The Vineyard Wind project has been shut down indefinitely while federal regulators investigate how a 107-meter blade folded over, spilling white and green fiberglass debris into the ocean.
A Vineyard Wind turbine blade broke over the weekend, scattering debris into the Atlantic and prompting an investigation by the manufacturer and federal officials.
The offshore wind energy company, which is in the middle of constructing a 62-turbine wind farm about 14 miles south of the Vineyard, said a 107-meter blade broke on Saturday about 20 meters from the root, but was largely still attached to the turbine.
The Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement (BSEE) is investigating the incident and said Monday that operations at the wind farm are shut down until further notice.
The malfunction is a setback for the Vineyard Wind, the first approved and currently largest offshore wind energy project in the country.
The damaged turbine was not fully operational and was still undergoing testing, according to Vineyard Wind. The broken turbine scattered debris into the ocean, and cleanup crews were combing Nantucket beaches after several reports of green fiberglass washing ashore.
The cause of the breakage is still unknown and no staff or third party contractors were in the area Saturday at the time of the damage.
“As part of its permitting, Vineyard Wind has detailed plans to guide its response to incidents such as this,” said Vineyard wind spokesperson Craig Gilvarg. “Following those protocols, Vineyard Wind established a safety perimeter, and worked with the U.S. Coast Guard to issue notice to mariners.”
The Coast Guard first received reports of debris near the turbines at about 7 p.m. Saturday, and a 500-meter safety zone was established around the area.
The Vineyard Wind turbines are over 800 feet tall, with blades as long as a football field. As of last month, Vineyard Wind had 10 turbines in operation, generating about 136 megawatts of power. About a dozen more were under construction. The turbines are manufactured by GE Vernova and the company is responsible for them as they are initially installed.
In the statement Monday, Vineyard Wind said GE Vernova will also be conducting the investigation into what went wrong.
“GE, as the project’s turbine and blade manufacturer and installation contractor, will now be conducting the analysis into the root cause of the incident,” Mr. Gilvarg said.
The issue was isolated to a single turbine, according to a GE Vernova spokesperson.
Most of the debris has been recovered or is in the process of being recovered, though smaller debris remains adrift and boaters should be cautious, Coast Guard Lieut. Samantha Corcoran said.
Nantucket charter boat captain Carl Bois was in the area on Sunday and saw what appeared to be large fiberglass-like panels and bits of styrofoam floating in the water. He wasn’t sure if it was from the turbines, but the debris was floating east, the same direction as the tide and the wind, he told the Gazette.
“I’ve never seen anything on the water quite like that,” he said.
On Tuesday, Nantucket closed all of its south shore beaches due to debris that had come ashore. Vineyard Wind announced it was sending a team to pick up debris. Matching Mr. Bois’ description, the company said the pieces were non-toxic fiberglass fragments.
Vineyard Wind recommended the public leave cleanup efforts to the company, and for the next several days employees would be walking Nantucket’s beaches to collect debris.
Given the region’s current and wind direction, Vineyard Wind didn’t anticipate debris showing up on the Vineyard.
Officials with BSEE said they have a team at the wind farm working closely with Vineyard Wind to analyze what went wrong.
State officials have touted offshore wind energy as a major player in efforts to battle climate change. On Monday, the state Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs said it was briefed on the incident and the company’s safety plan.
“There is a rigorous, federally approved safety process in place and we will continue to monitor the situation closely as Vineyard Wind, GE, and the federal Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement conduct an analysis of the cause and their next steps,” said spokesperson Maria Hardiman. “We are grateful to the trained personnel who addressed the situation so quickly.”
When completed, Vineyard Wind is expected to produce 800 megawatts of power. It is one of several planned for a wide swath of ocean to the Island’s south.
The company is a partnership between Avangrid and Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners, and has an operations headquarters and marine terminal along Beach Road in Vineyard Haven.
In his statement, Mr. Gilvarg said the company is working to make sure the area is safe.
“As that analysis takes place, Vineyard Wind will continue working with federal, state, and local stakeholders to ensure the health and safety of its workforce, mariners, and the environment,” he said.

Comments
doesn't bode well
A Islanddoesn't bode well
This is the second blade
Johnny SeaviewThis is the second blade incident to hit a GE Vernova offshore turbine this year, following a failure on a Haliade-X unit at the 1.2GW Dogger Bank project off east England
And so it begins. Bottom line
JHess EdgartownAnd so it begins. Bottom line…why would this resource of energy ever be permitted in very sensitive New England Waters without 10 years of due diligence. Disappointed.
