Main bus routes like the #13 are still running, but many other routes have been cut or curtailed for the off-season.
Jeanna Shepard

VTA Service Cutbacks See Pushback from Riders, Drivers

<p>As curtailed off-season service begins on the Island&rsquo;s only public bus system, the Vineyard Transit Authority is seeing pushback from riders, as well as drivers and their new union.

As curtailed off-season service begins on the Island’s only public bus system this fall for the first time in years, the Vineyard Transit Authority is seeing pushback from riders, as well as drivers and their new union.

Petitioners are at bus stops gathering signatures to protest the route changes.
Jeanna Shepard
Petitioners are at bus stops gathering signatures to protest the route changes.
Jeanna Shepard

A union-backed petition began circulating last week by a citizen group calling itself the Coalition to Restore Vineyard Transportation.

“The coalition is working on developing community support for riders and drivers around the service cutbacks and the VTA’s ongoing lack of transparency and accountability,” said Susanna Sturgis, an organizer. “We are asking people to talk to their selectmen.”

The first in a series of off-season service reductions began on Sept. 29. More cutbacks are due to take effect Dec. 1. Transit authority leaders said trimming routes is necessary to rein in a projected $1 million budget deficit for the coming fiscal year.

Higher insurance premiums, a lease renewal on the VTA operations center in the airport business park, and wage increases for drivers under the first union contract inked this summer have added up on the expense side of the ledger, VTA leaders said.

Information about the route changes are posted on the VTA website, but many riders said while winter cutbacks were expected and announced, reduced fall service came as a surprise.

Curtailed service this fall includes fewer buses on routes and also earlier shutdown times, with most service on down-Island routes ending at 6 p.m.

When winter service begins on Dec. 1, more routes will be closed, especially up-Island and there will be no service on Sundays.

VTA administrator Angela Grant confirmed that the service reductions are the most severe in the last 10 years.

But she said this is not a normal year, pointing to rising costs and falling ridership. A tense 30-day driver strike last summer concluded with a new negotiated contract with the Amalgamated Transit Union guaranteeing higher wages and benefits for most year-round drivers.

Ms. Grant said VTA ridership has dropped by some five to 10 per cent over the last seven years, at least partly a result of the rising popularity of Uber and Lyft ride sharing services.

The annual operating budget of the VTA is around $6 million; about 63 per cent of revenues come from state and federal grants.

Mark Snider, a member of the VTA advsiory board from Edgartown, said reduced service through next April is expected to shave $700,000 from the $1 million projected deficit.

More than 500 signatures had been collected by Thursday this week.
Jeanna Shepard
More than 500 signatures had been collected by Thursday this week.
Jeanna Shepard

“Nobody likes to have service cuts,” he said. “But it doesn’t make financial sense to keep the routes running.”

He said the transit authority had been subsidizing riders to the tune of up to $29 per rider per day on less-traveled routes off the main arteries. He also said the hope is that the cutbacks are short-lived.

“Hopefully this is a one time reduction because of the events of this year,” Mr. Snider said. “And that service can rebound next summer and into next winter.”

Many Islanders who rely on or frequently use public transit, from workers to high school students, are unhappy about the changes.

“It is going to be a hardship for people that depend on the bus, especially those who need it to get to and from work,” said Carlton Crocker, the community rider representative on the VTA advisory board.

Mr. Crocker takes the bus to his job at Menemsha Texaco. Now that he can no longer do that, he said he has purchased an electric bike for the commute.

“I try to use the bus as much as I can, because I’m a proponent of riding the bus,” he said. “But when they make it hard, you have to find other ways to get around.”

The VTA advisory board has announced a public consumer advisory meeting planned for Nov. 6 at 10 a.m. in the meeting room at Woodside II in Oak Bluffs.

“All are welcome,” the VTA website says.

Petitioners, who are canvassing Islanders online and on the buses with paper petitions, said this week they had amassed more than 500 signatures to take to the board.

“We are a combination of drivers, riders and interested community members who want to restore service to the Island,” Ms. Sturgis said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 10/25/2019 - 18:26

Permalink

Jack conway Sarasota

Another hardship for those that live year round onthe island. We did this for 7 years and when the visitors left,so did many of the restaurants, stores and services that islanders depended on.
One advantage we had was discounted tickets for the ferry. Looks like this may help by charging visitors more to use the service during june through october.
Problem is they use their cars but a surcharge can be assesed to cover shortfall and when implemented may even reduce cars coming over. Tough call but islanders deserve a break.

David Vineyard Haven

It’s always the answer to charge visitors for the shortfall of all the problems that happen outside of the high season on the island. Part of the problem is I’m sure a lot of the natives don’t even pay their fair share of taxes that help keep the island going. In the Summer a lot is paid in cash and cash doesn’t get reported to Uncle Sam. Let’s not forget that part of the equation when adding up all the short falls that happen in the budget that should keep the island going year round. I just get sick that every answer is tack it on to the summer people....

