Unweathered white cedar shingles and open doors beckoned customers inside the rebuilt Larsen’s Fish Market Saturday morning, when the market reopened after a winter-long construction project.
Unweathered white cedar shingles and open doors beckoned customers inside the rebuilt Larsen’s Fish Market Saturday morning, when the market reopened after a winter-long construction project.
Sitting on a bench overlooking a calm Menemsha harbor, owner Betsy Larsen said it was good to be back after the old market was torn down and replaced with a new one over the winter.
“We’ve had a great outpouring so far this morning. A lot of loyal customers that really missed us, and I missed them,” said Ms. Larsen, who wore her trademark Larsen’s hat, shirt and knee-high boots. “I even had customers offering to help — they said they’d come down to stock shelves or if I needed to move anything, so that made me feel good.”
It was a local Vineyard scene.
Roy Scheffer delivered his Edgartown oysters. Kib Bramhall, a West Tisbury artist and fisherman, was one of the first customers.
Lobster pot chandeliers hung from the ceiling.
Ms. Larsen’s husband, Bob Sloane, had gone out in his new boat named Twilight, hauled two lobster pots outside the harbor and brought back three lobsters and a crab to give to his wife for good luck.
The Dutcher Dock fish market will be open from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m. seven days a week, Ms. Larsen said. The market has been a Menemsha staple since Betsy’s parents Louis and Mary first opened in 1969. Ms. Larsen has worked in the family business since 1974, and said she was anxious to get back to it.
“I had my first Memorial Day weekend off in over 40 years and I didn’t like it,” she said.
The reopening follows the eight-month long construction project. The old market, which was built in 1998, was knocked down to make way for a more efficient, modern space. The architect for the project was Schiller Projects of New York city (principal Aaron Schiller is also a Chilmark resident). Brian Smith was the general contractor.
“I had a wonderful architect, a really good general contractor and all of his crew that worked for him worked really hard,” Ms. Larsen said.
The construction project had its hiccups despite the solid team, Ms. Larsen said. Permitting took time and global supply chain woes meant getting materials to the Island was tricky.
“The usual things that happen,” Ms. Larsen said.
Ms. Larsen said she is pleased with the final product. The new design features more room for customers to move about, taller ceilings and a relocated raw bar so people can see their clams and oysters being opened. The display case — which houses fresh catches like sea scallops, tuna, shrimp and striped bass — is the only thing which hasn’t moved.
“We opened up the space and heightened the ceiling and that makes it feel so much bigger,” she said.
Customers seemed to like it too, as many gave Ms. Larsen their stamp of approval.
“Betsy, I love the lights,” one said.
“Aren’t they pretty? At nighttime they look really great,” Ms. Larsen responded.
But she said she is still getting acclimated to the new digs.
“This morning I was like a fish out of water. I wasn’t sure where to put stuff or where stuff was and my muscle memory kept going back to places that I was used to having it in the old fish market,” she said.
“I imagine as every day goes by it’ll just get easier, I’ll get used to it.”
One of Ms. Larsen’s young employees came to work and announced she had one hour’s sleep.
“Gosh, I went to bed at 8 p.m.,” Ms. Larsen responded.
Bert Fischer contributed reporting.

Comments
We love you Betsy!
AnonymousWe love you Betsy!
So happy for you! It looks
Cathy KeohaneSo happy for you! It looks awesome. Can't wait to check it out!
The new market loops amazing!
Grolly Chilmark & BrooklynThe new market loops amazing! Congrats to Betsy, Kristine, Scott, and the entire Larsen’s crew!
Looks amazing! Happy you guys
Cohen Rhonda EdgartownLooks amazing! Happy you guys will have a beautiful building to work in. We so appreciate you and your entire staff who keep us in fresh seafood. Lobsters and half shells on the beach. Can't wait!
Betsy, does this mean prices
Peter Henley CT, WVBetsy, does this mean prices have gone up? :)
Congratulations on the new
Linda ScarlatelliCongratulations on the new building and re-opening.
What a delight to visit the
Paula Eisenberg AquinnahWhat a delight to visit the new Larsen’s and find everything the same except the building itself. Congrats to all who made this transformation happen. We had a terrific paella with scallops, shrimp and littlenecks tonight. Thank you, Betsy and crew!
I'm glad they are still
David Cilmark and PAI'm glad they are still moving forward! But I'll miss no longer having house accounts:( I loved being able to come from the beach wearing just my bathing suit and buy fish for dinner and say "charge it..."
I would come back from the beach and let everyone else take their shower, while I would go to Larsen's and decide what we would have for dinner. I'm afraid I might start checking out prices between both markets in Menemsha...
Bring back the Kick'N'Bayou
Val Krillmer HollywoodBring back the Kick'N'Bayou spicy sauce.
Been going to Larsen since
Paul Zydel Sound Beach NYBeen going to Larsen since 1980. They are a great family. We visit Menemsha every year aboard the Iron Genny. Best of luck with the new digs. Can’t wait to see it.
Along with having the best
Michael cutler West TisburyAlong with having the best fish on the vineyard, they now have the best looking building in menemsha!
Can’t wait to see it! We have
Adam Hawkes Amherst NHCan’t wait to see it! We have Larsen bumper stickers all over our house here is Amherst NH! Life long fans.
One of the best, most special
Lisa Herrick Aquinnah and Washington DCOne of the best, most special island businesses deserves such a beautiful home for great seafood and the nicest people who own it.
Congrats Betsy, Kristin and
John Moore Milton MACongrats Betsy, Kristin and everyone else on the successful reopening of Larsen's! See you in the fall, if not before then.
I complete wear out at least
Nowell Upham Dallas, VH Every SummerI complete wear out at least of your t-shirts every year. As long as you don't change the T-shirts, you know I'll be back soon. Can't wait to check out the new place. Update my wardrobe, and eat some chowder and slaw.
How we would really love to
Jack & Phyllis Kennally Rhode islandHow we would really love to be back in Menemsha, on the Lofty Lady, docked at the Owl’s Nest
and be able to run over to Betsy’s for cooked lobsters or harpooned swordfish one more
time.
Add new comment