<p>Martha’s Vineyard residents who wanted to talk about the Steamship Authority’s latest fare hikes at the boat line’s monthly meeting Tuesday were required to wait.
Martha’s Vineyard residents who wanted to talk about the Steamship Authority’s latest fare hikes — or any other topic — at the boat line’s monthly meeting on the Island Tuesday were required to wait until after the increases became reality. As is customary with SSA meeting agendas, public comment was the last item before adjournment.
“I was shocked,” said Vineyard governor Marc Hanover after the meeting. “I thought the public comment would be first.” Other Vineyarders evidently thought the same thing, with some 50 people joining about a half-dozen SSA staffers in the high school Performing Arts Center for a public session that began at 4:20 p.m.
The agenda included an update on the increasingly controversial Woods Hole terminal reconstruction project, with a slideshow on the auditorium’s large screen showing photographs of recent work on the waterfront.
Boat line general manager Robert Davis delivered the monthly business report and also reported on the independent review of boat line management practices, under way for the last few months by Seattle-based HMS Consulting and Management LLC. Consultants were originally due to produce a final report in early November, but are now expected to have the report ready in time for next month’s meeting, set for Nov. 27 in Falmouth.
Recently hired communications director Sean Driscoll announced that the boat line now has an active Facebook page and Twitter account, both with the user name steamshipauthorityma.
The Island audience listened to the proceedings — with repeated calls for governors and staff to speak directly into their microphones — until the board unanimously approved the fare increases, first unveiled at a meeting last month just after the board voted in the $105 million 2019 operating budget.
“No public comment on the rates?” a man asked from the seats. “You’re passing it first?” a woman called. Other mutterings were heard among the audience, scattered in ones and twos across the orchestra section of the 791-seat theatre.
Backing off a proposal to raise on-season Island-based excursion vehicle fares, the governors approved 12.5 per cent hikes in on-season standard vehicle fares and freight rates and a $5 per day increase in summer Saturday and Sunday parking rates at the Falmouth lots. It’s the first fare increase in six years and the first parking increase in four years, according to the SSA.
Retiring Oak Bluffs terminal manager Bridget Tobin, who started her boat line career in 1974 as a reservation clerk, received a standing ovation with widespread cheers and applause after Mr. Davis called her “truly an example of the best the Steamship has to offer.”
“Put her on the board!” called a pair of voices from the crowd. More cheers came when Mr. Davis announced that Ms. Tobin will return to work next summer.
The mood darkened when public comments began, as Islander after Islander approached the microphone to challenge the Woods Hole terminal redesign, the boat line’s perceived expansion on Martha’s Vineyard and the way the SSA applies rate increases at years-long intervals.
“Please do [the increases] incrementally,” said Island hotelier Josh Goldstein. “Do it, if you need to, annually. Nobody likes a big kick to cover a deficit.”
Fred Condon expressed frustration that the public was not allowed to speak until the final minutes of the meeting, which was scheduled to end at 6 p.m.
“How can you have a meeting when you ask people to come — because you really want to hear from them, because you want to get a sense of what’s going on — put us last on the agenda, make us wait through your meeting and then tell us we have six minutes?” Mr. Condon asked. “I’d be embarrassed.”
Tisbury selectman Melinda Loberg was waiting to speak when board chairman Robert Ranney of Nantucket adjourned the meeting shortly after 6. Mrs. Loberg told the Gazette she had planned to suggest cutting Falmouth parking rates, instead of raising them, to encourage more people to leave their cars ashore.
The board of governors holds its next regular meeting at 10 a.m. Nov. 27 in the Steamship Authority headquarters on Palmer avenue in Falmouth. Meetings generally take place on the third Tuesday of the month, but Nov. 20 was too close to Thanksgiving, Mr. Davis said.

Comments
Oh where, oh where is Mr
Doug OBOh where, oh where is Mr Hanover now. This is an outrage.
We simply adore Mr. Hanover
Ian and Nathan OB and NYCWe simply adore Mr. Hanover and love his eggs Benedict but it’s time for better representation.
Doug,
Bob S EdgartownDoug,
We need answers and good representation! Mr Hanover is a nice guy but clearly he does not want to "rock the boat".
Mr Hanover is awesome. This
Bruce EdgartownMr Hanover is awesome. This is a small increase and I don’t believe it’s his responsibility to report to us on this level of detail. I only care about boats leaving on time and Mr. Hanover has it locked and loaded - even has he flips the flaps at Linda Jeans - let’s back off and let him do his job!
