Verizon says its working to come up with a new plan.
Tim Johnson

Cell Companies Plan Improvements in Chilmark

Worried about poor cellphone reception in parts of town, Chilmark town officials are calling on cellular companies to beef up their infrastructure.

Worried about poor cellphone reception in parts of town, Chilmark town officials are calling on cellular companies to beef up their infrastructure. 

The select board held a meeting with representatives from Verizon and American Tower Company Wednesday and asked the two companies to work together to improve service.

“[We’re] asking them to circle up and take into account what they heard today and integrate public comment we had over the course of the late summer and early fall, related to service that is inadequate to meet public safety expectations, and come up with a way to bridge us to a more robust solution,” select board member Matt Poole said. 

The town received several letters from residents earlier this year outlining how the poor cell phone reception could cut off the town’s elderly population from medical help, especially as people stop using landlines. Some places throughout the up-Island community have little to no service, including sections of Middle Road, Tabor House Road and North Road. 

“It got to the point where even our EMS  and our police departments were having trouble getting what they needed,” select board member Jeffrey Maida said. “It’s beyond just the citizens not being able to get what they want. But now it becomes a safety issue when our fire and police and EMTs can’t count on it.”

The select board will hold a public hearing on Jan. 6 where Verizon will present an application to erect its own nodes, rather than use America Tower Company’s system. 

“We are currently sharing nodes on the ATC distributed antenna system, and our goal is to have our own nodes out there so we can control the network more, have more capacity and to change as technology changes,” Verizon representative Sean Conway said.  

About 15 years ago, there was a plan to install a larger macro tower in Chilmark, but the idea was rejected by the voters, leading to the more patchy antenna system where antennas are placed atop utility poles in one mile increments along town roads.

But that system is antiquated, according to American Town Company sales manager Derek Hastings.  

“When this was designed, it was a voice network primarily, and now we’re using it for data,” he said. “The network that exists today... wasn’t built to do what it’s being asked.” 

American Tower is designing a plan where it would involve only AT&T and T-Mobile, according to Mr. Hastings. Budget and zoning restrictions would still have to be ironed out. 

“What we want to do is to modernize, bring everything in the highest concentrated areas up to a common level for all carriers, and then expand as needed into certain areas again, when we have budget alignment and zoning approval,” he said. 

Verizon is itching to improve service for their customers and is ready to go as soon as they get the green light from the town. 

“We’ve been contacted by local municipalities, we’ve been contacted by the state, we’ve been contacted by all sorts of people to improve our network down here,” Mr. Conway said.  “It’s a big goal of ours. We are ready to build down here. If we got approvals, we would be ready to go, hopefully by next summer, with those new nodes.” 

Though there is no immediate interest in installing a macro tower, the select board wants to take a step forward as quickly as possible.  

“We may never reach everywhere, so to me, any improvement is improvement,” Mr. Maida said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 12/15/2025 - 15:24

Permalink

John Chilmark

A DAS/small cell system on telephone poles will never fully solve the coverage issue. Please let AT&T/FirstNet add antennas to the Peaked Hill tower. Only a macro site will provide full coverage and have the needed generator back up power in the event of a prolonged power outage.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 12/15/2025 - 17:10

Permalink

Josh Chilmark

The issue is that American Tower's end-of-life DAS equipment (deployed in 2018) requires a cost-split upgrade among the three carriers. They won't do it without the carriers paying for it. Verizon's separate plan to deploy small cells Up Island is a play by them to avoid paying rent to American Tower. So first, they all need to get on the same page and work together. American Tower is a landlord and has T-Mobile and AT&T already willing to deploy on an upgraded DAS with the cost split three ways.

Additionally, both American Tower and Verizon confirmed that neither the upgraded DAS nor the small cell network can guarantee E911 service across the area, making them significantly more expensive and less reliable than a macro tower solution.

The only reliable solution is constructing macro tower infrastructure. The Select Board needs to take these immediate steps:

1. Include a warrant at this year's Town Meeting to lift the moratorium on cell towers in Chilmark.
2. Include in the warrant that only municipal ownership of this digital infrastructure is possible so that the town maintains control and benefits from the revenue.

This infrastructure is extremely valuable, offering a potential six-figure annual revenue stream to the town while guaranteeing reliable E911 service. Voting this year to lift the moratorium on cell towers while also taking steps to own the actual infrastructure would allow carriers to allocate equipment in their 2027 budgets, potentially leading to service activation by mid-2027.

As a temporary measure, carriers must immediately coordinate a stopgap fix for the existing DAS. The best coverage option would be an upgraded DAS system and a tower, but either way it seems we're more than a year away from any of it. If the board does not add the warrant to this year's annual meeting agenda we're looking at years without E911 service.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 12/15/2025 - 18:39

Permalink

Jack A. West Tisbury

If the public wants cell service in case of an emergency, I say that makes sense. If there is a power interruption like a storm, or a car hitting a telephone pole - should cell service still work? If the answer is yes, then the town must get cell towers that can support backup generators. It is impossible to put a required generator at each node of a DAS system which makes DAS system unreliable for essential emergency communications. Remove the DAS system and join the rest of the world.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 12/16/2025 - 09:50

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

There is no reason that the entire island cannot be covered with adequate mobile service. There are excuses, but no reasons. In this day and age, not having adequate coverage is equivalent to not letting electricity be carried to residents. Everyone I know depends on mobile service, not just on this island, but everyone I know, everywhere. Get with the program, get it done. No excuses.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 12/17/2025 - 23:23

Permalink

Margot Lane Menemsha

Very relieved to hear. Esp. since the spike in tick related emergencies is spiking. This could save lives.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.