North shore West Tisbury property was formerly owned by Washington Post publisher Katharine Graham.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Mohu, Last Piece of Graham Estate, Goes on the Market

The last remaining piece of Washington Post publisher Katharine Graham’s grand Mohu estate on Martha’s Vineyard’s north shore goes on the market Friday for $39.5 million.

The last remaining piece of Washington Post publisher Katharine Graham’s grand Mohu estate on Martha’s Vineyard’s north shore goes on the market Friday for $39.5 million.

Stunningly beautiful mix of hills, shoreline, wetlands and pastures.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Stunningly beautiful mix of hills, shoreline, wetlands and pastures.
Mark Alan Lovewell

At the heart of the 50-acre parcel is the site of Mrs. Graham’s former home overlooking Lambert’s Cove, still marked by towering twin stone chimneys that were preserved when the house itself was dismantled in 2005. Trails weave down through woods and carefully tended meadows to a stretch of white sandy beach. James Pond borders the property on the east side, and a smaller pond is nestled in the middle.

The Graham estate once spread out over 236 acres, but the majority of it was put up for sale for the benefit of two unnamed charitable organizations following the death in late 2017 of Mrs. Graham’s son William, a Los Angeles lawyer and investor. A year later, the 186 acres were purchased for $32.5 million by a trust created by neighboring homeowners Brian L. Roberts and Dirk Ziff, who have pledged to keep the land undeveloped.

The remaining 50 acres was retained by the Graham family, who ultimately decided to sell.

In a statement emailed Wednesday to the Gazette, the family said: “We have loved this land. For several reasons, including geography, we’re not able to take care of it and use it in the way we would wish. After a lot of deliberation we’ve therefore decided it is time to sell it.”

A stunningly beautiful mix of hills, shoreline, wetlands, woods and pastures bounded by stone walls, the estate was pieced together by William M. Butler, a Massachusetts lawyer and legislator, who made a series of strategic land purchases between 1910 and 1920. He dubbed it Mohu, after an Algonquin chief.

Historic landscape includes woodlands and old stone walls.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Historic landscape includes woodlands and old stone walls.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Senator Butler, who was chairman of the Republican National Committee and served in the state Senate and briefly as an interim U.S. senator, began a long tradition carried on in later years by Mrs. Graham of entertaining dignitaries at his 22-room hilltop home. Calvin Coolidge, a Massachusetts governor who later became president, was a frequent visitor.

The property was sold in 1964 to William and Elizabeth McFarlane, their son and daughter in law, who had plans to divide it into 15 exclusive home sites. The project never got off the ground, and in 1972, Katharine Graham was persuaded by Vineyard Gazette publisher Henry Beetle Hough to purchase Mohu to keep it out of the hands of developers. She paid $1.46 million for 217 acres.

“The transfer means that Mohu will continue as one of the Island’s special glories, its hills, ponds, declivities and beach preserved from the ‘development’ that had threatened a scenic heritage tracing from long ago when the glacial ice sheet cut into the coastline,” the Gazette wrote at the time.

Every summer for most of three decades, Mrs. Graham presided over a stream of famous guests, ranging from Henry Kissinger to Oprah Winfrey, hosting dinner parties and tennis games and establishing Mohu as the Island’s foremost salon.

After her death in 2001, the property passed to Bill Graham, who preferred a quieter life. He deconstructed the house and removed the tennis courts, focusing instead on the fields, trails and landscapes, which he meticulously maintained.

The 50 acres now being sold includes a porched bungalow built in 1930 and once used as the tennis house, a small stone caretaker’s cottage and a boathouse fronting 860 feet of beachfront.

White sand beach adjacent to Lambert's Cove is also part of the estate.
Mark Alan Lovewell
White sand beach adjacent to Lambert's Cove is also part of the estate.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Tom LeClair and Gerret Conover of LandVest Martha’s Vineyard are the exclusive brokers for the property.

“It’s rare to find a place that is has so many distinct and different ecosystems — woods, meadows, beach, pondfront, marshland,” Mr. LeClair said. “It is amazingly unique and difficult to describe without walking it and experiencing it.”

The property is assessed by the town of West Tisbury at $16.3 million. Mr. LeClair said the asking price takes into account the “incredible privacy” of the property, which is surrounded by the 186 acres that was sold previously. It is also a reflection of the overall real estate market on the Island, which he said has appreciated by 20 to 25 per cent over the past two years.