Mr. Hanover has never turned
Just one Person Martha's VineyardMr. Hanover has never turned down a phone call from a single of you that has called to complain or report something. Some of you are just to Chicken to say something to him, to his face, email or phone because you know that there's nothing people can do for bs comments or complaints. It's always something with the bored Islander Talk SSA complainers or the SOSA group on facebook. If your day was perfect and the SSA treated you like gold then on board you had luke warm coffee and were even refunded for it, you'd still pitch a fit that the SSA screwed you. (This is the very vocal minority I understand ) .
Mr. Hanover knows his stuff. He knows his numbers (so maybe not the marketing cost) but he knows your issues and I am sure he's trying to navigate a board that is out looking for their own interests. He is just one person fighting an uphill battle. It He's doing what all the other good ones before him has done, question the management, try and push the board to do things correctly and control costs. It's not his job to babysit a bunch of cold coffee complainers or a couple of people that think they should have been given 1/2 hour to discuss a excursion increase that never was going to happen. Stop wasting everyone's time and learn about the authority.
I can not believe Islanders
Megan San FranciscoI can not believe Islanders are not demanding change. Civil disobedience is the only way. Enter the ferry without paying, tell your friends, flood the ferry.
Please leave your "attack
JohnPlease leave your "attack authority" tactics in California.
wow....
dave raposa brewsterwow....
We need Bridget, not a bridge
skip OBWe need Bridget, not a bridge! Bridget Tobin for Vineyard Governor!!
Agreed
BF in WT WTAgreed
The Steamship Authority never
Paul Kirby Worcester MA,The Steamship Authority never was, is not now, and will never be an authority on steamships. Their motive is the bottom line, net net... for themselves.
The taxpayers on both Islands
John Speers Cape CodThe taxpayers on both Islands and the port towns on the Cape are responsible for any budget shortfalls based on a percentage per the legislation that created the Authority. So it can be funded by rate increase's paid by those that actually use the ferry or by the taxpayers, take your pick as expense's rise every year for everyone be it property taxes, price of fuel and every thing we all spend money on. Maybe the Authority should cut back service to meet it's budget and see how quickly the complaints are about that !
What a sham.... everyone
gabrielle West TisburyWhat a sham.... everyone should be appalled at their actions and demand more transparency.
Another aspect of this is
Dean Rosenthal EdgartownAnother aspect of this is that the SSA spends 1.3 million dollars of their budget on advertising to draw as many customers they can have — is it any wonder that the numbers for cars get higher and higher? Yet as Louisa rightfully reported, they see the problem as one that we, on Martha’s Vineyard, must solve alone, and that they relate the solution to limiting cars. But part of the solution can be accepting that there is a LIMIT at some point. Do they add more trips? More boats? Because the infrastructure and the services can only support so much here. 1.3 million dollars of our money that goes to them to provide our lifeline and for the connection for ALL who visit here is devoted to advertising their service, to attract customers and ultimately increase profits. That’s how business works. My take is still that we are not trying to attract more people — it is our problem and yet they spend over a million dollars attempting to attract as many customers as they can with that money? The conclusion is that the advertising budget should be lower and that money put to BETTER USE. Or maybe that’s not the solution, but there is another one! The SSA has plenty of holes to fill in the budget every year. We are holding out our hand to share in solving a problem that may not concern them over in New Bedford or Hyannis, but sure as hell concerns everyone on this Island. The SSA, by right of their responsibility to serve the Island and be a “lifeline”, need to do more than apologize to me. Let’s get to work!
If the advertising takes
BS Oak BluffsIf the advertising takes customers away from the Hy-line and Island Queen then there is no net increase in visitors to the island and zero increase in cars. However the added revenue can offset future rate increases for islanders. I'm not sure if you have a VTA pass but there should be a rule that you can't complain about traffic if you don't have a pass. islanders are complicit in our traffic woes and we should address that first.
Dean, I love how a washashore
A music lover Martha's VineyardDean, I love how a washashore doesn't want anyone to come behind them. It's been that way for generation and it will always be that way but we shouldn't blame the SSA for making them want to come.
It can be debated as to the rise and the downfall of the island we all loved many years ago. The internet. How many people Asked Jeeves years ago where Martha's Vineyard was because President Clinton came here? How many people flocked to buy real estate, only seen on a computer screen, another country or continent away? Or how about the successful job the chamber of commerce did years ago promoting the island (not the current one). It's not the SSA's fault and should not rely on them to find a solution . Who really says there is a problem. For 2 months some, ok, maybe most complain and complain about how bad it is to get around. The same amount or more depend on those months to make it through the other 8 to 10 months to live here. So maybe a BETTER USE of your time Dean would be to help the hospital they seem to need it a whole hell of a lot more than the SSA. Let's face it, if there's a weather disaster here and we can't get off the island we need the hospital. admin to figure out their mess. The SSA won't be running anyways.
