Superintendent Richard (Richie) Smith spoke sternly to school committee members this week, wishing he was given a head’s up about the motion at West Tisbury town meeting that led to voters rejecting the high school budget.
Island superintendent of schools Richard (Richie) Smith spoke sternly to school committee members this week, wishing he was given a head’s up about Jeffrey (Skipper) Manter’s motion at West Tisbury town meeting that led to voters rejecting the regional high school budget.
Mr. Manter, a member of the West Tisbury select board and the up-Island school committee, made the motion at Tuesday’s town meeting to zero-fund West Tisbury’s $3.4 million share of the high school budget. Voters then approved the motion, saying it was in protest of the school's ongoing litigation over an artificial turf field.
At the up-Island school committee meeting Thursday, Mr. Smith said he was blindsided by Mr. Manter’s motion.
“I was not aware of what the motion was that you were going to bring up,” Mr. Smith said to Mr. Manter. “Pushback, I expected. This was an entire motion, made by my colleague, someone that I work closely with, and I didn’t know that.”
In the future, Mr. Smith asked that he’d be given a head’s up, and made it clear that his displeasure was with the lack of notice, not the budget vote itself.
“The town has spoken, and clearly I’ve heard it,” he said.
“I respect and actually understand [that] when a group of folks feels like they’re not heard, they’re going to take matters into their own hands in ways like we saw Tuesday night,” Mr. Smith added.
Mr. Manter’s motion and the nearly-unanimous vote against the budget are both evidence that the school district needs better collaboration among its members, according to the superintendent.
“There’s a need for us to lean in together and work together,” Mr. Smith said. “When a full town speaks out, it is time for us to look at what the issue is and it is time to work together.”
As superintendent of schools, Mr. Smith is the chief executive officer for all six Island districts and reports to their six school committees.
Formerly the assistant superintendent, Mr. Smith is nearly halfway through a two-year appointment to complete the contract term of former superintendent Matthew D’Andrea, who is now running the Wareham school system.
Mr. Smith made his remarks to the up-Island committee Thursday because the all-Island committee was unable to muster a quorum for its monthly meeting the night before.
Quorum issues also came up at the up-Island meeting. Members expressed their ire at the failure of some all-Island members to even respond to a pre-meeting quorum check.
“I am damn angry,” board member Robert Lionette said, while Alex Salop suggested that some all-Island members are single-issue voters.
Burnout could also be a factor: Longtime school district recorder Marni Lipke said Thursday that committee meetings have proliferated over the years.
“The meetings have multiplied exponentially,” Ms. Lipke said. “I would say you need to drastically cut back.”
All six districts have monthly committee meetings, with delegates from the Edgartown, Oak Bluffs, Tisbury and up-Island committees also serving on the high school and up-Island committees.
Additionally, the high school committee has several subcommittees that meet to discuss land use, transportation, athletic needs and the budget.
On Thursday, Mr. Smith recommended reviewing the number, length and start time of the meetings to see if the burden on committee members and district employees can be eased.
Also Thursday, Chilmark Preschool board member Alicia Knight thanked the school committee and Chilmark School principal Susan Stevens for agreeing to rearrange classrooms so that the preschool can continue sharing space with the town school for another two years.
The preschool hopes to build a new facility on the town campus that’s also home to the Chilmark Community Center, but hasn’t identified a site, Ms. Knight said.

Comments
Blind sided. Really. All
Tom Engley. WestTisburyBlind sided. Really. All those catch phrases. Lean in on this. Get your act together.
Did Mr Smith give Mr Manter
R Scott Patterson EdgartownDid Mr Smith give Mr Manter and the voters a “heads up” that he was planning to waste taxpayer funds continuing to fight for a toxic field that the majority here don’t want?
Drop the lawsuit, plan and
Voter OBDrop the lawsuit, plan and simple, Richie.
Beautiful, quite proud of
George Stein OBBeautiful, quite proud of that vote. Tremendous unity needs the call to action be served.
School commitee members
Taxpayer MVSchool commitee members refusing to attend meetings that have consequences on programming for our islands most venerable children .
