Crew members walk over the damaged bow section of the MV Iyanough as they depart the boat after it arrived back at SSA docks in Hyannisport in June 2017.
Steve Heaslip/Cape Cod Times

Coast Guard Report Details Cause of Ferry Crash

<p>Critical errors by the captain and pilot and an operations manual that was out of date were factors in the crash of the Steamship Authority ferry Iyanough in Hyannis two years ago.</p>

Critical errors by both the captain and pilot and an operations manual that was out of date and out of compliance were all factors in the crash of the Steamship Authority ferry Iyanough the night it struck a jetty in Hyannis two years ago, a Coast Guard investigation has found.

The 156-foot high-speed catamaran was inbound from Nantucket on the night of June 16, 2017, with 48 people and nine crew members on board when it missed the turn into Lewis Bay and ran up on the rocks of the Hyannisport jetty. Fifteen people were transported to the Cape Cod Hospital for treatment. The allision (a martime term used for a crash that is not a collision) caused severe damage to the catamaran’s three hulls beneath the waterline. Damages were later estimated at $450,000.

Capt. Karl Riddar was at the helm along with pilot Thomas Manley. Both cleared drug and alcohol testing later.

But a 50-page report released last week by the Coast Guard said among other things that the pilot had not been on board the vessel in 10 months and was unfamiliar with its operating systems.

Weather conditions were poor with high winds, fog and rain the report noted. When the captain asked the pilot to turn on the spotlights, he was unable to locate the controls due to his unfamiliarity with the vessel, the report said. The captain became distracted with helping the pilot find the spotlight controls, and mistook a pole and two sailboats for the buoys, which were arranged in a similar structure. Consequently, the captain never turned into the channel as he should have, the report said.

The investigation also cited problems related to the vessel’s radar, reduced visibility due to weather conditions and time of day, and the speed of the vessel — which “was at the high end of the Iyanough’s safe limit.”

The report found further that the operations manual for the Iyanough had not been updated in 10 years and lacked suggested provisions for crew refresher training.

“The operations manual was missing suggested content . . . in particular crew training and refresher training,” the report said in part. “. . . the first officer . . . had not been aboard the vessel in 10 months and could not operate vital shipboard systems. Annual verification and five-year plan approval could have caught this gap . . .,” it also said.

Pilot is the term used by the SSA for what the Coast Guard calls first officer, whose responsibilities include navigating and landing the vessel under direct supervision of the captain.

Formally called Findings of Concern, the report recommends that the SSA adopt new protocols to update its operation manuals every five years, among other things.

“The investigation identified several causal factors that contributed to the marine casualty, including the first officer’s lack of familiarity and training with the vessel,” Coast Guard spokesman Barry Lane told the Gazette.

Citing ongoing litigation, Steamship Authority spokesman Sean Driscoll said he could not comment specifically on what steps the boat line plans to take in response to the report.

“The Steamship Authority uses any incident, large or small, as an opportunity to learn and improve its operations,” Mr. Driscoll said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 06/17/2019 - 13:31

Permalink

What could go wrong?

What could go wrong with a professional accountant at the helm of the SSA during precisely that decade when operations manuals were not being updated? Why update vessel operations manuals, how could that help the bottom line?

T Bone Oak Bluffs

Any operating company run by a bean counter is doomed by myopic vision. Cost cutting always leads their mentality and decision making. Get a real CEO in there. Ridiculous. How many more incidents do we need? Lwt him get his generous pension and move on with a pro at the helm.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 06/17/2019 - 15:38

Permalink

Bridge Proponent Woods Hole

Build a bridge to each island and charge the same rate it costs to travel on the SSA
How quick will the bridge pay for itself
Run those numbers and you would be amazed

Ten years would do it Cape to Vineyard

Sunshine Skyway Bridge is a 6.7km-long (4.14 miles) bridge built over Tampa Bay, Florida, in USA. Its height is 430 feet (131 m) and is said to be the longest cable stayed concrete bridge in the world. It’s one of the most spectacular bridges in the world.

Construction cost in 1987 was $244 million. That's approx. $500 million today. Even at $650 million, that's only ten years of Steamship Authority revenue for the Vineyard (SSA revenue is approx $100 million year, 2/3 of which is Vineyard traffic).

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/18/2019 - 06:43

Permalink

CapeLange Brewster

Any boater knows this report is BS. The weather was fine. A chart plotter or radar could have been used to avoid this accident. They had both.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/18/2019 - 07:23

Permalink

Jim Menemsha

Class

Topic : Thinking

Repeat after me:

Accounting is Static

Operations are Dynamic

Static is Reactive

Dynamic requires Proactive

That is all...

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.