Throughout her life Carly Simon has been a dutiful diarist, and so the whole of her life was just an arm’s length away waiting to be reborn.
Near the end of her new memoir Boys in the Trees, Carly Simon writes: “I’m not the type of person to let go of my past easily. My memory is too good.”
Indeed, Ms. Simon’s memory is beyond good as she recaptures her life from childhood to about the mid-1980s, after she had reached the pinnacle of musical stardom and following the breakup of her marriage to James Taylor. But her memory also had help. Throughout her life Ms. Simon has been a dutiful diarist, and so the whole of her life — the events, thoughts and conversations of almost every day — were just an arm’s length away waiting to be reborn.
On Sunday, Dec. 20 at 4 p.m., Ms. Simon will give a book signing at the Bunch of Grapes Bookstore in Vineyard Haven.
The memoir took more than three years to write she said in a recent interview at her home off Lambert’s Cove Road in Vineyard Haven. “The first six or eight months was just research.”
She pored over her diaries, looking for clues and the melody of her life. She has long been a songwriter and the act of completing a book was in a way merely a longer version of what she had always been doing. And although it wasn’t a conscious decision, the patterns in a song also served as a guide.
“It’s a book whose chorus you don’t find out until it’s over and then you see if there is a chorus, a repeated phrase, or a repeated idea,” she said. “The beast, in a way, is kind of like a chorus. But not really. It’s more of a leitmotif. I think the big chorus doesn’t happen for me until the end when I start talking about forgiveness.”
The beast Ms. Simon refers to is the aggressive embodiment of the hurt and insecurity she felt in her life. And it does appear throughout the book, beginning when she was a little girl, the third daughter born into a wealthy New York family whose father Richard Simon started the publishing company that would become Simon and Schuster.
“I saw that the effect my father had on me was so crucial because of the lack of self esteem that I got from his not wanting a third daughter,” she said of her childhood. “I wasn’t beloved to him. And I saw it in contrast with how he was with my sisters.”
She developed a crippling stutter as a young girl, which made her shy and afraid of her own voice, a feeling that never went away. “I don’t like to be on stage either because I don’t like to be in the spotlight and that probably has to do with the early days in school and being called on in class and I couldn’t say anything because of my stammer,” she said.
A strange scenario for someone who has spent so much of her life on stage, performing for millions. But incongruities and insecurities are often at the heart of art and the drive to succeed.
Ms. Simon is correct that the beast does not serve as the chorus. Forgiveness and its ever present twin, vulnerability, provide much more of the motor for her memoir. But the case could also be made that words and writing are the true chorus. Beginning with her father’s profession and his ultimate fall from grace when he was edged out of Simon and Schuster, to her early diaries, to the men in her life — so many novelists and songwriters — to her own profession and the long journey to finding her voice, the act of writing has been a constant. And when asked about writing, Ms. Simon truly does comes alive, fairly leaping out of her seat and smiling from ear to ear.
“The most enjoyable part of the book was the actual act of writing,” she said. “I really love words, it’s like a wonderful puzzle. You see a bunch of words and it’s a mass of material that you haven’t decided whether to make a gown out of or curtains or what kind of curtains. You just kind of mold it and see how it comes to life.”
Early on she didn’t know exactly what form the memoir would take, but soon understood that the structure would be built around her relationships with men. Reviewing and reliving her relationship with her father made this essential to finding out why she has always been so hard on herself and worried about what men think of her, rather than what she thinks about them.
This is not to say the book is about settling grudges. The men in her life as described on the page come across as sympathetic characters. And they are, to use a fan’s vocabulary, a group of seriously awesome dudes.
Cat Stevens, Kris Kristofferson, Jack Nicholson, Warren Beatty, Mick Jagger, it is a gallery of 1970s royalty — the industries of film and music embodied in all of its male swagger through the eyes of a woman who was at the center of it all, and for a time eclipsed them. Be forewarned, some of the passages are sexually explicit.
