We had been living in Wilmington, N.C, for 15 years when we decided to move back north, trading my husband’s southerly clime for my northerly one.
We had been living in Wilmington, N.C, for 15 years when we decided to move back north, trading my husband’s southerly clime for my northerly one, from magnolias to maples, hot summers to cold winters, poisonous snakes to stinky skunks. We had been spending our autumns on the Island, loved biking the off-season roads, had made friends, and this move would settle us closer to family. In addition, for the past 10 years, I’d been studying Buddhism and practicing meditation, and Bodhi Path, the Buddhist center in West Tisbury, was uniquely appealing.
When online we saw a house for sale across the street from a friend, we called her and within hours were touring the property, Covid style, through our realtor’s phone. We liked it immediately. When he was showing us the backyard, he laughed and said, “Look, chickens!” He directed his phone towards two chickens ambling along. How sweet, I thought.
In less than 24 hours the deal was done. We called our friend back to learn more about the neighborhood. “You’ll love it,” she said. “More year-round than seasonal. Off the tourist track. Quiet.”
Then she added: “And you’ll get used to the rooster. He’ll wake you up at night, but you’ll learn to just turn over and go back to sleep.”
We arrived in late May. The tulips had come and gone, the giant white and pink rhododendrons were in full bloom and, as promised, we heard the trill of a rooster. By day, we marveled as the rooster led the chickens across our yard, enroute to the luscious compost pile in our other neighbor’s yard. In early evening, they would trace their tiny steps back to their coop. Herschel, our Miniature Schnauzer, ears perked, excitedly barked, as if saying, Look! Look! More things to bark at!
Being Herschel’s walkers, we quickly met other neighbors and their dogs, many puppies, part of the Covid canine boom. I once asked a delivery man if he was okay with dogs as I tried to stop Herschel from jumping on him in delight. The man looked at me bemused and said, “Everyone on Martha’s Vineyard has a dog.”
We were barely unpacked before family and friends traipsed off the ferry. “You’ll need a lot of plates,” my brother told us.We went to Ikea. We started the all-important visitor calendar, with days crossed off for extra sleep. We needed it. Evidently the rooster did not. He specialized in night crowing. We’d wake, remember our neighbor’s words, turn over and fall back asleep. Or not. His owner said he was the best rooster he ever had, that his lusty bellow kept predators at bay. He was sorry the rooster woke us and would be diligent about corralling the brood at night. And if that didn’t work, he’d whip up a tasty dish of Coq au Vin.
At Bodhi Path we strive to increase our compassion for all sentient beings — that includes hens and roosters. We send wishing prayers: May all beings be happy. May they not suffer. May their happiness always be separate from suffering. We’re taught that everyone and everything can be our teacher. Coq au Vin became mine. When he woke me at night, I’d wish him well and thank him for helping me become more compassionate.
Nature being nature, by autumn there was a proliferation of chicks and by winter, hens and a couple of rooster-boys. The parade through our yard became even more resplendent, Coq au Vin prancing proud, his brick-red feathers puffed, followed by the cluck of hens and the cute little baby crows of the boys. Nature also being nature, those Covid pups also grew. One fateful day, one caught a hen and killed it. No longer were dog barks innocent. At the slightest bark of a dog, instead of heading home to roost, Coq au Vin and his family took to sleeping in the trees. This afforded us a close-up serenade. In bed we now just tossed and turned. We knew if we just said the word, Coq au Vin would be doused with red wine.
Everything changes all the time. The day came when the sleep of two humans eclipsed the life of one rooster. The text was sent. An immediate text came back, and Coq au Vin’s fate was sealed. That same afternoon the neighbor with the compost pile asked us if we too were losing sleep, if the nightly hen parties in the treetops were, well, over the top. I marveled at the coincidence, found relief that it wasn’t just me, understanding that at any time there are a myriad of decisions being made by a myriad of sentient beings fueled by a myriad of circumstances.
Now the chickens no longer roam the neighborhood. Coq au Vin didn’t become stew. He moved to a farm where he can crow to his hearts content. One of the boy roosters was also sent away. And the red and brown one left to rule the roost does not have the fortissimo of his father’s crow. At least not yet.
May all beings be happy.
Amy Lyon lives in West Tisbury.
Editor’s note: We’ve received a large volume of comments on this essay, and we have published a selection of them, all signed with full names. The Gazette welcomes signed commentaries on a wide range of topics which do not necessarily reflect the views of the newspaper. We reserve the right to limit comments that are anonymous, repetitive or offensive.

Comments
A sweetly written essay on
Kathryn Muir EdgartownA sweetly written essay on why some people shouldn't move here.
