<p>Steamship Authority governors took plenty of heat in Falmouth Tuesday evening at a public hearing on design changes for the new terminal in Woods Hole.</p>
Steamship Authority governors saw a strong — and heated — turnout in Falmouth Tuesday evening for a public hearing on design changes for a new terminal building in Woods Hole.
More than 100 people attended the meeting at the Falmouth High School auditorium, called to seek community suggestions for making the building more acceptable to local residents.
But far from finding accord, the meeting appeared to only heighten the growing tension and feelings of mistrust between the boat line and unhappy residents of Woods Hole, as a $60 million years-long terminal reconstruction project grinds along.
Architects Chris Iweks and Liam Davis of BIA Studio, the firm designing the new terminal, attended the meeting along with Falmouth selectmen Susan Moran and Douglas Brown, and town manager Julian Suso.
“It is a very good and sizable crowd, and I’m glad you’re here,” said board chairman and Barnstable governor Robert Jones at the outset.
“Give us your thoughts and ideas.”
What the SSA board and management received instead was an airing of grievances that lasted until the Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket governors left to catch boats home, forcing adjournment for lack of a quorum shortly after 7 p.m.
Several who rose to speak took aim at a 79-page staff report posted by SSA general manager Robert Davis on the boat line’s website one day earlier.
The report gives a point-by-point response to about 130 emailed comments on the building, and concludes that location and size — the two most controversial aspects of the design — would not change.
Mr. Davis summarized his lengthy report at the start of the meeting.
Then frustrated Falmouth and Woods Hole residents took turns assailing boat line officials for soliciting public comments, when nearly all the building decisions have already been made.
“Mr. Davis, you started by closing a whole lot of doors in your opening comments, and when you read your recommended final decision, that closes the rest of them,” said Susan Shephard.
“Get ready for a big building, folks,” she said as she left the microphone.
Judy Laster said the staff report “seemed to misrepresent things that happened in the past” and responded only to comments emailed directly to the SSA.
“There were over 1,000 comments submitted in the form of a petition that went to the Steamship Authority,” and those should have been considered as well, Ms. Laster said.
She charged the boat line with estimating the effect of proposed changes, such as relocating the building or making it smaller, “only in the negative impact that would have on the bottom line of the Steamship Authority.
“The bottom line is not just about the Steamship Authority,” Ms. Laster said.
The audience clapped for every speaker, despite an early plea by Mr. Jones to withhold applause.
“We are here to express our common feelings,” said Woods Hole resident Damien Kuffler.
“A public meeting like this should have been held five years ago. You have never made an attempt before this to address the issues,” said John Woodwell.
“We started this exercise years ago and there were hearings, public hearings,” Mr. Jones responded. “The process has been in the public eye. It’s in the press, and every agenda we have discusses this.”
Public testimony strayed into complaints about traffic, especially early-morning trucks on the Woods Hole Road.
“Hazardous materials come down Woods Hole Road every day and we only need one spill,” said Barbara Blair. Others said they were woken daily by the sound of truck brakes.
Falmouth governor Kathryn Wilson said she agreed the new terminal building should be smaller.
“If this building was planned in any of the other port communities, we’d be having the same conversation there,” Ms. Wilson said.
Regarding the controversy, she added, “there’s the building, and then there’s the process of communication. We’re not set up as a town to communicate really well.”
But she also conceded that the Woods Hole Community Association, a group that worked with the SSA on the terminal design along with the business association, may not reflect wider sentiment in the village. “The community association does not represent all of Woods Hole and the business association doesn’t either,” Ms. Wilson said. “That makes it difficult for the Steamship Authority to have a reliable read on what the community wants.”
New Bedford governor Moira Tierney said she believes what the community wants is not to have the boat line “in its present formation, including freight traffic,” in Woods Hole at all.
“To the extent that you do not want such a presence of the Steamship Authority in your community — and I get the sense that is what you’re saying, without really saying it — you should let us know,” Ms. Tierney told the audience.
“I think you have to be straightforward with the board and straightforward with us. That would be a significant change in the way the Steamship Authority is structured — and in the way we fulfill our first duty, which, we can’t forget, is to serve the residents of Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket,” she said, adding: “The way I read the enabling act, that is our first priority.”