And yet, spoiler alert, there is no one man who is so vain. That song, perhaps her most famous, is really the journey of a writer again, jotting down snippets of phrases in her diary over the course of years — clouds in my coffee on an airplane, watching with a friend a group of men enter a party and check themselves out in the mirror. But it was Mick Jagger who provided the much needed heat, surprising her at a recording session in London that wasn’t going well, perhaps too nervous because Paul McCartney was in the room. But then Mick joined her in the booth, harmonizing on the vocals for the chorus, and the song finally took flight.
And, of course, there is James Taylor, her former husband whom she first met when she was 11 years old cruising around the Vineyard on her bicycle, and he was a lanky teenager playing a guitar at the Chilmark Community Center. The Taylors and the Simons have become such fixtures on the Island, their families first coming here in the early 1900s, each successive generation making its marks on Island life, that it is difficult to imagine a time when Carly and James were just kids, able to putter about the beaches and dirt roads like any other anonymous and carefree summer dinks, frolicking in the surf and nursing crushes as they licked ice cream cones and imagined being stars one day. But that is how it began and so their coming together as a couple seemed predestined. They met again when JT was already famous, and Carly about to be, when she opened for Cat Stevens at the Troubador in Los Angeles.
They married and moved to the Vineyard and the early days are lovingly described in the book.
“Ahead of us I could see the outlines of what looked like a romantic music box of a house. It was James’s cabin, silhouetted in the moonlight. The pitch of the roof was steep. The windows were high and narrow. Everything about the house was like James himself: tall, lean, modest, and beautiful,” she writes.
Carly and James created a life on the Vineyard, introduced its rural pleasures to the stars of Saturday Night Live and also began the journey of raising two children, Sally and Ben. But the marriage didn’t last. Two musicians trading number one hits would certainly be a strain, plus the trappings of a rock and roll lifestyle were not conducive to settling down.
The process of writing the book, Ms. Simon admits, was partly about coming to terms with her relationship with James Taylor, both together and apart. After all, she said, she still lives in the house she first saw on that moonlit night.
“I did want to come to terms with the wonderful ghostlike memory of James, because I live with it in this house,” she said. “I’m the one who lives in the house and I’m altogether happy about living here, but there’s a lot more of the presence of James Taylor in my life than I am in his, strictly because of locale.”
Part of that presence is no shower, still after so many years, and no closets either.
“James didn’t believe in closets,” she said. “Everything was hung on a beam with nails and hooks. This place was a cabin in the woods. He would freak out if he came into this house now because it is so adorned,” she added with a laugh.
Ms. Simon is about to finally put a shower in her house, collaborating with Margot Datz on the project. “We are going to design it together and we will find an architect who will go along with Margo’s artistic plans,” she said.
And although the shower may be a small step, it could be viewed as a tangible one that speaks to the power of reviewing one’s life in order to move forward.
“The cloth does look different now,” Ms. Simon said after pausing to reflect on the long arc of her life and looking back on it for her memoir. “It’s less opaque. Looking at me, I’m not afraid of anything now.”
Carly Simon will give a book signing at the Bunch of Grapes Bookstore in Vineyard Haven on Sunday, Dec. 20, beginning at 4 p.m. In addition to the print version, there is an audiobook that Ms. Simon recorded herself, and a companion CD of songs.

Comments
Carly, I've come to know you
Sylvia Daley New Bedford, MACarly, I've come to know you later in life (I'm 82). I was busy earlier in my life raising four kids and having a career but a dear friend gave me a copy of Never Been Gone couple of years ago and I fell in love with your voice and could not wait to get hold of every album you ever made! I spend 2 weeks on the Vineyard every year in July and I met you there at Consensus this past summer when we played a game and you wrote a song from the comments we in the group had come up with after viewing one of Sally's cells. You could not have been more gracious and kind. It was one of the highlights of my life. Please know that there are those of us who really love and admire you and are in awe of your talent not only as a singer, songwriter and musician but also of your amazing intelligence and abilities as a writer and poet. Thank you for enriching my life. I listen to you every day and sing along at the top of my lungs in my car. He also gotten to know wonderful Gabby at Consensus and have met and love Sally. You are very blessed as are they to have you in their lives! Have a very Merry Christmas Carly.
