<p>Construction has begun on a large bingo hall planned by the tribe in Aquinnah — and tribal leaders have issued a stern warning to the town and the Martha’s Vineyard Commission to not interfere.</p>
Construction has begun on a large bingo hall planned by the Wampanoag tribe in Aquinnah — and tribal leaders have issued a stern warning to the town and the Martha’s Vineyard Commission to not interfere or face aggressive legal action.
Clearing is now evident on tribe-owned property off Black Brook and State Roads where the bingo hall is planned. In a press release that went out Saturday night, Cheryl Andrews-Maltais, chairman of the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah), formally announced the start of construction.
“We remain committed to bringing positive economic development to our tribe, the town of Aquinnah and our neighbors in the larger Island community,” the statement said in part. “We bring to life the vision for this entertainment experience.”
Among other things, the announcement confirms that the plan calls for building a 10,000-square-foot facility to house 250 electronic gaming machines, a beer and wine bar, outdoor seating and food trucks. Once it is up and operating, the casino will employ about 100 full and part-time workers, the announcement also said. Williams Building Co. of Hyannis is the general contractor.
The tribe had previously announced its partnership with Global Gaming Solutions, a business entity of the Chickasaw Nation in Oklahoma, to develop the project.
Last week, work was underway on the site, formerly known as the Wiener property, which had been acquired by the tribe. Trees and brush had been removed and heavy equipment was visible from State Road.
The land clearing and formal announcement of construction come as the Martha’s Vineyard Commission is considering whether to review the bingo hall as a development of regional impact (DRI). Aquinnah and Chilmark selectmen have both asked for the review.
Simultaneous with the press announcement on Saturday, Ms. Andrews Maltais released an exchange of letters between the tribe, the commission and the town of Aquinnah last week.
The first was a letter hand delivered to Ms. Andrews-Maltais on Feb. 20 from MVC executive director Adam Turner, notifying her of the referrals from the two towns and requesting a meeting on Monday, Feb. 25.
“We trust that as the representatives of the original Islanders you share our desire to preserve the unique values of the Vineyard,” the letter said in part. “Regardless of political boundaries we are one Island.”
Responding by letter on Friday, Feb. 22, Ms. Andrews-Maltais said the commission lacks jurisdiction to review the project. She pointed to the decision by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit upholding the tribe’s sovereign rights to build a gaming facility under federal law, and the subsequent denial by the U.S. Supreme Court last year to hear the town’s petition for review, ending the case.
“If the MVC embraces that court decision and acknowledges that the MVC lacks jurisdiction over the gaming project, the tribe is more than happy to engage in a government-to-government dialogue,” Ms. Andrews-Maltais wrote. She said while the tribe had been unaware of Chilmark’s referral to the commission, she strongly criticized Aquinnah for seeking MVC review of the bingo hall. “It is unfortunate that the town has involved the MVC (and now the town of Chilmark) in an attempt to further the town’s longstanding agenda of interference with the tribe’s exercise of its rights under federal law to have a gaming facility on its tribal lands on the Island,” Ms. Andrews-Maltais wrote.
Meanwhile, in an even more sharply worded letter sent to the Aquinnah selectmen on Friday, Ms. Andrews-Maltais demanded that the town withdraw its letter to the MVC or face severed ties and legal action.
“Even after losing in the highest court in the land (at no small monetary cost to all parties), the town now seeks to do what it now knows cannot be done directly,” she wrote. “Therefore, unless the town withdraws its letter to the MVC and acknowledges that the towns lacks jurisdiction over all the matters integral to the tribe’s gaming operation, the tribe will no longer engage in discussions with the town on gaming matters whatsoever.
“It is truly unfortunate that it has come to this.”
The letter also said: “Please be advised that any repeated effort by the town to stop the tribe’s gaming operation will be countered with an aggressive legal defense by the tribe. Frankly, the tribe is surprised that the town would even raise the possibility of further litigation by trying to force the MVC into a position to pursue or be the recipient of litigation in the wake of the town’s unmitigated loss at the First Circuit and then again at the United States Supreme Court.”

Comments
Under your logic(?) my 26
Mensa Eddie Noth NoepeUnder your logic(?) my 26 acre MV parcel which I own free and clear could be converted by me into, say, a Rodeo Venue. After clear cutting all the trees building the structure. paving big parking areas, all without local agency or town scrutiny I can be "in business". After all , like you say it is my land and none of anybody else's business. Right R Scott ? Hmmm you got me thinking!
"They call it paradise, I don
NP Edgartown"They call it paradise, I don't know why, you call someplace paradise, kiss it goodbye."
The Eagles
"Last Resort"
Well. I cant imagine a low
DownislanderWell. I cant imagine a low budget slot machine gambler coming to the island, spending $2500 a week to rent a place, hundreds more on food and transportation to drive to Aquinnah to pull levers and eat $20 food truck burgers. We shall see.
You’re right...which is why
JM 02539You’re right...which is why this crowd will utilize tour buses for day trips...which will cause the predictable issues.... Overall a very unfortunate path that will result in considerable ‘cost’ Island wide
The Tribe, who claim to be
Farmer5 Formerly of ChilmarkThe Tribe, who claim to be the stewards of the environment, have not lived up to that lofty distinction. Their aquaculture project failed quickly and the debris, much of it plastic, was left to rot and/or blow over to the Chilmark side of Menemsha Pond. Threat of legal action was required before they hired a non-tribal member to clean up the mess they left behind.
