Heavy construction equipment parked at county-owned beach prompted complaint from family that donated property.
Mark Alan Lovewell

County Criticized for Condition of Eastville Beach

Eastville Point Beach came into the spotlight this week after a member of the Island family that donated the beach for public use many years ago criticized the way it is being managed.

Eastville Point Beach, the scenic public beach overlooking the outer Vineyard Haven Harbor on the Oak Bluffs side of the drawbridge, came into the spotlight this week after a member of the Island family that donated the beach for public use many years ago criticized the way it is being managed.

“Abandoned and forgotten is a description that suits it well over the last 20 years,” wrote Leo Convery in a letter to the county and the town of Oak Bluffs that appears on the editorial page in today’s edition.

Mr. Convery is a longtime Edgartown businessman, now retired at age 89. He and his sisters donated the five-acre parcel to the town of Oak Bluffs in 1977 after their parents, Leo Convery Sr. and Irene Convery, had died.

Formerly the site of the Mary Guerin Inn in the 1960s, the property extends along the jetty that divides Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs and juts into the harbor. Easily accessible from the road, the beach is used by fishermen and sunset-watchers, among other uses. But in his letter to the town and county, Mr. Convery said the parking lot for the beach had been neglected and become full of potholes. And he said the county was allowing part of the property to be used for the storage of heavy equipment.

“It is an extremely valuable piece of beach real estate. This spring it resembled an abandoned industrial park,” Mr. Convery wrote.

He slightly revised the letter since it was first written to acknowledge the fact that county manager Martina Thornton had apologized and said steps would be taken to correct the problems. Speaking to the Gazette by phone, Ms. Thornton admitted that the county had been allowing Lawrence Lynch contractors to store equipment being used for the Beach Road repaving project.

Five-acre parcel was donated for public use by the Convery family in 1977.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Five-acre parcel was donated for public use by the Convery family in 1977.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Ms. Thornton said the contractor plans to leave the site by June 23. She added that the county was unaware that there were deed restrictions on the property until Mr. Convery raised the matter in his letter.

“I did not know . . . this was not proper use of the property,” Ms. Thornton said.

But Mr. Convery’s complaints go beyond use of the beach as a storage site. He said the property has received little to no attention or maintenance over the years.

“There obviously hasn’t been anyone doing anything,” he said. Among other things, he noted that a plaque placed on a rock at the beach entrance has become overgrown with vegetation. And he described the condition of the parking lot as poor.

“You could probably swim in the potholes — you don’t have to go to the beach,” Mr. Convery quipped.

Ownership and management of the property has changed slightly over the years. The initial donation by the Convery family in 1977 was to the Vineyard Conservation Society. In 1982, ownership of most of the property was transferred to the county, according to Ms. Thornton.

Today the property is divided into parcels owned by three different government entities. Assessors maps show that Oak Bluffs owns the beach parking lot and the beach directly fronting it, while the town of Tisbury owns a small sliver on the west end of the property.

Property is divided into parcels owned by three different government entities.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Property is divided into parcels owned by three different government entities.
Mark Alan Lovewell

The issue was discussed briefly at a meeting of the county commission Wednesday night.

Commissioner Tristan Israel said he had been concerned about the state of the beach for some time.

“It’s just frustrating to me . . . it’s all kind of out of sight out of mind,” Mr. Israel said.

Commissioner Peter Wharton made a motion to issue an apology to the Convery family that was never voted on. But there was a general sense of regret among commissioners over the state of the beach.

“I think we owe the Convery family and apology,” Mr. Wharton said.

The commission plans to discuss the matter with Mr. Convery at a meeting scheduled for July 6.

Mr. Convery said he was happy that his letter had prompted a response.

“That’s what I’m trying to do . . . is get people to call the county and call the Oak Bluffs selectmen,” he said.

Ms. Thornton said she hoped it would mark the start of a new conversation that could lead to better maintenance and beautification of the beach.

“It’s a unique site and it’s being used by a lot of people,” she said.

In his letter, Mr. Convery outlined a single goal.

