Tribe's Casino Plans Stay Mostly Under Wraps

<p>An Aquinnah selectman met with the chairman of the Wampanoag tribe to discuss the current status of the bingo hall project. But there were few new details.</p>

With uncertainty surrounding the plans by the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah) to build a class II gaming facility in town, Aquinnah selectman Jim Newman confirmed this week that he had met with tribal chairman Cheryl Andrews-Maltais to discuss the current status of the project. But there were few new details to report.

At the regular selectmen’s meeting Tuesday, Mr. Newman informed the other two board members that he had met last week with Ms. Andrews-Maltais, as well as town counsel Ron Rappaport and an attorney for the tribe.

“They expect to be up and running in the summer,” Mr. Newman said. “This is the first time we have sat down and talked. It was a very good meeting. Nothing has been signed or anything else. Rather, just discussion at this point. But it opened the way for us to start having a good dialogue.”

The tribe was cleared to build a class II gaming facility, or bingo hall, by the U.S. Supreme Court last January. Since then, few details have emerged about the plans, although in September the tribe’s gaming faction announced a partnership with an Oklahoma Native American gaming operation owned by the Chickasaw Nation.

According to reports from tribal members, Global Gaming Solutions has agreed to invest $12 million to build a 10,000-square-foot bingo facility on a 17-acre piece of land that abuts State Road between Moshup Trail and Black Brook Road.

The land currently remains undeveloped.

On Tuesday selectman Juli Vanderhoop aired her frustration over the lack of details that emerged from Mr. Newman’s meeting with the tribe.

“So basically the meeting was very minute, it sounds like,” she said. “It sounds narrow in scope and everything else — that’s no further than we were six months ago.”

Mr. Newman replied that any meeting was progress.

“Well, I’m glad you feel that way,” Ms. Vanderhoop replied. “I don’t. There’s a lack of understanding here that is quite profound for me.”

She continued: “I will state it that I’m not comfortable not knowing what our neighbor, what my tribe, has going on up its sleeve. And this is embarrassing. I don’t understand why none of our questions, agreements, letters, et cetera are being answered. And I’m upset.”

Mr. Newman also stressed the importance of renewing a town-tribe public safety agreement which has lapsed. He said town and tribal leaders met to work on a new agreement approximately two years ago, but never signed the document because of the pending litigation over the casino rights issue.

“We definitely have to have a meeting about the town-tribe public safety agreement and have that re-ratified,’ Mr. Newman said. “We should probably send another letter to them explaining to them that it’s very important we sit down and do it ASAP.”

Aquinnah fire chief Simon Bollin, who attended the meeting, said according to the current agreement he only has to respond to fires at residences on tribal lands, not public buildings such as the community center or water treatment plant.

“That’s what’s been signed,” the fire chief said. “That said, if there were a fire in any one of those buildings, we would have to put it out. We just couldn’t sit by and let it burn.”

Selectmen decided to send a letter to tribe requesting a meeting to renew the public safety agreement. Town administrator Jeffrey Madison said the letter would go in the mail sometime next week.

Board members also agreed that the next meeting with tribal leaders should include the other two selectmen.

“I think perhaps we should ask if we can have a meeting with the whole board?” Mr. Newman said.

“I think that’s a good idea,” Ms. Vanderhoop said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 12/12/2018 - 15:41

Permalink

curious cathy

Please tell me this project won’t leave the tribe indebted to an off-island entity if it fails!?

I’m all for the tribe exercising their rights. What kind of business will really be able to survive and benefit the residents and operators year road upisland?

Let’s find a common way forward.

anonymous 2

Certainly not true. This isn't a football stadium. The tribes fund their own projects and assuming the project has the legal authority to build and the area can support it, debt funding is not hard to find. Plus, the tribe is partnered with another highly reputable tribe in the development. Indebtedness to tax payers here is not an issue.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 12/12/2018 - 17:55

Permalink

Mr. B Chilmark

The traffic should be just wonderful--especially as it all has to go through a school zone in Chilmark and right by the summer camp at the Community Center. And the Tauck Tours buses idling along the way.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/14/2018 - 17:05

Permalink

Lawyer

The Supreme Court did not "clear[]" way for the bingo hall. The Supreme Court declined to review the decision from the First Circuit, but such denials express nothing about the merits of the case. The First Circuit's opinion cleared the construction of the bingo hall; it was made final when the Supreme Court declined to hear the appeal.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 12/15/2018 - 10:36

Permalink

Rt. Hon. James van der Hoop Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

The important thing to remember here is : My tribe is the last of 6 tribes that thrived on Noepe. All but a handful of the other tribes remain on the island. The Wampanoag Tribe of Aquinnah is a sovereign nation with the absolute right of self determination, basically, mind your business non-tribal members. And, to "Bill" in OB - You are correct, the Wampanoag Tribe IS funded by US Tax dollar AS IT SHOULD BE. That is all.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 12/15/2018 - 11:18

Permalink

Anonymous

While SCOTUS did clear the tribe to build the gaming hall on tribal lands that were taken into trust by an act of Congress that established them as a Tribe in the 1980s, that is not their plan.

Rather, they intend to build the gaming hall on land abutting State Road, which the tribe purchased just a few years ago and was taken into Trust by the DOI. As such, they will be facing the same legal challenges that the Mashpee Tribe has faced- and lost- in building their casino.

If they were not a recognized tribe when IGRA was passed (which they weren’t), then the DOI is overstepping and cannot take that land into trust (Interestingly, they have refused to support their sister tribe in this endeavor.)

Just gonna be more and more legal battles. Buckle in. Disclaimer: I’ m not a lawyer, so it would be great if some lawyers weigh in.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.