Planning board hearing was held over Zoom Thursday evening.

School Leaders Condemn Outburst at Oak Bluffs Planning Board Meeting

Martha’s Vineyard school leaders are strongly condemning an Island resident for his vulgar outburst at an Oak Bluffs planning board meeting Thursday evening.

Martha’s Vineyard school leaders are strongly condemning an Island resident for his vulgar outburst at an Oak Bluffs planning board meeting Thursday evening, apologizing to the community member the outburst was directed at and calling for the person who uttered the expletive to take responsibility for his actions.

“The comment was offensive, demeaning and misogynistic, and an affront to the community member, an insult to all who were in attendance and disprespectful to the planning board and the process our community put in place for allowing a thorough review of the project,” school leaders said in a statement issued Friday evening.

The statement was signed by regional high school committee chairman Amy Houghton, Vineyard schools superintendent Matthew D’Andrea, assistant superintendent Richard Smith and high school principal Sara Dingledy.

The brief, vulgar outburst occurred near the end of a planning board hearing held over Zoom on the school athletics field project Thursday night.

Susan Desmarais, an Oak Bluffs resident, had begun to testify against the project. Terry Donahue, a longtime vocal proponent of the turf fields project, could be heard directing a vulgar remark at Ms. Desmarais.

In the statement issued Friday, school leaders distanced themselves from Mr. Donahue, who was not named, and apologized to Ms. Desmarais, also not named.

“The school committee and school administration denounce the comment and want to express our apologies to the community member who was sharing her views. While the person who expressed the abhorrent language is not affiliated with, a spokesperson for, a consultant to, or otherwise engaged with the school system, he has been a vocal proponent of the project,” the statement said.

In a letter sent to the Gazette Sunday afternoon, Mr. Donahue apologized to Ms. Desmarais.

“I would like to publicly apologize to Susan Desmarais for the offense and hurt caused by my remarks during her statement at the March 31, 2022, Oak Bluffs planning board meeting,” Mr. Donahue wrote. “While I was unaware the mic was on, it does not take away from the egregious and demeaning nature of the remark. The responsibility for that statement is mine and mine alone, and one I have had to live with in the past days with the women in my life. I apologize and ask for both Ms. Desmarais’s forgiveness and that of the entire community.”

The exchange has served to cast another shadow across the $11 million athletic fields overhaul, which has grown bitterly divisive between groups of vocal proponents and opponents over the plan to use artificial turf on the main field.

The plan has been through exhaustive review by land use boards, first with the Martha’s Vineyard Commission, which approved the project last July. The project still needs a special permit from the Oak Bluffs planning board because it lies in the water resource planning overlay district in that town.

A planning board hearing opened last week and continued on Thursday night. Testimony from proponents was taken first, and took up most of the second hearing. Among other things student athletes and coaches turned out in force to advocate strongly for the turf field.

“I can say that the field that we currently use is basically unplayable,” former football player Zachary Smith told the board.

“I’ve pulled rocks out of my players’ bloody knees,” said Lisa Knight, former high school field hockey coach. “I am comforted because there is a solution, and it is before you right now,” she said.

Proponents also criticized the turf field opponents who have raised vocal concerns about groundwater contamination from the long-lasting chemical PFAS.

“They’re just creating fear,” Joe Mikos said. “I urge you to follow the science.”

Near the end of the hearing, planning board chairman Ewell Hopkins opened the floor for testimony from opponents, and Ms. Desmarais began to speak.

“Why are we still discussing the possibility of putting forever chemicals in our land?” she said. “Why are so many unwilling to stand up to big industry? . . . We, the MV community, are the ones with skin in the game.”

The hearing was continued to April 21 at 5 p.m. Testimony from opponents, which saw only a few minutes of time Thursday, will be taken.

Just before adjournment, planning board member Erik Albert lauded the young speakers for their participation.

“I’d like to thank the young people that came out,” he said. That’s the most I’ve seen at any of our meetings.”

Updated to include letter of apology from Mr. Donahue.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 04/02/2022 - 13:19

Permalink

Susan Desmarais Oak Bluffs

I am misquoted in this piece. I asked why so many are unwilling to stand up not willing. And I need to add…you labeled this an exchange, that would imply an element of give and take. I was verbally assaulted, interestingly enough while speaking about bullying and intimidation tactics. I continued with my statement not engaging with the perpetrator for even a moment.

The apology I expect and deserve is from Terry Donahue. And he can do it in this format if he chooses.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 04/02/2022 - 19:34

Permalink

Bob Edgartown

Not the first outburst heard on Zoom but one that got plenty of attention. People need to remember the mute button and the moderator should have muted none speakers. This would not of happened in person and is the product of the Zoom age. I have heard people from both sides of this debate express similar frustration just not on camera. I wonder if the current 8th graders will have a new field to play on.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 04/02/2022 - 23:51

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

Violence brings on more violence
Insults bring on more insults
I’ve known Terry for years he and I were active in the cancer support suppers New Year’s Eve at the Black Dog tavern. Ages ago What he said was stupid mean and vile. He’s been like a dog on a bone for years about this ridiculous issue. Drop the bone it’s over you went all in with your disgusting comment shame on you.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 04/03/2022 - 11:48

Permalink

Charles callahan So Boston edgartown

This place is getting as nasty as so Boston where I grew up.hopefully it won't get quite as bad.

DAJ Hidden Cove

Love your reference to former Beatle Ringo Starkeys moniker “peace and love”. It’s both timely ( given his annual call for everyone to stop and express ‘peace and love’) AND a much needed sentiment in an era where aggression and impoliteness is more and more acceptable. Yes R. Starkey ( perhaps Ringo does visit our beloved Island) peace and love, indeed.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.