“Let’s make the beach viable and useable for the people of the Vineyard, as intended,” he wrote.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 06/16/2022 - 18:38

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

Thank You to the Convery family for such a generous gift. And shame on the entities that control or not control these gems. It’s an amazing spot people love to swim there clean outer harbor water.
Mr Israel if wondered about it why didn’t you do anything. Last year I was really shocked at how run down and over grown the VH side of the bridge park was I called Larry Gomez and the next day it was 90% cleaned up and completed the next day. So if you see something say some thing.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 06/16/2022 - 23:51

Permalink

Schools Out Tisbury

My own frustration with Tristan goes back decades during his tenure as a selectman in our town. It's one thing for him to say he's frustrated. It's better if he'd actually do something about this. He's a county commissioner, I'm not. Let's see this commission do its job.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/17/2022 - 06:48

Permalink

Joe Oak Bluffs

I didn't know this history of the beach. Thanks to the Convery family. Additionally, isn't Eastville beach the site where Mooncussers tried to lure ships in? If so, doesn't that add a neat piece of history to this beach? Let the public know what we can do to help clean up this special historic beach.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/17/2022 - 08:50

Permalink

Vasha Brunelle Vineyard Haven

Thank you to the Convery family for one of the lovliest sites in the County, and so convenient for busy folks in VH and OB. In addition, this year there is a piping plover family(three chicks not yet fledged so please be careful out there), an oyster catcher pair attempting to nest, and a flock of least terns.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/17/2022 - 10:28

Permalink

Janie flanders Edgartown

Thank you to the family for the donation and for the courage to speak up.
I’m unfamiliar with their story but would like to say that this is the very reason many island families state that that stopped donating land.

Listen to the land donated up island alone in the desire to make areas public - and how the donations of intended use or to establish an area for agriculture use is often forgotten.

I’m stuck by the comments that people in office didn’t understand the deed restrictions.

A reporter or anyone could easily find land donations given for many reasons (including restitution for land received to people historically in ways that oppressed other people.

People without money but having inherited land have also given land for “community use” and “preservation “ to have new residents move in and (for example) order the death of all chickens in their neighborhood.

Affordable land; housing; access - that is dependent on donations or otherwise needs to have leaders enforce deeds and intentions if they still want future land donations.

Just an opinion. And mine alone.

Jeanne VH

I agree. I am disappointed to read the comment by Ms Thornton that she was unaware of the deed restrictions. We elect these officials to do a job and part of the job is to know these things. I do hope this doesn’t deter anyone from donating land.

With the way the island housing is and the prices things have gone to, we can not afford to have these properties unattended to. It is important to respect people and their generousity. They are watching.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/17/2022 - 18:47

Permalink

Amy Edgartown

Bravo Convery family! THANK YOU for your generosity and for the confidence to speak up to ensure that this incredible gift be appropriately managed. I believe your generation was one of the last to truly appreciate this wonderful island. We can only hope that your resolve to stand up for the proper conservation trickles down to the next generations. For the record, as an employee at the hospital, I frequently take my lunch break here, in the off season of course. I will think of your family name now with gratitude

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/17/2022 - 21:16

Permalink

Danny East Chop

Agree. Beautiful spot.
Speaking of beautiful spots, whatever happened to that Squibnocket Pond spot land bank secured? Wasn’t that suppose to be made public over a year ago? That is the crown jewel of their (our) portfolio, yet access remains restricted.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/17/2022 - 22:51

Permalink

TRIP BARNES VH

I DELIVERD CO-OP DAIRY MILK TO THE MARY GUERIN INN IN 1958 &59.ONE HELL OF A GIFT FROM THE CONVERY FAMILY,,JOE THE MOON CUSSERS TURNED OFF LIGHTHOUSES AT GAY HEAD AND EDGARTOWN TO BRING SHIPS ONTO ROCKS AND THE BEACH FOR LOOTING...READ UP ON THE"BLUE ROCK OF CHAPPAQUIDDICK"ALSO THOSE NASTY ENGLISHMEN WHO TOOK BOATLOADS OF OUR SHEEP TOFEED THEIR ARMY LOST A SHIP OR TWO.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 06/18/2022 - 06:34

Permalink

Mike Bradley Durham, North Carolina

During our annual trips to the Vineyard, my wife and I would visit this gem of a location several times. We often wondered why such a beautiful and interesting beach always seemed to be in disrepair. It is great to hear the background of the property as well as plans for it to receive some TLC.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 06/19/2022 - 22:20

Permalink

Kitty OB

I can appreciate why Ernie Boch, Jr. is keeping his park in VH under his control. No doubt with years passing his park would deteriorate, too, if the town had control of it.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/21/2022 - 19:12

Permalink

James PI3 Edgartown/New Haven

I couldn't imagine how frustrating that would be if I donated that beautiful property. What a disgrace.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.