Tom Bennett recently celebrated 50 years at Martha's Vineyard Community Services.
Mellissa Knowles

A Career of the Heart, 50 Years of Community Service

In the late 1960s Tom Bennett was a Vineyard kid adrift in Europe, lying in his sick bed at a hospital in Amsterdam.

It was the late 1960s and Tom Bennett, a Vineyard kid adrift in Europe, was lying in his sick bed at a hospital in Amsterdam when he thought about what he wanted to do with his life.

The recently discharged Air Force medic hadn’t cut his hair for months. He was running out of money. He needed work but couldn’t work, quarantined and suffering from a vicious strain of hepatitis he had picked up while traveling in Morocco. His liver was so swollen he could hardly breathe. At that moment, Mr. Bennett didn’t even know if he was going to have a life.

But if he did, he realized then and there what he wanted it to be.

“I went away to find myself,” he recalled. “And when I was in that hospital in isolation in Amsterdam, I had time to think. And I thought, I want to go back home. I want to direct my energy into being positive and helping others.

“I had these ideas of what I wanted to do organizing people. I wanted to coach Little League. I wanted to get involved in the community. And I knew I wanted to do something with people.”

Now the associate executive director at Martha’s Vineyard Community Services, Mr. Bennett has spent the past half century working with hundreds of combat veterans and thousands of Islanders, helping them cope with the traumas of their lives and past experiences — not unlike his own. Last week marked his 50th anniversary at the nonprofit, which has grown from a three-person operation in the 1960s to having more than 100 staffers and servicing more than 6,000 Islanders every year.

Family, friends and colleagues gathered at the Harbor View Hotel to celebrate him.

Fifty years and counting — Mr. Bennett has no plans to retire anytime soon.
Melissa Knowles
Fifty years and counting — Mr. Bennett has no plans to retire anytime soon.
Melissa Knowles

Mr. Bennett has spent his career working with people at Community Service, and has grown with the organization himself, from a lost youth to the bedrock of his community; from an uninitiated volunteer to the unquestioned patriarch of MVCS; from someone who didn’t know what he wanted to do, to someone who couldn’t imagine a life doing something else.

Through it all, he found a way to start a family, raise three boys, and of course, coach Little League. For him, that’s how he found purpose in life. And that’s what he tells the veterans he works with, too.

“We are driven to find meaning,” he said. “And that has to be by giving back to others. That’s why I encourage my peers to join committees. To work with Little Leaguers, to coach kids, because that’s what gives you meaning. And you feel like there is something to live for.”

Mr. Bennett grew up on the Vineyard, first on Chappy and then moving to the big city (Edgartown) when he was in grade school. Despite saving money for college, he decided to enlist in the Air Force. He became a medic, and was stationed in Maryland as a litter-bearer, carrying wounded soldiers off the plane as they returned with combat injuries from Vietnam.

The experience shaped him forever.

“You go from 19 years old to all of a sudden being pretty grown up. Life fasts forward. You can’t capture your youth again, even though you try,” he said. “I still can remember the back of the plane, seeing it come down and seeing all those guys on those litters. I saw a lot of wounded guys. It hit me.”

But being in the service provided Mr. Bennett with a new cosmopolitanism and world view. When he returned home after his bout with hepatitis, he reconnected with a mentor from his childhood, the Rev. David Smith, who introduced him to the Vineyard’s first psychiatrist and the founder of Community Services, Dr. Milton Mazer.

Dr. Mazer, a Vineyard summer resident, had been recruited to work on the Island during the height of the hippie era, as the Island became a small hot spot for young Americans who felt alienated from broader society. Some of them were suicidal. And the Vineyard largely welcomed them. In response, Dr. Mazer set up Community Services, among other things starting a hotline program that would allow youths on the Island to call if they were dealing with anything from depression to a bad LSD trip.

Mr. Bennett was chosen to lead the program. He eventually grew the hotline to include 70 volunteers, hiring people like Shirley (Tankard) Robinson to head up the Island Youth Center. His experience as a medic helped him work with young Islanders dealing with trauma.

“I was young, but I had some sophistication about the ways of the world, and people seemed to respond to me,” Mr. Bennett said. “I used to have to talk to the patients who were upset, soothe them, and try to help them. Especially the guys who I took off the plane who were wounded, who had lost parts of their bodies.”

It was at that time that Mr. Bennett met his wife, Carol Whitmarsh. They married in 1973. Mr. Bennett considers her his major support throughout his life.

“She’s the person who’s really made it possible for me to do what I’ve been able to do,” he said.

During the 1980s, Community Services went through its own set of trying times, struggling for funding and resources. Almost everyone at the organization credits Mr. Bennett with being a steady force that enabled it persevere. He has worked in a variety of capacities at the umbrella social services oragnization, spending 16 years as the programming director at the Island Counseling Center before becoming its associate executive director. Throughout the entire time, he has maintained a heavy caseload and worked specifically with combat veterans, leading veterans support groups and helping Islanders with PTSD.

He has also mentored and trained almost everyone at Community Services, from new program director Jennifer Vogel to David Araujo, who now heads the Island Intervention Center.

“There is no Martha’s Vineyard Community Services without Tom Bennett,” Mr. Araujo said. “It’s his knowledge base, his empathy, and his ability to connect with people. It’s ingrained in him and it’s something he’s developed over 50 years.”

Mr. Bennett’s process with clients developed out of the holocaust survivor Viktor Frankl’s experiences in concentration camps, called logotherapy. His office is papered in quotes from Mr. Frankl, and when Mr. Bennett speaks about his techniques he grows hyper-focused — his eyes narrow, and he is able to explain methods from exposure therapy to the Internal Family Systems model with the clarity of an elementary school teacher and the erudition of a scholar. He’s well read but has no pretensions, just a salt-of-the-earth crunch in his voice, textured with a soft, patient and caring tone.

