Dogs will not be allowed on Lambert’s Cove Beach for the remainder of the pandemic, the West Tisbury board of health announced Friday.
Dogs will not be allowed on Lambert’s Cove Beach for the remainder of the pandemic, the West Tisbury board of health announced Friday.
The board voted at a meeting Thursday to ban dogs from the town beach “for reasons related to owners not adhering to dog-waste cleanup and leash requirements,” town health agent Omar Johnson said in a statement that went out late Friday.
“During this pandemic it is of utmost importance that dogs not be allowed to roam freely while efforts to maintain social distancing are being emphasized,” the statement also said.
In the summer months dogs are allowed at Lambert’s Cove before 10 a.m. and after 6:30 p.m., a rule that came about as a compromise after years of heated back-and-forth debate about dogs on the popular town beach. Voters approved a no-dogs bylaw at a special town meeting in 2011, but the next year a compromise bylaw was hammered out. Throughout, there were passionate opinions on both sides.
But with the pandemic creating a need for strict social distancing, the casual Island practice of allowing dogs off leash has been a source of tension at the beach at times this year.
Mr. Johnson said the ban is temporary, and will be removed when the threat of the coronavirus subsides.
“The West Tisbury board of health will proceed without delay, banning dogs from Lambert’s Cove Beach until such a time as the board agrees that Covid-19 is no longer a significant threat to the community,” the statement said.

Comments
In other words - This ban is
Bob OBIn other words - This ban is temporary, and will be removed as soon as we can think of a better one.
Finally. Make it permanent.
Islander TooFinally. Make it permanent.
Love dogs, but not at beach.
Take responsibility by
Philip Cordella Oak BluffsTake responsibility by offering to self police the beach as a solution. Dog owners who want to have access could volunteer their time to monitor usage and enforce the rules. Wear an armband to identify yourself. It could be a way to solve the problem assuming there are enough volunteers who want to help. Offering a community/ government partnership is best assuming the governing body is open to this idea.
Such a shame that people can
JCDIII MakonikeySuch a shame that people can’t take responsibility for keeping their dogs on a leash, and picking up after them. I agree that those who enjoy the privilege should help enforce the policies that keep the beach safe & clean for everyone to enjoy. Additionally, I’d recommend that the Town sell dog walking passes that could then be used to help fund initiatives in support, such paying for person to check badges, add a few more collection boxes for waste, and fund frequent removals. I personally would recommend that dogs be kept on a leash the entire length of the beach which should help compel owners to pick up after their dog, since the waste would be right in front of them. Anyone, who abuses their privilege, loses their pass to bring their dog along for a walk, plain & simple.
That’s a great idea Philip—
Cathi Gilmore West Tisbury and WabanThat’s a great idea Philip— and actually, we have such a group. We volunteer; we have greeters who remind all dog walkers of the rules; we work with the Town. It has been a very successful community effort for some years.
Love this idea. I'd do it in
Chris Potts TisburyLove this idea. I'd do it in a second.
So sad to hear the latest.
Rose ConcordSo sad to hear the latest. It was always such a joy to see the dogs enjoying the vineyard's most beautiful beach. Hopefully they will be welcomed back soon.
Dog poop was disgusting. The
Kelce OBDog poop was disgusting. The owners who won't pick up their dogs duty ruin it for the rest of us.
Very, and it smells bad too.
mike SomewhereVery, and it smells bad too. Simple solution - Watch your dog. Pay attention. Stop lollygagging obliviously. Do you watch your children? What makes dogs any less worthy? Even NYC has off leash 8pm -8am in many city parks. That's not the problem - lazy inconsiderate people are. Cleaning up after your dog is mandatory. Not voluntary. Do it. If there is a violator we all speak up, what are you doing? Talk about their inconsiderateness to them and others, and that the few are putting our privileges at risk. You will see very high compliance with group policing. There will always be a few violators and we should all know who they are. This tact can be very Effective.
It's too bad, but I agree
David VHIt's too bad, but I agree with the ban. Having beach access for dogs was a privilege but the leash requirement was blatantly ignored by many which is unfortunate.
The compromise passed by the
Terry West TisburyThe compromise passed by the West Tisbury voters was that dogs were allowed on the beach before 10:00 a,m. Period. They were not allowed after 6:30 p.m.
the dogs aren't the problem,
bobthe dogs aren't the problem, it's the dog owners
I can understand both sides
Renee West TisburyI can understand both sides of the argument but am extremely disappointed we can't take our dog for a morning swim. For those thoughtless dog owners who don't pick up after their dog, carry the waste out, and flaunt the rules, you've certainly taken away a very special joy of being on the island.
