical piece about integrity of the larger, massive, disruptive "what price glory" projects happening around the island on large rural lots or tiny village postage-stamp lots, such as the project featured in in the lead photo.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 10/10/2020 - 11:33

Permalink

Tom Edgartown

I think we need a shut down on all new construction for one year and then re- evaluate do we really need more 6-8 bedroom homes??

Kelce OB

So during a global pandemic you're proposing a building "pandemic"? Are you going to feed the families of all the plumbers, carpenters, electricians, roofers and masons who'll be unemployed during your proposed lay-off?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 10/12/2020 - 14:27

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

IF there is a contractor course being taught at the MV High School, is there an apprentice program that goes along with it? Certainly many or most of the people buying/rehabbing/building these huge houses will need maintenance on an ongoing basis? Nothing stays news, it all needs tweaking and repair. It is difficult to call for a moratorium on building when families need work to survive. How is that accomplished without damaging the workforce and families?

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.