<p>The Menemsha waterfront traditionally begins to stir at this time of year. Fishermen mend their gear, sturdy work boats are back in the slips, ready for the early-season haul. With the pandemic, all that has changed.</p>
The Menemsha waterfront traditionally begins to stir at this time of year. Fishermen mend their gear, sturdy work boats are back in the slips, and the Menemsha Fish House opens its doors to take in the early-season haul.
But with the pandemic, all that has changed.
Disruptions in the supply chain have rippled across the ocean from China, the main importer of seafood from the U.S., to the Menemsha Fish House. The wholesale distributor has closed indefinitely amid mass layoffs at its Boston-based parent company, Red’s Best.
“When they shut down the restaurants, our main buyers, it put a huge dent in the business,” said Alec Gale, who opened the Fish House in 2004 and was laid off last week. “It had a trickle-down effect all the way to us. We were one of the first to go.”
The Fish House isn’t alone. Ocean C Star, a New Bedford company that buys Island-caught lobster, scallops, conch and other shellfish, is also temporarily closed.
“I don’t think anyone is buying right now,” said Gary Yang, co-owner of Ocean C Star. “This may be a disaster not only for our business, but Island fishermen.”
Under the recent state emergency order imposed during the pandemic, fishermen and their distributors are considered essential businesses, along with agriculture and some others.
But with distributors shuttering and the market retracting, many fishermen said it’s unlikely they will even launch their boats this year, unsure if they will be able to make a return on the base cost of boat maintenance and gear. Those who have gone out fishing said they are unable to sell. Some are freezing their catch, waiting for the economy to thaw.
Mitchell Pachico is a commercial shellfisherman who rakes quahaugs in Vineyard Haven in the winter. In the spring, he shifts to pot fishing, hauling lobster and sea bass from Vineyard Sound. Now he said he is looking for other work.
“We’re still allowed to go out and fish, we just have nowhere to sell,” he said. “It’s putting me out of business for now until things open back up.”
Tubby Medeiros also fishes for lobster and sea bass in the spring. He said this time of year he usually launches his boat after routine winter maintenance. But with boatyards closed, he said his boat is still hauled up in New Bedford.
“I got a lot of money already out. I bought more tags this year, ordered more gear,” he said. “Normally I start putting my gear [in the water] this week, but I can’t even get my boat in the water. Right now, I’m about three weeks behind.”
Wes Brighton has a sea scalloping permit, one of the few on the Island. He said the quota for March has already been reached, but much of the product has been frozen instead of sold. He said he is unsure if the market will be able to absorb more when the quota reopens April 1.
“Everyone is freezing, crossing their fingers and hoping everything works out,” Mr. Brighton said. “There’s only one thing for sure, the markets have completely tanked.”
He continued: “Seafood is seen as a luxury item. It’s served at weddings, parties, restaurants. People don’t really eat it in the same quantity at their homes. Right now, there’s just no demand.”
Mr. Yang, the bulk distributor out of New Bedford, said the problem started long before the restaurants shut down, and in fact began in January, when the pandemic hit China hard. Seafood from Canada and the United States that was meant to be exported to China began to flood the domestic market. Distributors had a surplus of supply. Now with restaurants in the United States closed, he said, much of the surplus will be left to rot.
Shelley Edmundson, executive director of the Martha’s Vineyard Fishermen’s Preservation Trust, acknowledged the stark realities — and also ironies — right now for local fishermen.
“If fishermen are still allowed to go out, but the prices get too low, it will essentially make it impossible to recoup their expenses, and they will be at home like all of us. Which is a shame because we are all at home too, but need food,” she said.
But there may be a silver lining to the collapse of the global seafood market, which has historically handed local fishermen the short end of the stick. She said some fishermen are looking into buying permits that will allow them to sell their catch right off the boat. With restaurants closed, she said she hopes individuals at home will be able to help sustain the industry.
“Maybe this is just a window to start doing things in a different way,” Ms. Edmundson said. “Our fishermen are in a place to be a little creative. I’m hopeful, in the end, we can restructure things to be better. Maybe this is an opportunity increase our demand, to land and absorb more seafood on a local level.”

Comments
Would totally buy fish from
Peyton W West TisburyWould totally buy fish from the boats! Let's support the island fishery and let them have permits to do so. Going inside a store or restaurant not a great idea right now, but buying straight from the boat would be great?