Agreed. Always maddening to
Debbie OBAgreed. Always maddening to see the people flaunting the rules and knowing we were putting our privilege at risk. And if what happened at Tradewinds is a model, they’ll be the most outraged.
no more walking barefoot from
RT WTno more walking barefoot from the parking lot and finding a surprise between your toes. Make it permanent.
Dogs should only be allowed
Peter VHDogs should only be allowed during fall and winter PERMANENTLY. Self-policing will NOT work.
People have been reminded to
J.D.S. The VineyardPeople have been reminded to control their dogs without success for several years. They have totally ignored all the pleas to pick up after your dog, keep them on a leash under your control and all without success.
Now many if not all beaches Do Not Allow Dogs on the Beaches Period from April 1st thu August 31st of each year!
Dog owners have totally abused the privilege, ignored all the warnings now they have to pay the penalty, Period!
Also all island trails are posted to keep your dogs on a leash under your control and pick up their messes. Guaranteed those trails will be the next areas that will not allow dogs at all because of the same ignored warnings listed above!
That’s really disappointing.
Jane ChilmarkThat’s really disappointing. In all our years of visiting that beach with our dogs, there’s far more trash and mess left by people than there is from dogs.
Totally true. Unnecessary
Mark MV DreamingTotally true. Unnecessary and mean spirited to ban the dogs. Petty bureaucrats trying to feel powerful.
Ban loud obnoxious people and
Diane Demarest wesr tisBan loud obnoxious people and leave the dogs alone How prtty
Some dog owners are
John West TisburySome dog owners are responsible, observing leash laws and picking up their mess. Unfortunately this type of owner does not seem to represent the majority. Too many owners act like the rules do not apply to them and their dog(s).
How cruel to the dogs who
Steve Lambert’s Cove RoadHow cruel to the dogs who love a morning swim and the early-morning beach walkers who share that time with them. In all the years we have taken our dog to the beach in the morning, I’ve rarely seen this privilege abused. The wonderful group of volunteers who we supported were an additional reminder of the rules virtually all followed. Sadder, still, that one of the things that give so many of us joy in these difficult times is being taken away on the pretext, it seems, that the health crisis demands it. Nonsense. We would certainly support a pass system that like the parking passes could be revoked for failure to abide by the rules.
Leave the dogs alone and ban
charlie callahan so boston/edgartownLeave the dogs alone and ban the people. The more time I spend around people here,the better I like my dogs
I’ve lived here most of my
Tom Engley West TisburyI’ve lived here most of my life ,born here in 1954. We have always had dogs and always went to the beach but never with the dog. How ever we did walk the dog on the beach but not in season to be polite. Here’s the solution. Allow only dogs and no people. It’s that simple.
Sounds like dog owners are
LWS OB/CC/MDSounds like dog owners are the real problem, not their dogs. Leaving a plastic bag with dog waste on the beach is not technically cleaning up after your dog.
It's unfortunate. However,
Carol formerly ChilmarkIt's unfortunate. However, without citations (like $200 tickets for having your dog off-leash or not picking up the poop) and rent-a-cops out there to write those tickets, there's zero downside for scofflaws, which ruins it for everyone, both dog owners and non-dog owners.
I still don't see the
RR Vineyard HavenI still don't see the relationship of dogs off leash to COVID19 precautions. I am not trying to be flippant but really don't get it. They seem to be separate issues unless there is a connection that I don't understand.
There is no relationship
Mark MV DreamingThere is no relationship between dogs on the beach and Covid-19 precautions. Dogs don't get or spread coronavirus. This is someone taking advantage of the pandemic to push their own agenda. A terrible petty ruling that takes joy away from dogs and people alike, and makes the Vineyard less special. And by the way, the comments about dog owners abusing the privilege are bunk. The overwhelming majority pick up after their dogs and observe the leash rules. If a few violate them, that's a shame, but it's no different than any other situation in which the public uses shared resources. Human beings, unaccompanied by canine companions, also leave trash on the beach, but we don't ban them -- or pretend the ban is somehow justified by the pandemic. Shameful.
Reach out to the WT elected
Philip Cordelka oak BluufsReach out to the WT elected officials and see if they want to work with a community group to help solve the problem. Is there a community group set up and seriously want to correct the problem? What do the people who are running for office feel? Will they work with such a community group?
I'd much rather see the West
Charlie Giordano West TisburyI'd much rather see the West Tisbury board of health banned from the beach. And everywhere else. For this board a pound of prevention is worth an ounce of cure. Silly, bureaucratic, overreaching, snobbery.