Your devoted fan
Sylvia Daley
I am looking forward to
Ann Graham EdgartownI am looking forward to coming to Bunch of Grapes on Sunday- to buy a beautifully written and rendered book. Thank you Carly for writing it and thank you Bill Eville for sharing your words about it. They are equally beautiful.
Bill, talk about writing
Joanie Ruppel Keller, TXBill, talk about writing eloquently, your article is better than any I've read so far, because you captured reality. I'm going to send Katie the paragraph beginning, "I really love words..." it's her too.
Congratulations on a book
Toni Puig New YorkCongratulations on a book about a life well lived. When I think of the Simons I have a memory ingrained in my consciousness. After buying Peter's signed calendar each each for what seems like forever, I've never even shared it with him. I didn't want to bother him but I fell it might be a memory that you all would enjoy hearing about. I believe it was the day of Carly's first book signing at the old Bunch of Grapes. I was walking across the street taking a leisurely stroll when ahead I saw a beautiful elderly woman walking towards me. I first noticed her beautiful white shirt, her gorgeous gray hair in a bun and a small black bag slug over her body. Her face was beautiful and I said to myself, wow I hope I can look like that when I'm older. When she got closer I recognized she was with your sister (I believe it was Lucy). I then realized it was your MOM!
My memory forever ingrained, you can still look beautiful at any age.
Just want to say thank you
Tamela Millhollon OklahomaJust want to say thank you for being my saving grace through out my own childhood & suffering through my own anxieties. You've always lifted me up.
That was a wonderful article.
Cindy Hisle Southport, NCThat was a wonderful article. I have been a Carly Simon fan since I was a child. Love James Taylor, too. I would so love to go to the book signing and meet Carly. Hoping one day, she'll head south and do one. Everyone I know loves her and her music. Cannot wait to read the book!
And I'd be right beside you!
Dana Southport,NCAnd I'd be right beside you!
A huge fan from those early
Robert Thompson Cape Town South AfricaA huge fan from those early days and still feel like I can keep in touch, if only through the computer. Your earlier songs still resound in my head and as a local bass guitar player for charity only many years ago and a roady for my sister's band has always carried me through the hard times and now semi retired I can reflect on those times with joy. Take care beautiful soul.
The photos in this article
Cathie Fields Capistrano Beach, CAThe photos in this article are wonderful. I especially like the one of Carly and James at the Oak Bluffs School, with James playing a Mark Whitebook guitar -- made by my talented husband!
Can't wait to read it..
Suzanne de Cornelia Santa BarbaraCan't wait to read it...admire Carly Simon so much.
I think the Gazette should
Michael Cutler West TisburyI think the Gazette should find something a lot more interesting than another article on the Vineyard's self anointed royalty. I am not a fan of anything Simon/Taylor because I am sick and tired of hearing about them..
Please find something or someone new and more interesting
You have no taste and are
Annalee BearingtonYou have no taste and are rude.
Newspapers have to touch a
Mr. B ChilmarkNewspapers have to touch a range of audiences if they are to survive--this piece is for one of them. The column on Birds is for another. Perhaps they overlap.
Islanders shouldn't smash
Mrs. Johnson Pottersville, NJIslanders shouldn't smash islanders, not very tasteful!
I was a resident in Edgartown
Dave Hard Boulder, ColoradoI was a resident musician in Edgartown back in the 60's when there was still a wealth of good taste and decorum. Sadly, it appears that the Island's consciousness has given way to nouveau-riche impropriety.