How can I get some of those
Devin NantucketHow can I get some of those sea scallops over her on Nantucket?
Can you ship some of the
Rosalind Lazarus Washington DC and ChilmarkCan you ship some of the scallops if I round up a group of purchasers?
Would love fresh seafood
Kathi H Kansas CityWould love fresh seafood delivered to my door...if ever that was a possibility!! Good luck to all!!
The direct marketing-
Dick AquinnahThe direct marketing--retailing--of local fish is a great idea. I'm all for it. The other upside is a likely resurgence of fish stocks. Stressed species, and even those in good health and numbers, will have a chance to rebound further. Future harvests, and accompanying jobs, will rebound.
Feeling for the island
Francie Aquinnah and Hastings-on-HudsonFeeling for the island fishing community and all who are hit so hard by the pandemic. Previously published in the Gazette:
Squibnocket Point
He said he could talk a pack
of dogs off a meat truck but
what we noticed was how
straight and easily he stood
on the uneven rocks, how well
he told a story, just a straight
out story about the heart attack
a year ago and that he’d died.
He told us how they brought
him back, how he’d worked
his whole life to have—and here
he swept his arm out to the sea
in a gesture bigger than words—
to have this. When the doctor
cleared him for fishing, this
was the place he wanted to come
because of the history. He said
to walk all the way around the
point and we would find the
remnants of an old pier and he
wondered how they drove the iron
pilings into the rocks back then.
Teddy Roosevelt, Grover Cleveland
used to come to fish off that pier
and boys would come in their
dinghies to pick up the fish
and bring it round to sell. He
had been fishing for four weeks,
he had to call his wife twice
each day and one day he had to
meet her on the mainland so she
just could see him. He got lots
of albies and one time with a
friend, they got 47 stripers in
one day, all too small to keep.
He grinned and said the thing
about the meat truck. We had
been married four months and
ten days on the day we met him.
We had never gone so far around
the point. It was a fine bright day
and we went off to find the pier.
Francie Camper
Frankie, great post. I got
Lorraine EdgartownFrankie, great post. I got goose bumps reading it. A word picture and history and people all involved, great story....
even when demand does bounce
Norm Off islandeven when demand does bounce back boat to table is a great concept, it certainly has worked with farm to table
A perfect opportunity to
Islander West TisburyA perfect opportunity to grant " Off the Boat " licenses to be sold directly to people on the dock or even mobile like the IGI vegetable truck. Maybe this could be one small silver lining in the Covid -19 Pandemic. You have to find them where you can. An App where Fishermen post what they have available when they land. Venmo or PayPal. Boom.
Islander, you are so right.
Lorraine EdgartownIslander, you are so right. I would go for that. I have lived and traveled in places where one could do the very same. Fabulous idea. Let us stay on it, those of you who are involved, and see what can be done about it? I am involved as a purchaser and will support it.
Why is locally caught and
Lionel Spiro ChappyWhy is locally caught and raised fish and shellfish not sold at Stop and Shop stores?
Could fishermen sell directly to them at a slightly higher price than they would get from a distributor?
This would be great public relations for Stop and Shop and good for consumers, as well as MV fishermen.
Lets all start asking the Stop and Shop people why they are not buying local.
I would love to purchase alot
Ann C. NEW YORK CITYI would love to purchase alot of that seafood off the boat!
Please change the laws, and make it
happen. Can't wait.
I'd buy some of your seafood.
Jeanette EastonI'd buy some of your seafood. Could get others also. Let me know
#NETTOTABLE #BOATTOTABLE
ISLANDER West Tisbury#NETTOTABLE #BOATTOTABLE #RODTOTABLE #SEATOTABLE Any Social Media expert out there to help make this happen ?
I think the boat to table
David F Lagoon PondI think the boat to table idea is fantastic! Would definitely be a customer
. the Scallops Yellowtail,
B A Hiller S. CA, Edgartown, MA Bethany Bch., DE. the Scallops Yellowtail, Cod Haddock & other delicious freshly from Fish ordered from Menemsha last Wednesday arrived early Friday 3/27 in thr AM sea scallops were the B E S T i"ve prpared & eaten on six(6) years. Lanette & Stanley Larsen hit the ball out of the park. Major home run hit
Since I am dealing with immunodeficiency, believe this healthy wonderful batch of seafood was precisely what the Dr ordered
Worth every $.01 tooenjoy & make this wash ashore feel closer to uor Island home...
Thank you.
Add new comment