Remember Robin Williams from Good Will Hunting? Pretty much the only thing Mr. Bennett is missing is the beard and the MIT degree.

“Tom is a God-given talent,” said Bob Tankard, who grew up with Mr. Bennett, is a fellow veteran, lifelong friend and still works with him in veteran support groups. “He is so sensitive. And he’s been doing this so long, he knows the soft spots and the hard spots. And he knows when a guy is just about ready to tip that edge, and he can bring them back. The veterans, they love him. They swear by him. And I know why.”

Spending 50 years working with combat veterans has presented its own challenges for Mr. Bennett, who said that he, too, uses the same psychotherapy techniques that he prescribes to clients.

“I’ve had to work at that over the years,” Mr. Bennett said. “It does affect you. What I’ve tried to do, and I learned this a while ago, is I try to have compassion for clients, rather than empathy. Because if you come from empathy, you are joining them. You are actually more effective if you can stay separate.”

He said over the years, he’s learned that the Island takes care of its own — an ethic that he believes is rooted in the Portuguese and Cape Verdean tradition of warmth and giving. The ability to be part of that is what has driven him for the past half century.

“When you see someone begin to have hope again, and they begin to feel like they are getting their lives back on track, it is exciting to watch. You also see some very emotionally tearing things that people go through. But I’d rather be in that position, working with people to try to help them, and achieve whatever goals they have to change their lives,” he said.

Mr. Bennett is 74. He has no plans to retire. And even if he did, Community Services has ensured that he will never truly leave the organization. During the ceremony honoring Mr. Bennett’s 50th anniversary last week, they announced that a wing of the new building will be named after him.

“I’m still working full time. I love what I do,” Mr. Bennett said. “But I want to give more. I’m trying to figure out how I can give more.”

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/21/2020 - 09:44

Permalink

Patricia Tyra Edgartown & Dania Beach,FL

I worked with Tom for about 12 summers in the 2000's, as part of a very small emergency crisis team with Island Counseling. Tom was and is a truly caring and supportive person of staff and clients. It was a pleasure to work with him but I do think and have encouraged him to consider more time for himself and family!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/21/2020 - 10:23

Permalink

Margaret Vero Beach

What a wonderful story about a giving life. God bless Mr. Bennett and all those who dedicate their time to serving others. Much thanks!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/21/2020 - 11:37

Permalink

Brenda Berube Beckman Edgartown and Wilmington, DE

I grew up in Edgartown with Tom and I have always known that he is a very kind and compassionate person. I also knew that Tom works for MVCS. What I did not know is how long Tom has worked for MVCS and all the wonderful things he has done with his life. None of it surprises me. Congratulations Tom for 50 years of service and all the fantastic work you have done!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/21/2020 - 13:40

Permalink

Jim Worden Greenfield formerly Edgartown

Congratulations Tom on such a long and committed endeavor. You are one of a kind and as Pat T noted you should find more time for yourself.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/21/2020 - 17:07

Permalink

Rick DeTucci Vero Beach, formerly Edgartown

I have known and worked with Tom since the 1980’s. It has been a privilege in both respects. Though I no longer work in our field or live on the Vineyard, I will always consider him to be one of my best friends and someone I most admire. MV you must cherish this guy. There is no other.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 02/21/2020 - 20:06

Permalink

Woody Williams MVI

Congratulations Tom, We go way, way, way back! Thanks for all the Memories, your Help, your Service to our country and your continuous serving!

"Semper Fi"

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/22/2020 - 10:56

Permalink

Hollis Engley Pocasset MA

Lovely story about a modest man dedicated to the Island community. I’ve known Tom since high school, where we played basketball together. Some of us left the Island and made lives in the larger world. Tom found his world on Martha’s Vineyard. And he’s spent 50 years making it a better place.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/22/2020 - 17:34

Permalink

Stephen Nichols Jr

Congratulations Tom, You and Shirley were the BEST for the youth center! When I saw that she passed away I thought back to those days. Many fond memories (some we won't bring up). Reading what the people who knew you better than me said, my admiration is even more than it was. Keep on doing what you do for the veterans! They need you. God Bless you. Steve

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 02/23/2020 - 10:39

Permalink

Gerald F. Plante Schenectady NY 12305

I can relate. Although by different circumstances the message is still very clear: action! Too bad there weren't more involved in their respective communities...I, for one, and my twin who lives in Newton MA, a Disability Rights Activist, Journalist, have been involved in one form of society's issues or another since we were kids! We're now 60 yrs. of age...and, no you can't have your youth again...my sentiments exactly! So, go out and change the World for the better young people of today...it's yours for the taking! What are you waiting for?!
Gerald Plante - Stockade District of Schenectady NY 12305

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 02/24/2020 - 05:49

Permalink

Jeff Baker Prospect Maine

Been 50 + years since Vietnam and as I write this I am reading about a girl I saw shot 5 ft from me July 20 1969 we could not talk about it for years (book Murder on Stage Cathy Wayne By JD Owen ) this was only one of the things tom helped me with. Thanks to Tom and the Rap group I got through a lot of things that most people don't think about. Forty years on the Vineyard and Tom will always be my friend.1st Force Recon Radio op 1968-1969

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/14/2025 - 15:23

Permalink

Skip Rusbosin Mount Airy Maryland

What a wonderful article - it is a joy to experience your life’s journey via the

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/14/2025 - 15:28

Permalink

Skip Rusbosin Mount Airy Maryland

What a wonderful article - it is a joy to experience your life’s journey via the Vineyard Gazette. God bless you and your family. Being a 100% service connected disabled Vietnam war veteran- and your long time friend - this article has brought me joy and peace.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.