<p>The state of public bathrooms, the public beach, loitering and noise from the bowling alley were all aired at the annual summer taxpayer meeting.
Oak Bluffs summer residents packed the library meeting room Tuesday to register concerns about their part-time home and talk with town officials before summer ends. The state of public bathrooms, the public beach, loitering and noise from the bowling alley were all among concerns aired.
But the possibility of a residential tax exemption for year-round residents was a primary worry.
The tax exemption would lower property taxes for year-round residents, shifting more of the burden onto summer homeowners. A recent analysis done by the town estimated that 1,600 of the town’s 4,550 properties would qualify for the residential exemption.
“Those of us who are summer residents are very concerned about that,” said summer resident Dawn McKenna.
Ms. McKenna and several others asked that if the town does pursue a residential exemption, town leaders should seek comment from summer residents.
Selectman and board chairman Brian Packish said the town is only in the very early stages of exploring the idea.
“The selectmen have worked with the board of assessors to begin a discussion and exploration,” Mr. Packish said. “I’m told it’s about a 14 to 16-month process to even investigate.”
He said extensive property data is needed to understand the potential impact of the exemption, and said the decision would not be made without seeking summer resident perspectives. “We’ll need a tremendous amount of public input before we take any step along those lines,” Mr. Packish said.
The town’s principal assessor MacGregor Anderson and town leaders also said they would update the website regularly, so summer residents could follow from afar.
Applying a residential exemption would require more assessor staff time. Selectmen plan to ask the town to fund an administrative assistant position for the assessor’s office at next year’s town meeting, according to the assessors’ website.
On the Island, Tisbury is the only town with a residential exemption.
“It will be a very exhaustive process,” Mr. Packish said. “If nothing else, if we get to the end and decide it’s not a direction that we want to go . . . it’s an opportunity for us to learn a lot more about who lives in our town, how they live in our town, who rents, who doesn’t rent, all those types of things, and it will help us guide a lot of conversations moving forward.”
Summer residents also voiced concerns about the state of public bathrooms.
“It’s kind of embarrassing to bring someone, for the first impression of Oak Bluffs to be the public bathrooms downtown,” said Byron Barnett. He also said noise from the bowling alley dumping glass bottles was a nuisance at night.
Tené Shavers said reports last spring of squatters living in temporary town buildings left her family concerned for their summer home. Mr. Packish said the buildings are now occupied by school administrators, and that they will be needed eventually when a new town hall is built.
“The break-in that happened there was we had some people who unfortunately didn’t have a place to live, and they were there and they were warm. They got into them and they stayed for a short period of time,” Mr. Packish said.
Amelie Loyot said freight trucks have been parking and idling along the seawall.
“We’re all looking at mobile billboards. They are running the trucks for like, hours, and it is loud,” she said.
Selectmen said the trucks are likely waiting there before taking the ferry and need to stay running for refrigeration purposes. Police chief Erik Blake said the road is a state road, and vehicles are free to park there for less than 72 hours.
Selectman Gail Barmakian asked whether selectmen could limit commercial vehicle parking in the area.
“They’re going to end up in downtown,” Mr. Blake said. “They’re doing it because it’s easy to stay there and get to the boat.”
In other business, after a lengthy public hearing, selectmen approved a request from Noman’s owner Doug Abdelnour Jr. to include some outdoor patio space in the restaurant’s liquor license. Mr. Abdelnour bought the restaurant, formerly Lola’s, last year.
The restaurant is located in a residential area, and a large contingent of neighbors came to the meeting to express misgivings about any expansion of the establishment’s liquor license.
“The operation is no longer just a restaurant, but an outdoor entertainment business,” said Alfred Woollacott 3rd, leader of the Harthaven Neighborhood Association. “The restaurant is allowed only because it’s grandfathered to operate in a residentially zoned area.”
But Mr. Abdelnour said the changes did not represent an expansion of the license, but an acknowledgement that people who are served drinks inside the restaurant may wander outside.
“Lola’s was a bar. It was a restaurant. It had outside seating. It had music. That’s exactly what we’re doing. Except we’re doing it in a manner that starts at 9 a.m. and closes around 9:30 p.m.” he said.
Selectmen stipulated that alcohol may not be served outdoors and that the restaurant submit a detailed description of its operations for the record.
Selectmen also approved a contract with the EMS employees through the International Association of Firefighters Local 5137 Union, and approved the fourth annual Martha’s Vineyard Marathon for May 16, 2020.

Comments
Spent 3 days in Nantucket
T Bone OBSpent 3 days in Nantucket last week. Their public bathrooms were spotless and convenient. Trash barrels were plentiful and not overflowing. I wish the town or a downtown business association could take some pride in treating our guests like they weren't visiting a third world country.
