South Beach in Edgartown has been hit hard this winter by a trio of storms.
Ray Ewing

Island Towns Step Up Planning to Restore Beaches

The state Department of Environmental Protection Monday granted Edgartown emergency authorization to dredge Katama Bay, clearing the way for a project intended to help restore the storm-battered South Beach.

After three strong storms washed away chunks of the Vineyard’s coastline this winter, Island towns are looking to make emergency repairs ahead of the summer tourist season. 

The state Department of Environmental Protection Monday granted Edgartown emergency authorization to dredge Katama Bay, clearing the way for a project intended to restore the storm-battered South Beach. 

In a meeting with town officials in early January, the select board declared a local state of emergency after the Island was hit with the winter blasts. The declaration was made in part to secure time-sensitive state and federal funding. 

The town estimated that the winter storms have caused upwards of $1.7 million in damages, and officials submitted an application to the state emergency management agency to receive aid. 

The Chilmark conservation commission Thursday approved emergency work at the Squibnocket parking lot.
Ray Ewing
The Chilmark conservation commission Thursday approved emergency work at the Squibnocket parking lot.
Ray Ewing

Up-Island towns are also now considering work to help with erosion. Chilmark got permission from the town’s conservation commission Thursday to shore up the edge of the parking lot near Squibnocket Beach after the storms ate away at the dunes. 

The asphalt at the edge of the lot now freely hangs over the sand and there is a steep dropoff. The town asked for an emergency certification to do the repairs, which include filling in under the road surface to replicate the stone and other materials that are used around the rest of the cul de sac. 

“This year, there’s going to be a considerable step down,” said Chris Murphy, a member of the Chilmark conservation commission. “That’s just the nature of it . . . . When you deal with the ocean, it’s always changing.” 

The commission also asked that the town consider a long-term managed retreat plan for Squibnocket. 

Chilmark also received permission from the DEP to dredge the Menemsha Basin, and the sand could potentially be used to beef up Menemsha Beach or Squibnocket. In the past, sand from Menemsha Beach blew over into the basin, making navigation difficult for boaters. 

The town would dredge the sand and bring it back to the beach. More dune grass planting has taken place recently in an attempt to slow the shifting sands. 

“We’re trying to stabilize the [Menemsha Beach] dune so it’s not happening so much,” Mr. Murphy said. 

Aquinnah has also raised the potential of getting involved in dredging. On Tuesday, town administrator Jeff Madison told the select board he was concerned about West Basin after the recent storms. 

Aquinnah conservation commission chair Sarah Thulin said the town could potentially work out a deal with Chilmark, offering them a good deal on the sand in exchange for help with the dredge.

In the meantime, Mr. Madison said he will look into an emergency authorization similar to the one Edgartown received this week, so Aquinnah could begin a solo project if necessary.

“I want to do this right so we’re on solid ground, so to speak,” Mr. Madison said.

Emergency work on the Island isn’t expected to be cheap.

The first phase of the Edgartown South Beach nourishment work alone is estimated at about $709,000.

The town is still waiting on the full response from MEMA that would facilitate the rest of its restoration efforts. Town officials estimated the cost to replace the area’s lifeguard facilities, now sitting precariously on the beach, at about $400,000. Repairs to Atlantic Drive, the main point of access to South Beach, are expected to cost $21,685.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/30/2024 - 08:18

Permalink

Danny East Chop

They should really be focused on putting that sand offshore about 200 yards, create a deep water sandbar that will break waves before they reach the beach. The problem isn’t a lack of sand, it’s the steepness of the beach that creates a constant backwash which is removing all the sediment. An outer reef / sand bar would promote a flatter beach front and prevent the seasons strongest storms from running full speed into the island.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/30/2024 - 12:04

Permalink

Roddy Seasonal Visitor

I understand this is really only about the ability to continue to attract the seasonal tourist dollars as long as possible, and I get it, but the bigger picture we should all keep in mind is that these efforts will only achieve very temporary results, since continuing to do the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is the definition of insanity. Mother nature eventually wins every battle.

Islander Edgartown

I agree, Roddy. As an islander, it is dispiriting to see the emphasis placed upon timing as part of a tourism problem, completely weird, in fact...let's hope they do the job right, rather than rushed and with mistakes.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/30/2024 - 12:20

Permalink

Beach Walker Edgartown

$400,000 for a lifeguard shack that gets used for 10 weeks a year. Ridiculous. 1.7 million to build dunes that easily can get wiped out in 1 storm. You should get you heads examined .

Edgartown Resident

If you paid attention to the town meetings, the lifeguard shack is used year round now because they have year round employees maintaining the beaches and parks. Name me another place that they can store all their tools vehicles and equipment to operate year round. 400,000 is the reality of trying to put any structure anywhere in this day and age, everyone wants to beaches taken care of but doesnt factor in where all that equipment has to live.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/30/2024 - 16:28

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

What will take weeks to dredge out of the ponds and spread over the beach can be removed in one overnight storm. If you put the horse where it should be in front of the cart and say dredging the pond is our prerogative and necessary I agree dredge away.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/30/2024 - 16:31

Permalink

Trudy Edgartown

Thank you Edgartown for helping to restore our beautiful beach.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/30/2024 - 23:14

Permalink

Colonel Martha's Vineyard

I remember as a child walking 200 yd before I hit the water's edge now it's 25 feet. Dredging sand a temporary fix. Next couple of noreasters will remove all the sand dredged. Earlier comment called for a sandbar to be constructed offshore. I agree but a sandbar is also temporary. What is needed is an artificial reef. How? Take a bunch of junked auto's clean them up for pollutants and place them out there as an artificial reef To act as a barrier to the storm surges caused by the noreasters. Mark the location with buoys so boats are aware. Our beaches need to be rebuilt as they are an important and critical asset for the tourist economy. Building an artificial reef would be a permanent solution. And if someone were to run the numbers would have a positive ROI. This project calls for dredging and building an artificial reef.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/31/2024 - 05:38

Permalink

Sara Piazza Edgartown

Before one grain of sand is relocated, take a look at Squibnocket Beach. The idea that man can rebuild South Beach is ludicrous.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/31/2024 - 08:19

Permalink

Michele Dunn Edgartown

Why not get the army corps of engineers in to assess the root cause and all possible long term solutions?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/02/2024 - 08:01

Permalink

Sandy South Beach

It’s great that this immediate action is being taken with the help of state and federal $. Thanks to those involved. Longer term an analysis of broader possible approaches is called for. Some New Jersey beaches for instance installed steel under the new sand as just one example.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/02/2024 - 22:22

Permalink

Beach Walker Edgr

I have read all of the comments, and it’s as if I live on a different planet. A sand bar made of used cars 200 yards off shore in 80 feet of water for 10 long miles . So you want to put tens of thousands of junk cars in the ocean ? ? Are you making fun or just plain stupid.

Sara Piazza Edgartown

Not to mention, it will create an inviting, but dangerous, surf break. Imagine wiping out and getting tangled in an old rusty car.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.