Amy, I love your description
Penelope SmithAmy, I love your description of these events, but as a long time islander, I’m a little concerned with how you don’t seem to have any regard for the agricultural way of life in this town. I know that sleep is important, but please consider the area you came to and respect the traditions in place here and perhaps there’s a harmonious blend that can be achieved?
And so ends the agricultural
Brian Athearn west tisburyAnd so ends the agricultural town of West Tisbury.... one chip at a time
Cute story, but maybe a wee
Beka ElDeiry VhCute story, but maybe a wee bit insensitive during an housing crisis that is forcing our teachers and doctors to move away , you explained that bought a house on your phone .
Love, love, love this story!
Lisa Holley OBLove, love, love this story!
Very sad this is an article
Jane flanders EdgartownVery sad this is an article printed in our paper - presented the way it is.
Many have fought hard battles to keep the small family farm. Food was hard to get here not that long ago for locals. Local sustainability to promote the long history of agriculture here against the gentrification of the island was needed. Can’t believe this story is being celebrated this way.
This is why there’s an angry divide against those relocating. Come; be part of the community but Roosters and other animals ? We love them. Our feral kids too.
Bodi path ? Or religion when it’s convenient for our comfort.
I get roosters can be noisy and sometimes they end up in a pot - I don’t understand an article that’s printed in our local paper with this message.
I’ll be also sending love and light -
But I don’t understand this writers plight.
At all.
Dear Ms Lyon, if you haven’t
Chrysal Parrot West TisburyDear Ms Lyon, if you haven’t read the thread about your article on Islanders Talk (Facebook), I suggest you do so. This piece demonstrates that you have little to no understanding of the community that you have moved into, and if you want to be able to coexist peacefully here, you will need to educate yourself.
I think it’s worth mentioning
Jason Cooley WTI think it’s worth mentioning that the rooster did not end up on a farm, the neighbor confirmed on Islanders Talk that they had to have it killed along with another young rooster. It’s a tragedy, and emblematic of the displacement and destruction of so many things islanders hold dear.
A couple of noisy roosters
Pat Mcgibbon Edgartown and MethuenA couple of noisy roosters were relocated. EVERYONE is getting sleep including other neighbors bothered as well,and "peacefully" coexisting. Read it again. Reading comprehension. It's called being considerate.
If this were true, you’d be
Rebecca Cournoyer West TisburyIf this were true, you’d be correct. However, there are two sides to every story; this version is not accurate. Truth in journalism is important.
The roosters in question, were not relocated, but culled. They are not living on a farm. The family who owned these chickens were pressured to have their beloved pets killed. I don’t believe “everyone” is sleeping well now. I can imagine the children of this family are most certainly not.
Perhaps you should read it
Kristy Rose EdgartownPerhaps you should read it again from a different perspective. We have been poultry owners for many many years and have sent a fair share to the pot. This is about something much bigger. -
When one moves into a neighborhood, you are accepting the things that make it unique and are preexisting. West Tisbury is a historically agricultural town. Farm animals are a way of life. They come with the territory. Captain Kirk (the roo’s real name) was living a happy existence with his flock until this person moved into his neighborhood and then imposed their beliefs on how things should be. Kirk lost his life, his son’s life and one of his lady friends was killed by a dog. If the author had done some research ahead of time and purchased elsewhere this all could’ve been avoided. -
To put it in perspective for you, it’s like moving into downtown Edgartown and trying to make them shut off the Whaling Church bell that has rung since 1843 because it rings every hour. Or, moving into a neighborhood on Chappaquiddick with a tower and then trying to make them take it down. These things preexist. When you move into a neighborhood, you accept them with the purchase. Buy a different house away from the farms, bells and cell phone towers if they will bother you. Don't move somewhere because you "love" it and then try to make it fit your mold by killing its uniqueness.
Well said Kristy
Brian Athearn west tisburyWell said Kristy
While I bemoan the outcome,
Aushra Galley EdgartownWhile I bemoan the outcome, it should be noted that the "problem" was manageable until a free-ranging dog attacked the flock in question and they began to roost in a tree for safety. Perhaps the problem here is people who allow their dogs to roam freely? As I understand the law, an owner of chickens, or any other livestock, is within their rights to shoot a dog that attacks said livestock. Dog owners should bear that in mind.
As the neighbor with the
Peggy MacKenzie West TisburyAs the neighbor with the compost pile, I feel compelled to say that Amy and her husband are great neighbors. I admire Amy's confidence in submitting her writing for the public to read and respond to.
Add new comment