This is unacceptable. Protest and VOTE THEM OUT.
I also wish there was a heads
Zack EdgartownI also wish there was a heads up... so Edgartown could have taken the same vote. Stop trying to poison the island for an expensive football field that causes more injuries than grass fields. As a place of education, the school should have been embarrassed by their mistake, instead they doubled down and want to fight it in court. Their actions are a total disregard for the island and it's people... but they expect more respect from their critics. Stopping your attempt to poison the island is the first step in getting respect.
I thought John Steven’s was
Tom Engley West TisburyI thought John Steven’s was helping with some of these issues. He’s a smart guy I would like his opinion on what’s going on.
Richie, I’d respect you if
Susan Desmarais Oak BluffsRichie, I’d respect you if you showed a bit of similar outrage when I was verbally assaulted on zoom during the Oak Bluffs planning board meeting last year. Instead you made excuses for the perpetrator and asked forgiveness on his behalf. Now that was blindsiding.
I'm curious if away games are
RC OB,DCI'm curious if away games are played on synthetic turf? If they are so toxic and dangerous as described, should the games be forfeited? I also think any college tours should exclude any school with synthetic turf.
I have often thought the same
Tisbury Resident VINEYARD HAVENI have often thought the same thing as RC. How far do people go with their beliefs. Will they stop their children from playing high school sports if the other teams have turf fields or is it just NIMBY kind of thinking. There was once a huge debate and battle over the roundabout. Look it up, I did, it's in the papers. West Tisbury wanted to sue the MVC because they voted 7-6 in favor of the roundabout. by the way, that vote was a closer vote than that of the turf. West Tisbury had no problem being willing to sue itself, or all of us for that matter, because as I see it, we all pay into the MVC budget. 2011-2013 years respective. I find it interesting the outcry about legal matters. It's somewhat hypocritical of some folks. the legal system is there to be used to settle disputes, ideas, land use..... the Dover Amendment needs to play itself out or it will be back to haunt us.
There are way too many moving
Tom Engley West TisburyThere are way too many moving parts too many committees consolidate regionalize start now. Don’t wait Burn out yes single vote members yes. Town meetings are also showing strains. Not enough people interested. Other towns have board members voted in to position. Pay them let them run thing while the rest of us work to pay to live here.
Is it just me or is our
John Aldeborgh KatamaIs it just me or is our ability to make decisions and focus on the education of our children inversely proportional to the number of administrators involved in decision making and management process. The one glaringly obvious fact is that the towns people are very unhappy and frustrated with how the school system is being managed, the outcome seems to be poor. How many layers of bureaucracy and how many administrators are truly needed to run a relatively tiny island school system. Somehow the children are getting lost in all this non-value added bickering and frankly nonsense.
I’ve written two different
Islander61 OBI’ve written two different comments on this article and neither has been printed. I certainly hope the Gazette isn’t editing the comments that both support Dr. Smith and the turf field, although it certainly seems that way. Dr. Smith supports all students, and in this case, student-athletes. It’s been demonstrated clearly that the athletes, coaches, and athletic administration support the turf field. There hasn’t been any evidence, none, that shows that the turf field being proposed will harm the environment, injure athletes, can’t be recycled, will be costly to maintain, or any other argument that has been thrown at the school. The school plan is well thought out and has tried to compromise but the opposition won’t compromise even though they can’t prove any of their claims. Dr. Smith should be upset, Skipper Manter was out of line with his actions. To use student funding as a pawn in this matter because you don’t agree with what your committee has voted on is outright wrong. The school has a legitimate reason to appeal the planning board decision, so let the judge decide.
I have no skin in this debate
JT EdgartownI have no skin in this debate. I think we need to move on. I will say this one thing. There are far so many more important thing to be concerned about. Inflation, the cost of living. My God I wish the same folks would talk about that. Who cares if we have grass or synthetic??
JT, I could not agree more!
Gail EdgartownJT, I could not agree more! Let’s move on for the kids! A few parents on both sides causing chaos. I understand folks get involved but this is crazy.
Also, I agree people should be concerned about real issues. Inflation price of goods food etc…
Add new comment