Pilar NYC

I agree That islanders but I also don’t think that it should be more expensive for people to come to the island during the summer and fall. The prices on the island are getting way out of hand. Martha’s Vineyard was set up to be a seasonal Tourist destination that was affordable and now it’s turning out to be a playground for the richest of the rich.

bridget aquinnah

I agree with both David and Pilar. The constant soaking of tourists has gotten out of control. $20/day parking on weekends during the summer, the 60% increase in bus fares not to mention the new, exorbitant rental tax. I am surprised the business community has not fought back at all of these increases. Economics can be a zero sum game and if a vacationer has more taxes and fees loaded upon them, they will likely spend less elsewhere (restaurants come to mind). Or worse, they will vacation somewhere less expensive. We can't continually complain the Island is just a playground for the rich when we created policies that ensure it.

Chris OB Oak Bluffs

Gosh, I will never understand this island. So many want to make every solution a soaking of the seasonal vacationers. This is what keeps us running - all the money made by seasonal travelers, all the money the trades make in building and keeping summer residences maintained, all the money on seafood which keeps our fisherman in business, all could be gone. Think cost of living is high now? I got news for you, the Vineyard is great, but it’s not the only place for people to go. They pay a ridiculously high rental fee, a new tax, the steamship, exorbitant food prices, etc. The part-time owners pay taxes and a land bank fee. All of that money goes to benefit us, yes, even the steamship money. Imagine what the cost would be for the boats if less people came?

So please, stop it already. Yes, it sucks to have traffic and tons of people - but it’s for 2 -3 months. That’s it!! They rest of the year it’s all ours. Most of this island makes enough money in that time to carry them through the whole year! Let’s support and welcome summer visitors, not seek and destroy them.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 10/26/2019 - 11:00

Permalink

T Bone Oak Bluffs

We’ve seen data on the number of routes and drivers cut back. Were there comparable headcount cutbacks/salary reductions in the administrative/executive areas?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 10/26/2019 - 16:46

Permalink

bs Oak Bluffs

We should demand to know how much of the deficit is related to the years of legal bills and high paid consultants the VTA used to fight the union. My understanding it's around $700k, maybe more.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 10/27/2019 - 14:46

Permalink

Jane Edgartown

PUBLIC transportation is a SERVICE - regardless if it's profitable. Period.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 10/28/2019 - 06:00

Permalink

here we go again edg

Would those riders opposed about the service cutbacks be willing to pay a higher fare for restored service? Are the fares artificially low? Is it possible to see more federal and state grant money obtained? Are the businesses that depend upon subsidized public transportation to transport their underpaid workers willing to kick in a few bucks towards winter service?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 10/28/2019 - 10:14

Permalink

anne sylvester oak bluffs

this story is a little lopsided. Fails to mention huges raises given to top VTA administrators. Failed to point out how administrator Angela Grant stated at a public meeting that new lease cost $100 grand -- actual cost less than a third that amount, according to figures uncovered in a FOIA demand. Union busting activities like flying Union fighting specialist Greg Dash back and forth from Pennsylvania = upwards of $350 of taxpayer transit $$$$. Routes are being cut because Angela Grant mismanaged public funds put in her care. Boards of Selectmen are going to be picking up the VTA mess with your tax dollars; they need to hire a new administrator before any more costly damage is done.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 10/29/2019 - 10:04

Permalink

Ann Noyes West TIsbury

Don’t forget the Seniors and their medical appointments on the Cape. No longer are we able to board the medical van at Park and Ride to be bused to nearby locations on the Cape. Now the only medical van is to Boston. Our appointments are monthly on the Cape to doctors who have satellite locations. Last month we boarded the ferry at 7AM, waited for the Cape Transit bus in Woods Hole, transferred to a medical van which took us to our appointment in Sandwich at noon and returned the same route, arriving home on the Vineyard just before dark. An all day’s journey with much advanced planning. We are in our 80’s, but luckily we are active and in good health. What do others do who cannot maneuver by themselves? Shame on the Vineyard Transit Authority for dropping this very needed service.

Diane Edgartown

This should not be with all the services and donated money to the island charities we should be able to take care of our seniors. That is disgraceful. I am not in the know but hope someone who is will tackle this problem immediately. We should be able to provide private transportation in vans that don’t take all day. Why are there not Doctors available on the vineyard?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 10/29/2019 - 10:33

Permalink

Susanna J. Sturgis West Tisbury

I hope the Gazette will do a little investigating on this story instead of just quoting press releases and official statements. The VTA's financial situation is not clear at all, and its advisory board has been less than active in its oversight role. Why, for instance, is Mark Snider, the newly appointed Edgartown representative on the board, merely quoting figures put out by the VTA administration? In the spring, as negotiations faltered and a strike loomed, the board didn't even meet. The July meeting came about only because riders, drivers, and the public pressed for it. Those of us who attended advisory board meetings this past summer were shocked by the nastiness and/or the lack of preparation of some board members. The Vineyard is not being well served by the current board and VTA administration, and accurate financial information is hard to come by. What a great opportunity for the Gazette to show why investigative journalism is in the public interest!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 10/29/2019 - 11:37

Permalink

VTA Watcher OB

I went to the VTA's website and looked at their posted financial statements for the year ended June 30th, 2018. I noticed the opinion from the independent auditor was dated October 12, 2018. Based on last year's date I would expect the auditor has already rendered his opinion for the financial statements ending June 30th, 2019 by now. Those financials need to be posted soon so we can all see what extraordinary costs were incurred.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.