Wastewater concerns continue to hover over the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital’s proposed new nursing home facility off the Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Road, with selectmen voting Monday to commission an independent analysis.
Wastewater concerns continue to hover over the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital’s proposed new nursing home facility off the Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Road, with Edgartown selectmen voting Monday to have an engineering firm conduct an independent analysis of the project.
The proposed development is slated for a landlocked parcel at 490 Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Road, currently owned by the Philip J. Norton family.
In December of 2019, hospital chief executive officer Denise Schepici confirmed that a purchase and sale agreement had been signed for the 21-acre piece of land, with the intention to construct approximately 70 beds in five, live-in-care, group-home style buildings and 60 units of workforce housing.
A formal plan for the development has not been submitted to the town, planning board administrator Doug Finn confirmed Tuesday, although the hospital has been in discussions with the wastewater commission and Martha’s Vineyard Commission about aspects of the project.
With Edgartown’s sewer plant nearing capacity, wastewater remains a crucial factor in the development. According to wastewater facility manager Bill Burke, the hospital wants to tie into town sewer using the Morgan Woods pump station, which would require approval by the wastewater commission and the state Department of Environmental Protection.
At the selectmen’s meeting Tuesday, town officials voted to have the engineering firm Tighe & Bond examine the project. The analysis will cost $9,600 and will be paid for by the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital.
“There are some wastewater concerns,” town administrator James Hagerty told the Gazette by phone. “It’s a big project and we want our third-party engineers to look at it.”
According to a copy of the contract provided to the Gazette, the firm will examine possible upgrades needed at the Morgan Woods pump station, the cost of upgrades, and the impact of the development on sewer capacity and nutrient loading. The study assumes the hospital will request 17,050 gallons per day of capacity.
“With the additional flow, are the pump stations big enough, can they handle the flow, do they need upgrades?” Mr. Burke said. “Those are the questions.”
The town approved new zoning regulations at its 2021 annual town meeting that allow for the construction of an elder care facility in anticipation of the project. If the project is ultimately approved, the hospital plans to eventually transition out of the Windemere nursing facility on its campus and relocate long-term care to the new facility.
In other business Monday, selectmen opened the commercial shellfishing season in the Edgartown Great Pond, unanimously approving a daily limit of two level, 10-gallon washbuckets, and a weekly limit of no more than six level, 10-gallon wash buckets.
The closure line stretches east from the base of Swan Neck, across the pond to the tip of Slough Cove. The season runs from Monday through Friday, ending on Sept. 6.
According to a letter from shellfish constable Paul Bagnall, the weekly limit is a new feature.
“It allows the fishermen discretion over which days of the week to fish, based on weather and market conditions,” the letter says. “We expect turnout to be light, with two to six people participating.”

Comments
This is a huge ask for the
Bob EdgartownThis is a huge ask for the tax payers of Edgartown. That area is not as fragile as other areas that need to be seward and to lose capacity for this project is not a small issue. It is more than just can the pumps handle it? Everything is important and that is what we need to decide protect the ponds and water quality? The waste water plant will need upgrades and who will pay for that. The Edgartown taxpayer does not want to lose taxes on this land either to a so called non profit. This needs to stay on the tax roll.
To my knowledge, it is only a
Jeremy TisburyTo my knowledge, it is only a collection system capacity issue. The wastewater treatment plant still has about 1/3 of its capacity left unused, even during peak season. The pump stations and force mains however, may not have the available capacity to handle the additional 17,000 gallons per day.
Sorry to hear Edgartown has
T Bone Oak BluffsSorry to hear Edgartown has gone poor. Here in Oak Bluffs we have to support an island hospital and a regional high school. But I'm sure your elderly can pitch tents.
T Bone I couldn’t agree more.
Nettie Kent Ruel ChilmarkT Bone I couldn’t agree more.
I’m guessing none of you against this project have a loved one having to live off island in a nursing home, well let me tell you it’s painful not to be able to visit them as often as you could if they were here.
We desperately need elder care on island, nursing homes, assisted living, call it what you will, with this housing crisis this island isn’t getting younger it’s aging and then what?
The housing crisis isn’t just for the young families and workers, it’s coming for our elders and we need this project, desperately.
T Bone if you follow the
Bob EdgartownT Bone if you follow the officials in Oak Bluffs they are always complaining about that very issue. That OB has the institutions you refer to not paying taxes and they want to correct that. All I am saying is I do not want to have the same problem OB has and complaining about no revenue from them. And remember these are not really non profits they pay huge salaries and they should pay taxes like everyone else.
Same old story from OB.. Here
here we go again edgSame old story from OB.. Here in Edgartown our sewer plant has been accepting out of town waste for years. We have to support the county jail, county courthouse, south beach crowds and associated traffic. How much do you think we spend when our officers get injured assisting the problems at the jail and go out on disabilty and we get stuck with the tab for overtime to cover their shifts. How much do we spend on lifeguards and police patrols and other associated costs with south beach where we welcome visitors from ALL towns (unlike the stingy up island towns) Do tell us how much profit OB makes from the off island ambulance transports for the hospital patients.. Its a cash cow.
Agreed Bob! This project has
Ben I. EdgartownAgreed Bob! This project has a myriad of issues that pose significant impacts for the town of Edgartown, in addition to what appears many abutters. This land also shares a property line with the historic penny wise path. Where’s the Land Bank on this one? With Caroline Tuthill close down the road I’d certainly rather imagine a 21 acre addition of trails and conservation land for the enjoyment of Edgartown and all island residents! This land is precious. Let’s make a sound decision for the future and find a better suited location for the hospital that does not require such a tremendous lift.
I cannot believe these
Nicole B EdgartownI cannot believe these comments. Here the hospital is attempting to create a nursing facility for our elders and all you people are doing is bitching about taxes? And where's the problem with all of the building going on in town and the huge houses going up with all of their wastewater demands? Edgartown has a very high tax base, and the cost of homes (as we all know) are only increasing. OB does have the hospital and the high school. Perhaps it's time that an institution of island-wide benefit be located in our town. We are talking about human beings here, and, at least in my book, helping people outweighs lower taxes.
Add new comment