And it is just beginning. It
Wind Farm Operator Off IslandAnd it is just beginning. It happens more than people think.
Now we need to worry about
Ester ChilmarkNow we need to worry about pieces of metal striking boats or washing ashore and being stepped on. Thanks Vineyard Wind for prioritizing safety (sarcasm). Now it’s like living on the Louisiana coast.
A blade breaks and suddenly
tom BostonA blade breaks and suddenly the sky is falling in? Are there not mechanical failures at all energy producing facilities? Coal mines/plants, oil & gas facilities, nuclear plants? We aren't exactly talking Chernobyl, Benxihu Colliery or Deep Horizon here.
Wind turbines are a great
Justin C. VHWind turbines are a great source of clean energy, but they should be built farther offshore to minimize their visual and safety impacts. No one will want them anymore if they develop a bad reputation.
What an incredible eye sore
Tom P EdgartownWhat an incredible eye sore on one of the Country’s most beautiful shorelines!
Nantucket just closed all its
Neilson EdgNantucket just closed all its south shore beaches because of debris in the water. This is our future.
If we need to close our
Bill OBIf we need to close our beaches like ACK just did will Vineyard Wind compensate all of the island businesses that will loose tourism dollars? Probably not, because they don’t care about our island, they are just stripping it for resources, no better than a coal or mining company.
This is a large environmental
Ellen ChilmarkThis is a large environmental disaster. The water is now littered with fiberglass shards that will be harmful to marine wildlife and will be exceedingly difficult to remove from the beaches. We will be dealing with this for a long time.
Ellen, I agree… and why the
Carol EdgartownEllen, I agree… and why the silence on all this? Why not better communication? This is not the SSA after all!
Ellen raises a powerful point
Jose Oak BluffsEllen raises a powerful point. Will fish ingest the particulate matter? Will fish be safe to eat? What will this do to larger predators who consume fish (seals, sharks, whales, etc.)? What is the impact on industries that depend on tourism to make their year? Does anybody know? Has anyone ever asked? Also, is it coincidence that this disaster occurred 1 day after a large storm? Are these contraptions sufficiently stress tested for Nor'easters or hurricanes? What type of wind event makes them prone to damage? And if winds are picking up in intensity, will they be strong enough to handle the larger wind events that will be coming in future years?
Peter Pfluger, VINEYARD HAVEN
Peter Pfluger VINEYARD HAVENPeter Pfluger, VINEYARD HAVEN
In all fairness, the picture of the windmills at the top of this article is taken with a telescopic lens from land, which is sensational, but gives a false sense of their actual visibility, which adds unnecessary fuel to the falsehood that the windmills are highly visible from land. Please post two more pictures of the windmills taken from land within the same minute, one with the same telescopic lens with the same magnification used for the picture used in this article and the other with NO magnification at all. Please post these pictures next to each other. You will barely be abler to see the windmills in the picture with no magnification, and if the day is not perfectly clear, you will not be able to see them at all.
July 17, 2024 - 10:06am
Come up island and see for
Mike B UpislandCome up island and see for your self! They are highly visible with the naked eye and the plan is to build more and bigger ones closer to Gay Head. The jobs are in New Bedford, Denmark, and Spain. The power goes ashore in mainland MA and NY. The island has a damaged view shed and damaged marine/avian life…..absolutely no local benefit except blinking lights at night if that is your thing. This was railroaded through with the promise that they would not be visible and no one consulted the tribe. Someone pulled a fast one on the island and there should be an investigation into how this happened.
Can’t see’em from my house
Goodrogering HereCan’t see’em from my house
Looking @ the Nantucket
Gina Menemsha/NYCLooking @ the Nantucket lifeguards cleaning up the hazardous windmill mess doesn’t instill any confidence in VW promise of prompt response They got their priorities & could care less for safety
If the rest of the damaged
Arnold EdgartownIf the rest of the damaged blade falls and the winds shift the debris will be all over our shores too. We have a tourism based economy that relies on two months out of the year. If our beaches are closed we need to seek significant compensation from Vineyard Wind and their failed experiment in the ocean.
Add new comment