MassDOT is designing a $1.7 million project to help deal with flooding in Tisbury.
Timothy Johnson

MassDOT Unveils “Band-Aid” Plan for Tisbury Flooding

State transportation officials presented a $1.7 million project Monday to deal with flooding in Tisbury.

A lasting solution to flooding at Vineyard Haven’s infamous Five Corners remains a distant prospect, with state engineers this week unveiling a stopgap plan to divert and trap some stormwater further upstream from the chronically swamped intersection.

In an online presentation to about three dozen people Monday night, state Department of Transportation officials outlined plans to install a 150,000-gallon underground infiltration system uphill from the intersection. The drainage system is planned to go beneath the town parking lot at 21 Beach street, where the downtown fire station was demolished nearly a decade ago.

Though the project is estimated at $1.7 million, Five Corners will still require a future project of its own to deal with the flooding, said MassDOT project manager Hung Pham.

“This really is a Band-Aid approach,” Mr. Pham said.

The state’s design has a series of plastic tanks, nestled in crushed stone below the lot’s paved surface, where stormwater will be filtered and then allowed to seep naturally into the sandy soil. Additional catch basins and pipes will redirect stormwater from Causeway Road to the Beach street lot, according to the plan.

The estimated $1.7 million cost of the project, expected to begin in 2024, will be shared by the state and the Federal Highway Administration, Mr. Pham said.

The entire system can filter and slowly release the equivalent of six inches of rain on an acre of land, said MassDOT engineer Lindsey DiTonno. It’s the largest installation the Beach street property can hold, she said, and should alleviate some Five Corners flooding in stormy weather.

But heavier rainfalls are likely to bring more stormwater than the system can filter, Ms DiTonno said.

Keeping the critical five-way intersection dry in all conditions will require more study for a future project, according to the DOT staffers, who detailed the site’s complications.

“Dense development and the creation of impervious surfaces over time has been a contributing factor to the increased rate and volume of storm runoff that enters the harbor through the existing drainage system…Water is really being forced toward the Five Corners,” Mr. Pham said.

That includes runoff from neighboring properties that should be taking responsibility for their own stormwater, according to Ms. DiTonno.

“It’s really shocking how many private properties are draining into this without treating [runoff] on their own,” she said.

While quick to flood, Five Corners is painfully slow to drain. An outfall pipe leading down Beach street extension to the harbor is regularly clogged by shifting sand, while the low-lying intersection doesn’t provide enough slope for the pipe to push stormwater against incoming tides, Mr. Pham said.

But simply extending the outfall pipe far enough into the water to both avoid tidal silting and achieve a positive flow from land to sea would jeopardize boater safety in the busy harbor, he said.

The state is planning a separate study on Five Corners drainage and recently issued a request for proposals from specialist firms to tackle the problem.

One possible solution, according to Tisbury town officials, may lie in reviving state licenses previously issued to the town to develop a drainage corridor along Lagoon Pond Road.

Town officials and residents at Monday’s presentation lodged no objections to the Beach street project, which Mr. Pham said he will bring back for further review once it goes through additional design work.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/01/2023 - 19:52

Permalink

Richard Knabel WEst Tisbury

If gravity can’t relieve flooding at Five Corners, then maybe a pump can help. A force main along Beach Road Ext. to the harbor, or along Lagoon Pond Road to the Lagoon could work. Or pump it to an infiltration basin somewhere with filtration capability. While nothing is ever easy on MV, this problem affects the whole Island, and band-aids aren’t enough when you need a tourniquet.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/01/2023 - 23:32

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

The corner past the hospital entrance going into OB has been fixed twice still it’s overwhelmed by a heavy rain. The electric VTA buses have a problem running into deep water the 5 corners issue is age old hurricane Bob 4 ft of water. Tough one the solution is not going to work and waste 1.7 million. Why not get creative and ask a top college with a hydraulic engineering program to give us a solution. Too many things happen at five corners. The boat the traffic the flooding the lack of proper lighting dangerous. Avoid 5 corners.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 02/02/2023 - 06:19

Permalink

Frank Brunelle Beqh Roqe

Five Corners does not usually flood in the summertime. But off-season it is a real problem. According to this article there is an issue with interfering with marine use and they want to not interfere. It would be more work and expense but I would ask Mass DOT if it would be possible to extend the pipe out - perhaps using a lightweight system, and remove it seasonally. It could theoretically slide into the outlet with a smaller diameter, and clamp on and be removed prior to boating season. Not a perfect solution, but they could evaluate what dates are important to drain and see if it would make sense.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 02/02/2023 - 10:11

Permalink

George Stein OB

How did reconstruction of Beach Rd ignore this ? Holding tank is more important than music festival that makes no money. Anyone need another lawn chair ?

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.