The meeting ended abruptly when Vineyard governor Marc Hanover and Nantucket governor Robert Ranney left to catch evening ferries.
Mr. Davis had recommended that the board request a new design from the architects, but without a quorum, there was no vote.

Comments
Re "“We started this exercise
Islander TooRe "“We started this exercise years ago and there were hearings, public hearings,” Mr. Jones responded. “The process has been in the public eye. It’s in the press, and every agenda we have discusses this.”---Yes, they come over to the Vineyard and a meeting was held at the High School, and the whole plan was a fait-accomplie and they were not interested in what Vineyarders had to say. They were totally on broadcast, not receive. The only reason for the SSA to be there was to inform the public of what it had already decided. It is a misrepresentation to say that this process has been open to the public and responsive to public input. The architects are clueless and they produced a terrible design. The project should have been given to local architects with some sensitivity. The SSA has grandiose ideas and needs to cut down to size and brought down to earth in terms of being forced to adhere to its mission. The new administration building at Palmer Avenue sez it all. Top-heavy admin and not enough attention to actually running the boats properly. IT is too bad that the genuine issues regarding an inappropriate building get mixed up in Woods Hole with residents' beefs about traffic on the State Road that goes to Woods Hole. But if the SSA had handled the building project with more common sense they would not now be fielding traffic and garbage griping at a meeting meant to be about the building. EARTH TO SSA: HIRE A LOCAL ARCHITECTURAL FIRM TO DESIGN THE TERMINAL.
Well Stated.
Stephen G Devine Oak BluffsWell Stated.
Mr. Hanover had to leave at 7
Lame excuseMr. Hanover had to leave at 7:00PM to catch a ferry? There were three more ferries to the Vineyard that Tuesday evening: 7:30, 8:30, and 9:45PM. We thought you ran the ferries and knew the schedule.
You forget, last boat into
Big Guy Oak bluffsYou forget, last boat into Oak Bluffs leaves WH @ 7:30 pm. Mr.Hanover can’t leave later and go into VH, would be a inconvenience for him
It took him 79 pages to say
ECS edgartownIt took him 79 pages to say 'it will not change' so fire him.
In a time when disruption is
ECS edgartownIn a time when disruption is key to the way every business must operate if it is to survive, It is high time for serious disruption at the SSA. Unfortunately the leadership of the SSA [Board of Governors and management] and the US Congress are afflicted with the same disease, arterial sclerosis so there will be no solution in the foreseeable future. There are many, many variations of the current system but what there isn’t is much leadership to push forward creative thinking.
The distance from Logan to WH is 83 miles; from Logan to New Bedford 55; Providence NB is 31 and the distance doesn't tell the story of the traffic issues. Sort of like putting a single new modern Stop and Shop on Barnes Rd, how intelligent does one have to be to try regular ferry service from NB?
The auto rate would be higher, similar to Nantucket but that would reduce the cars on the Vineyard. If the SSA had competent management with today’s data processing capabilities they could select out year round residents / property owners who would be the only one's allowed to use Woods Hole ferry facilities [or get a special rate while the rate for others would be raised].
How about no trucks in Woods Hole [with the exception of Stop and Shop-don't shop at Cronig's not because they are so over-priced but because they pulled that stunt in VH with the attempt to remodel the S&S-typical of ‘leadership’ on the Vineyard]?
Yes, there would be plenty of disruption but that is life today and tomorrow and when the process is well thought out and managed it creates something better.
Why can't they put the
WashAbhorred EdgartownWhy can't they put the facilities other than ticket selling, etc. at Palmer? I seem to recall they have a rather extensive shuttle bus system between the two locations. I bet if SSA employees and management had to depend on those shuttles the service would get a whole lot better.
No way SSA would consider any
Gina Menemsha/NYCNo way SSA would consider any move that’s efficient
Agree they should have hired a local architect firm for the sensitive surroundings being stepped up
Another example of how tone deaf SSA management is
Why not build the new
Throwinitoutthere VineyardWhy not build the new terminal into the hill where the freight shed and employee parking are? Certainly better for the view. Convenient for three lanes like a drive through, one outside lane to pass through and two covered, one for trucks and one for cars. Opens the entire lot for parking and staging. They should not block the view of the slips for the people in line, it's already frustrating trying to figure out what chance you have of getting on a boat.
Add new comment