“It’s a generational property, an asset somebody is going to buy and hold to for generations,” Mr. LeClair said.

Updated to correct the asking price for the property, which is $39.5 million, not $38.5 million.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 08/19/2021 - 21:45

Permalink

Marie Laursen Tisbury

Wouldn’t this be the property the MV Land Bank was created to preserve? If anything can be done to encourage this acquisition, please do it now! Find out who your town’s Land Bank commissioner is and call them. If this isn’t worth preserving, what is?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 08/19/2021 - 23:32

Permalink

J Klingensmith Naples Florida

The owners of this land should just donate it to the Land Bank.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/20/2021 - 06:22

Permalink

Susan N.Tis

I whole heartedly agree with Ms. Laursen, I the Land Bank can’t do this then a concerned citizen of mV should. My father used to fish off there30 years ago and used to take me, it is by far some of the most stunning land on the island. DONT LET IT BE DEVELOPED. SAVE Mohu.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/20/2021 - 06:34

Permalink

Mary Vineyard Haven

Dan , Brian we appreciate all you have done thus far.. is it possible you both could jump n again ? Perhaps, if they did Landvest could donate their commission….

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/20/2021 - 07:15

Permalink

Summer Activist Edgartown

The MV Land Bank WT Commissioner is Peter Wells.
It would border there recent James Pond Preserve acquisition.
Meeting this Monday on zoom at 3pm - see the land bank web page for agenda and zoom log in.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/20/2021 - 19:27

Permalink

robert skydell Granada, Nicaragua

It seems like every time one of these large, magnificent Vineyard properties comes up for sale there are the same pleas from the peanut gallery; ¨They should just donate it!¨
I wonder how many of these same people realize what a large and significant part the owners of such properties have played in the preservation of Martha's Vineyard over the years.
Perhaps they should be thanking them instead.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/20/2021 - 20:09

Permalink

Bruce Edgartown

While the sentiments about the Land Bank acquiring are nice, remember two things: 1) the asking price is about equal to two and 1/2 years or Land Bank receipts, and 2) removing this property from West Tisbury tax rolls will, at the current assessed value, reallocate about $100,000 in property tax revenue to the remaining taxpayers of West Tisbury (and if the $39 million is the real "new" value of the property, about $250,000 will have to be paid by the remaining taxpayers). Would the other town taxpayers like to chip in to cover the tax loss?

Belle West Tisbury

The Land Bank didn't seem to care much when they removed The Red Gate property off Aquinnah's tax revenue. I think Aquinnah took a major hit when the Land Bank purchased that land.

Jose Oak Bluffs

Per the June 30,2020 Land Bank Financial Statements, unrestricted liquid assets only total about $17.1 MN, well below the asking price. Perhaps if the Land Bank worked in conjunction with other conservation entities like Sheriff's Meadow, Trustees of Reservation, Audubon, etc., enough cash could be raised to make an offer. It seems like these organizations (like many of the non profits on the Island) work independently and don't talk to each other which is a shame given how small the Island is and how well staffed and paid the leaders of these organizations are. The issue of foregone property taxes is important. It takes real money to run governments and there needs to be a plan to address the consequences of foregone tax revenues if this property ultimately goes into the hands on non profits.

Mike Somewhere

That's a high asking price- $790,000 an acre. Even the assessed value seems a little warped - $320,00 per acre.
Amen, WT taxes are getting pretty high because of high assessments. The revenue loss will affect the rest of the tax payers. Yes - preserve the land in its current natural state. No - don't ask the tax payers of WT to pay for it. Not for profit (pay no taxes) land acquisitions have sharply raised individuals taxes. How about if you want to donate your land to avoid paying annual taxes- go ahead, but please provide a self perpetuating trust that pays the annual taxes specifically for the parcel being donated. Therefore not a burden to the remaining tax payers.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 08/23/2021 - 07:39

Permalink

PAW Winter Park

186 adjacent acres are supposed to remain open, clear. This 50 acre parcel (20% of original estate) used to have 1 home. In the interests of providing affordable housing I would suggest this 50 acres be divided into 4 or 5 homesites. Let's all get behind affordable housing!

gina Menemsha/NYC

If a Developer buys the land it may very well be divided into 4 or 5 homesites which would be a shame.. but affordable housing , probably not ..

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.