I was born in 1961, she was
Joel Weeks Tenn.I was born in 1961, she was one of the first female musicians I had ever heard and I fell in love with her music, when I finally saw a picture of her I fell in love and started reading every thing I could find ., I thought she was so pretty, growing older and getting into harder and harder rock -'n'-roll I would still listen to her songs, and read any thing I saw with her name on it. I came to realize that the way she carried her self and acted in the spot light was the way she really was, that she wasn't just a rock-n-roll chic and I like most all the female rockers but she was a Lady ,not only that but she was nice, I don't think I ever read anything negative about anything she ever did. In the early 80's I saw her on TV doing a concert on the side of a river in a white dress, I was in love again. For the past 30 or so years I have lived in the back woods of Tenn.I only got a computer and on the internet a few months ago and found out about face book. I guess I had put her down as one of my liked musicians because a post appeared on my FB page I couldn't believe it. Being in my 50's now and living a hard life I found that nothing is what you think or thought it was including people I almost didn't look her up on FB didn't want to ruin my life long heart throb and vision I had . Weeks later getting up the nerve I looked her up boy did I get surprised . She is just as I had visioned her to be , down to earth ,nice,pretty,and evermore the lady!! Thanks Carly you were what you seemed to be!! Can't wait to read the book. I look forward to every FB post and read any thing with your name on it . No matter how bad I feel or how bad I hurt when ever I see a picture or hear your name it always brings a smile to my face and good thoughts to my mind, Thanks again!!! The ColdSteel- CowBoy
Carly my BFF from First Grade
Suzanne Hoy Southington, ConnecticutCarly my BFF from First Grade may have been your youngest hardcore fan back in the 1970s. He introduced me to your music. He grew up to be a producer on Broadway and I grew up to be a licensed Architect. I also grew into a fan of JT. I would value the opportunity to write a proposal for your Music Box Cabin in the Woods. This would be a fun project! My cousin lives on the island too.
Please check your birth dates
Pia Webster EdgartownPlease check your birth dates. When Carly was 11, James was 8 and not a teenager.
Hoping that Carly will sign
Susan & daughter Meredith North Carolina, USAHoping that Carly will sign books for those of us that cannot be there on the 20th & that we can purchase them from Bunch of Grapes on-line! ;) XO!
Bill did a wonderful piece,
Peter Simon ChilmarkBill did a wonderful piece, capturing the essence of my sister's creative force at work. Of no surprise to me (I have reading her school papers and various letters to me and others through the years) her book is brilliant. It was painful reliving some of the material about my father's fall from grace and our general family dysfunction. But Carly tells a true and very poignant story of our formative years. Her attention to detail and ability to produce some highly eccentric analogies, rarely seen before in a memoir to be knowledge. Our family is very proud of her honesty and her message of forgiveness. And to Michael Cutler....we don't think of ourselves as "Island Royalty." Humility is a big part of our bloodline. We just wish to be to part of the gloriously gifted playing field here, trying play our part in joining the community with spirit and artistic energy. All is good.
Carly, I can't be at the
Toby Condliffe Toronto, OntarioCarly, I can't be at the signing as Toronto is too far, but I wish I could be there. I remember bicycling to the Boy's School. I'd see you waiting for the bus to take you to the Girl's School, and you'd look at me in the most fetching way. I suppose you looked at all the boys that way. I also remember hearing the Simon Sisters sing. Days gone by at the Moon Cusser. What a great place that was! I've bought the audio book and look forward to hearing you read it! All good wishes. Toby
Carly....Please, please save
Mason Buddy Marblehead/VHCarly....Please, please save a book for me!! I only wish I were on The Island this time of year. Every day with happiness I look at a photo of you and James on your honeymoon...each with leis around you necks. A fan you've had in me most of my adult life....you and Edith Piaf. Loved this article.....
Always more than a fan,
Michael Portobrisia Modesto, CaliforniaAlways more than a fan, always a deep, deep appreciator and lover of your music, its emotional honesty, its lyricism, I feel you have enriched my life. I just discovered your photo on the cover on the sheet music to "Haven't Got Time for the Pain." You are too beautiful.
Add new comment