Agree! Nantucket presents
LWS OBCCMDAgree! Nantucket presents itself extremely well in this regard. Would it be asking to much to having 3 recycling barrels at trash locations in our downtown (high tourists trafficked) areas?
Surely, that would not break our budget?
How could this possibly be
Mike WTHow could this possibly be fair to second home owners. They can't vote. They pay a disproportional of taxes already because they use little or no town services. Don't have children in school (MV schools are some of the most expensive in the state per student)
Additionally, if the town lowers the taxes on island residents how will the already dire shortfall be funded? Raise the seasonal % rate way higher to make up for the loss?
Seasonal residents of Tisbury are disgusted with this practice of killing the golden goose.
I get it, the perception is the seasonal residents can afford it, after all it is a second home when most of us can barley afford one.
Yes it may generate additional income, but at what cost.
I'm going goose hunting.
Illogical
Anybody can sell their
Tom TisburyAnybody can sell their seasonal residence if they feel they are treated unfairly
Right, and any full time
Bob OBRight, and any full time resident can move off the Island if they feel it's getting too expensive to live here.
So Tom you believe in
Pat OBSo Tom you believe in “Taxation without Representation”? As a summer resident I pay as much taxes as my year round neighbors Yet I have no right to vote for or against raising or lowering my taxes.
Exactly. They pay higher
Jake OBExactly. They pay higher insurance premiums because the house is vacation property or not lived in year round by the owner. I don't hear any complaints about that
It is "taxation without
Dan ObIt is "taxation without representation" by choice. We would love to have more people living here year round. It is by choice that they are not.
Maybe this will be good incentive for more people to make MV their permanent residence?
it is becoming increasingly
johnit is becoming increasingly more difficult for people who provide vital services like teachers, social workers, hospice providers, janitors etc. who don't make enough money to offset the extra expenses required to live here. I would think part of the investigation will be an exemption for people who qualify based on income. If they are forced to leave I fear much worse problems then a few golden geese flying away
True Tom,
Mike WTTrue Tom,
You must be a Tisbury resident getting the exemption.
After all the hard work scraping money together to purchase a dream, that is the rhetoric of a town resident.
Shameful.
Must be nice sitting fat and getting discounted services on others hard earned money.
It is great! and we are going
Tom TisburyIt is great! and we are going to push to have the exemption increased to the highest level of 30% which many towns use in Massachusetts go to the state web page and get informed we are on the low end at only 18%. I am not going to get in an a contest if it is right or not its the law and we use it, you must be very happy that you pay full freight, I am happy for you.
It’s just a matter of time
PAulli D EdgartownIt’s just a matter of time before the arrogance of the so called ‘island people’ push the summer home owners to a different location. then we can have our island back with no jobs for landscapes, painter, construction, waiters, etc. We the island people need to understand that our economy is based on vacation and summer residences. You alienate them, let’s see who starts to complain about lack of jobs, and OUR taxes will have to increase. No exemptions for island full time residences.
Mike, it is nice try the
Tom TisburyMike, it is nice try the water
This is what I have to put up
SamThis is what I have to put up with. For 8 years now these self entitled rich vineyard residents have nothing but disdain for the trucks and the guys working out of them. We come here year round no matter the weather, try to negotiate through narrow streets without hitting anything. Walking long distances to make deliveries because of the lack of loading zones and the ones that are there get taken up by the same self entitled asshats that complain about the trucks. So here are my suggestions. 1) put your money where your complaining suck hole is and build a lot for the trucks to wait for their boats that's out of your eyesight. 2) become a self sufficient island and grow your own food, make your own clothes, drill for your own oil and gas. Make your own medications and there would be no need for the trucks to come over in the first place. Or 3), which is my favorite, move somewhere else.
Isn't taxation without
Mark EdgartownIsn't taxation without representation what we went to war with England over...would tread carefully.
Why can’t the trucks wait up
LarryWhy can’t the trucks wait up island out of sight... they really are a eyesore while I’m going for a walk with my cat Lardy
seasonal residents
bobseasonal residents complaining about trucks, traffic and noise? i guess they forget they are contributing to it as well. they tell islanders to stop whining and that they need the tourists and then they complain about the same things
a seasonal nimby is worse than a permanent one
Tired of the commentary of
Susan of OB Oak BluffssTired of the commentary of those who choose to live on MV -- yes, it's expensive, but so are other areas of the U.S. off the island. I pay taxes equivalent to someone who owns a fully winterized house, yet, mine, a cottage, not winterized, no chance of staying year round, so no chance to put demand on the school system, etc. during 6 plus mos. of the year. My abode, been in our family for 85 years.......so do not tell me my vote doesn't count. We vs. them is pathetic....how about US and making MV and OB the best it can be for all.
Those with no representation,
MarieThose with no representation, who use less town services, should pay more in taxes? Maybe the schools and other services should be put on a fiscal diet. Live within your means.
Add new comment