Agreed - what does dogs being
JDP W TisburyAgreed - what does dogs being off-leash outdoors have to do with Covid-19 precautions? Another wonderful, joyous, safe activity curtailed that I HOPE will soon be restored. PS - dog owners PICK UP AND PROPERLY DISPOSE THE POOP!!
I am always dumbfounded when
AJ Edgartown and BostonI am always dumbfounded when people walk their dogs without a poo bag, I was on the Vineyard last summer walking with my dog I saw another dog owner on their phone as their dog "went" they waited and then after the dog was done they began to walk away I said I had an extra bag they replied "no thanks but you can clean it up if it bothers you" kept walking. I always have bags in my pockets as a responsible dog owner it is part and parcel of owning a dog. Dog feces carries diseases and I for one don't want my dog stepping in your dogs and getting sick nor do I want to step in it and track it in my house car etc.
Another thing that we've notices on our Edgartown walks people picking up the poo and leaving the bags of poo on the sidewalks etc. NEWS FLASH if your going to pick it up and bag it don't leave the plastic bags of poo on the ground put them in the trash, again the Vineyard isn't home to dog poo fairies that magically clean it up, its your dogs poo its your responsibility.
AJ, i totally agree. and
annieAJ, i totally agree. and cannot understand the mentality of the dog owner you encountered. at this point in my life, i can't have a dog, because i know i couldn't give it the life that it should have. there IS a resonsibilty in owning a pet. isn't that what we teach children? i have 3 "granddoggies" and i'll be damned if i haven't taught my children to take care of their dogs. dogs cannot pick up after themselves, that is why they have owners.
Thank you! My kids have been
Mack and the boys West TisburyThank you! My kids have been chased by dogs there several times, and the smells along the trail linger all summer. Sorry to all the dogs, but this is long overdue.
Love dogs, have (old lady)
PollyLove dogs, have (old lady) dog... have loved seeing more people out & about walking, maybe where they have never regularly walked before! BUT owners that don’t pick up after their pets are disgusting! RUIN it for everyone! Just because some neighborhoods aren’t fully populated doesn’t mean that you can leave your dog’s mess! How would they like it if we brought our dogs to their house to poop where they walk? BE RESPECTFUL! Clean up after your dogs!
I totally agree with picking
DDI totally agree with picking up the poop and disposing of it properly but part of the joy of a dog on the beach is for it to be able to run and swim and enjoy the ocean. This is a very sad decision and I don't agree with it. Covid is just a handy excuse for anything people want to ban.
It truly is a shame that so
Fred Roven EdgartownIt truly is a shame that so many have to suffer for so few especially off-season when I see most dog walkers being conscious and considerate. I love the feeling I get seeing my dog being so carefree and sharing the beach. I see the joy on most faces as he runs from the path and dives in the ocean. I never have understood the leash thing walking on the path. My preference is to have my dog do all his business in the woods before we arrive at the beach. I am not sure how anyone can keep track of dog's business while off leash on the beach. And for all the years of living in West Tisbury I could never figure out what was meant by third buoy. And of course making this about a pandemic is ludicrous. And I wish someone would explain to me how anyone could possibly think it better to leave a plastic bag on the beach than at least having the courtesy of removing your dog's business.
Dogs at the beach are a
Elizabeth edgartown and Hobe Sound FloridaDogs at the beach are a problem for nesting shorebirds, sea turtles, other wildlife and people.
At the beach even the best mannered dog (and their owner) is reacting to a wide range of unfamiliar stimuli including young children and other dogs jumping around. Some people feel unsafe when a 60 pound mammal with fangs lunges at them. Native shore life also recoils. And the poop does contain disease - all sorts. No one needs to go to the hospital right now from infection, or a dog bite. Personally, I do not want to be licked by anything that carries Covid 19 - or by anyone or anything that I did not invite to sniff or lick me. I am not sure dog owners understand the rights of non dog owners that are routinely violated.
My family has lived on
Rachel L cove rdMy family has lived on lamberts cove for years and have always had dogs. It's so heartbreaking to think as generational residents and taxpayers that summer residents people from all over the island have ruined this special place for our family. My mother is die ing as I write this in her home on lamberts cove rd. I never understood why this beach couldn't have been reserved for its residents like Lucy Vincent and virtually all others on the island. My mother and our family spent many happy days on that beach with our dogs throughout decades. This is but yet another sign of the vineyard we used to know disappearing. But we will always have the memories. Sad.
Add new comment