I sincerely doubt that their plan for a bingo hall will work. The numbers don't make any sense. In the off chance it could sustain itself it would certainly have a serious impact on the immediate surroundings, the roads and the Island in general. Apparently, that is not their concern. I'd advise them to start thinking about alternative uses for their 10,000 sq. ft. bingo hall now before it is abandoned and deteriorates like some other notable 'projects'.
I respect the tribe, it's
Robby K Oak BluffsI respect the tribe, it's desire to help subsidize the membership with the casino proceeds, etc. However, I do believe that all towns should be involved in the discussion, only to ensure that the tribe contributes proceeds from the venture to road maintenance, environmental impact and public safety (outside tribal land). I also believe that this is the first step to a full blown casino on island. In my humble opinion, I believe that we will see the tribe challenge the SSA down the road to ensure they will be able to have their own ferry transportation to the casino, heli-pads ( as other casino's do) and transportation centers. The Wampanoag are a great people, and should be respected. The tribe should also respect all residents of the island in their decision making on the casino. After 100's of years, and generations long passed, now we all share the island and the impact is on far more than those who choose to live in Aquinnah. The decisions made today will affect us all for generations to come.
I would love to see someone
Carol Greenwich CTI would love to see someone embrace eco-tourism. The Tribe may be the most qualified to introduce exploration, cultural and natural history interests and a unique up Island experience. Have great food, simple but elegant overnight opportunities - indoor and out! Guest speakers and Tribal leaders from around the country and from different tribes could come and add to the experience. I would go. So would my friends. Of course they could make it like a theme park but nothing sells like the real thing. As for gambling, yawn.
Will they have a spa? I like
RK Brookline MAWill they have a spa? I like spas. Hope they have a spa!
The Tribe has spent years
Kelce OBThe Tribe has spent years working on this, and turned over many rocks and held lengthy internal deliberations. The've hired professional advisors to guide them and to help with setting up and running a first class operation. A good contractor has been hired. I wish them great success with their new endeavor.
Sounds like this is going to
Bob EdgartownSounds like this is going to cost the tax payers plenty as the tribe is ready for a fight in court. The MVC is ready for the fight and eager to spend our tax dollars. We must put a limit on how much this fight is worth as the group behind the tribe will take this all the way up the money chain of lawyers, consultants, and courts. Let them have the slot machine as it will fail or be a side bar and of no concern. No one will come here to play the slots they come for beach and quiet. On a rainy day they will get a few clients and no one wants to drive up island at night. In time it will be a nothing issue.
You are aware that this has
R Scott Patterson EdgartownYou are aware that this has already been decided by the Supreme Court? The tribe can build it's bingo hall and doesn't need to ask the MVC or anyone else for permission. If the MVC, Aquinnah, Chilmark try to sue they will be costing the taxpayers money, it won't be the Tribes fault.
Folks - let's be realistic,
John EdgartownFolks - let's be realistic, no one wishes our native american neighbors ill will, but this is just another move in a chess match playing out before us between the tribe and the State of Massachusetts. The tribe is attempting to use this, and the outrage it causes on-island, as leverage for a mainland casino - but the state is calling their bluff. Maybe the casino will be a success, maybe it will wither on the vine - who's to say. The one thing to remember is that the tribe has chosen to put their future economic viability in question - and it's unfortunate that these decisions are being made by tribal members and tribal gaming corporations that are a ferry or airplane ride away. I sincerely doubt that anyone but the local tribe members are assuming the financial risk here, so I hope they have incorporated this endeavor well.
So what is the tribe's
Adam Lang Martha's VineyardSo what is the tribe's strategy for this chess match?
they could never do to this
virginia yorke AQUINNAHthey could never do to this island, as much, as we have done to their island. . they were a peaceful people, with their own language and respect for the land. be thankful that you get to live here..
The tribe lawyers are clearly
Richard ChilmarkThe tribe lawyers are clearly bluffing. The federal courts have significantly, but still only ruled that state gaming restrictions do not apply to the tribes use of its land. Those courts haven't ruled that the state and local general police power rules, including generally applicable zoning laws that protect public health, safety, and welfare from the adverse impacts of poorly planned land use development do not apply. Of course they do. All laws regulating development because of its impact on traffic, water quality, aesthetics continue to apply as clearly do generally applicable code such as fire codes. It is a big deal that gaming restrictions do not apply. But all other generally applicable laws still apply. The town and MVC should not be fooled.
Best solution is for Charlie
Steve WhalenBest solution is for Charlie Baker to revive efforts to prepare, submit and approve a joint application by Mashpee/Aquinnah Wampanoags for the third major casino license approved for southeast Massachusetts. Everybody wins, the State, the State’s citizens, all the Tribal members, year round and summer residents of Martha’s Vineyard, the trades, everyone. Need to get this on Governor Baker’s radar.
I'm in. How can we support
James DonahueI'm in. How can we support this?
It should come from the
Steve Whalen Franklin/OBIt should come from the Tribes, not an easy lift as they are separate and distinct Nations. However no one could reasonably argue that Aquinnah is an ideal or even particularly attractive, venue for a casino, but it is all the Aquinnah Tribe has. Times and circumstances have changed since Governor Patrick was involved with this idea. I think Governor Baker would be much more open and willing to make a joint effort between the Tribes happen for the approved Southeast MA location if the Tribes want it to happen.
Add new comment