Proposed rending of Navigator Homes development.

Edgartown Planning Board Reviews Navigator Homes Project

The Edgartown Planning Board weighed in on proposed Navigator Homes skilled nursing and workforce housing facility this week, seeking to address both town concerns and those of abutters.

The Edgartown Planning Board weighed in on the proposed Navigator Homes skilled nursing and workforce housing facility this week, seeking to address both town concerns and those of abutters.

The project was approved by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission in November, and aims to resolve Martha’s Vineyard Hospital’s needs for skilled nursing residences, patient care space and workforce housing.

The planning board is the last Island regulatory body to address the project before proponents seek state approvals. In its sixth public hearing with the board Tuesday, Navigator Homes officials sought to address septic concerns from the town as well as traffic, noise and lighting issues raised by abutters.

Upon its approval, the MVC conditioned that the project would need to install 14 nitrogen-mitigating septic systems on neighboring properties to offset its nitrogen loading impact. Navigator Homes spokesman Ed Pesce countered that the Edgartown board of health found only eight systems would be necessary at first, but the organization would continue to monitor nitrogen levels in the first year to determine needs.

“I would try to condition at least 10,” board member Scott Morgan responded. “The other option is to lessen your footprint, but I know you don’t want to do that, either.”

Mr. Pesce was confident that eight systems, all of which have received grant funding, would be sufficient to offset nitrogen levels.

“I expect that when the dust settles...we’ll be mitigating an excess of the nitrogen required to be mitigated by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission’s condition,” he said.

As a hospital facility, the project is required to provide generators for each building with the capability to provide four days’ worth of electrical power. The diesel-powered generators would sit in covered sheds on the edge of the property, where they would occasionally need to be run to ensure proper functioning.

Chair Lucy Morrison requested details on the proposed generators and regular decibel readings to control noise. At the time of the hearing, no construction schedule had been finalized, so the board could not weigh in on summer construction regulations. Although planning board bylaws prohibit exterior work in the summer due to noise and traffic concerns, the board has the power to grant exceptions.

Project attorney Geoghan Coogan hoped to waive that restriction.

“I think it’s in everyone’s best interest to get the project going and get it done,” he said.

During public comment, abutters on Teaberry Lane and Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Road broached concerns ranging from lighting design to noise to traffic. Teaberry Lane resident Rob Lanelli objected to the size of the project, which would provide 48 workforce housing units and 66 patient beds on a 28-acre forested plot.

“I know there’s a need but truthfully the location is problematic,” Mr. Lanelli said, adding that he and his wife had just done major renovation work on their house. “We’re fearful that our property value...it’s probably gonna go down.”

Juliet Mulinare said she had already observed frequent speeding in that the area of Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Road and worried that the project would increase traffic in the neighborhood. Mr. Pesce replied that the MVC had already approved the project’s traffic plan, finding no significant increases in traffic or congestion.

Paddy Moore, a longtime senior care advocate and proponent of Navigator Homes, spoke in favor of the project.

“The residents will not be driving as you are well aware,” she said, referring to the fact that many of the senior care residents legally would not be able to operate a motor vehicle.

“What we are trying to do is keep the community of the Vineyard a community,” Ms. Moore said. “I think we all care about that, every one of us, no matter how we individually feel...We hope very much you approve these plans and let us get started.”

The public hearing will be continued on Feb. 7.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/26/2023 - 09:12

Permalink

Peter Edgartown

I am not impacted by this project, but it’s time to think about the nitrogen effect on this area?
This is a huge project and in a residential area…

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/26/2023 - 11:39

Permalink

Gail Edgartown

This project appears to be very large in scale… and I would think this would have a major impact on the nitrogen ? One day I hear we need to cut back on the development because of the nitrogen, next we are building developments all over the Island?
Confused?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/26/2023 - 12:42

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

My contacts in the field of wastewater treatment have assured me that this project needs its own treatment plant, and that it should have a septic system, no matter how modern and updated.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/26/2023 - 13:22

Permalink

gina Menemsha/NYC

Per the Navigator Homes web site they file as a Non Profit which means the entire project will NOT be paying any taxes to Edgartown .. even though the schools will be effected as other town support services. .. Quite a large complex Am I correct in that assumption ??

Mike Somewhere

Gina,
Non profits do not pay taxes to the towns they do business in.
So many non profits acquiring land for Nobel purposes means the tax burden falls on the remaining town residents. Not at all fair.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 01/28/2023 - 20:36

Permalink

Johanna H

How many acres of forest have been cleared across the island for development since 2020? Just Curious.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.