Whoever you are, hiding
Dean Rosenthal EdgartownWhoever you are, hiding behind your anonymous comment, I am GLAD you LOVE that a washashore "doesn't want anyone to come behind them". Funny, I still get crap from people who aren't courageous enough to let me know who they are, such a hoot! If you haven't noticed, it's definitely not just Dean Rosenthal who is the one with the complaints about traffic – it's anyone who lives here, just ask around or read the rest of the comments on this article or any other about the SSA and traffic on MV. Some in the business community would probably love to see the Island clogged up even more with tourists, which is, I think we can agree, objectively sad in many ways, but other than that, the real story is that there is a limit and the infrastructure cannot support the rising tide. Meanwhile, the idea that the Internet is responsible for the recent discovery of the island during Clinton's administration is interesting and you're probably right that that factor contributed. At last we agree! Thanks for your continued support of my advocacy for various causes around the Island and thank you for loving music! I suspect you may not be my biggest fan, haha! That's ok, I can handle it.
Please sign this citizen
N Trumbull WHPlease sign this citizen petition if you object to the scale or height of the proposed design of the Steamship Authority new terminal building in Woods Hole: www.steamshipauthority.info
I think the waterfront should
Paul iantosca ChilmarkI think the waterfront should be left open as the view is so beautiful
Broken record response time
Bob EdgartownBroken record response time to lay off employees on the boat. We watch them stand around while we load and other places around the world do not need as many as we have so why do we? Only reason could be our workers are not that good or this is a jobs program and not a boat line. We would save millions over time if we cut the staff by 3 people and we would not miss one of them.
Harsh Bob. A multi-million
Rick Vineyard HavenHarsh Bob. A multi-million dollar operation where you get to go on the boat anytime you want by paying your fare. You’ve already saved millions. You just need to “watch them stand around” as you grumble to yourself as you board.
Its not perfection, but I can count on the Steamship to go back and forth, or should we all ask Bob for a better ride?
Not one Board member
Caroline Hunter Oak BluffsNot one Board member supported public comment before the vote! It's past time for new leadership and MV deserves better representation! We don't have it now! Outrageous!
Why would any of Board Member
Public Commenter Martha's VineyardWhy would any of Board Member want to sit there and have public comment for 30 or 45 minutes to listen to complaints about the excursion increase when they knew all along they were going to rescind their recommendation for said excursion increase?
Islanders should be thankful
WashAbhorred EdgartownIslanders should be thankful there is a large population of non-residents and tourists willing to pay full fare on the ferry. Those are the tickets that support the low excursion fares charges to Islanders. Remove or reduce the number of non-residents using the ferry and the excursion rates are going to increase (or the number of ferries drop).
On the downside the 12.5% increase on freight is going to hurt everyone as the cost of goods coming over is going to have to increase. I guess it won't be long before those $22 burgers are upped to $25 and gas hits $5/gallon.
Has the time in Island
BF in WT WTHas the time in Island history arrived to get a completely new structure that benefits the Islanders and not only the employees and management of the SSA? Should our local and state level politicians get involved and dismantle this ridiculous, poorly run and outdated organization?
Time to build the bridge
Jeff Winter FloridaTime to build the bridge
Build a bridge and MV will
CR Lake Bluff ILBuild a bridge and MV will truly cease to be the haven we all have loved flocking to.
That's the problem with the
WHY Martha's VineyardThat's the problem with the island with the SSA. We throw comments out there that will never happen and offer nothing fruitful to the discussion. Much like the rantings that happened in the MVRHS meeting last Winter /Spring. Why would they seek out our assistance to help with a solution when all some do is provide rude or ignorant comments to be just funny instead of a solution to be talked about?
The Islands cannot restrict
John Cape CodThe Islands cannot restrict traffic to there ports just like we on the Cape cannot restrict how many vehicles come over our Canal bridges, which of course everyone has to use to get to the Islands in the first place. Perhaps the Vineyard would like to eliminate the SSA and have a bridge instead to connect to the Cape, so they can experience real traffic gridlock.
A lot could be learned by
Anne New YorkA lot could be learned by consulting with
www.cohoferry.com which operates boats out of from Washington to Victoria Island to
see how their ferry service functions. Their ferries are always on time, no waiting and hardly have the constant mechanical failures that the SSA ships do.
Why not seek advice from successful systems?
Those ferries are nice,
WashAbhorred EdgartownThose ferries are nice, however, they're funded by the State of Washington taxpayers. The SSA is funded almost totally by passenger, vehicle and freight fares. In recent years the Washington ferry system has had some serious budget problems.
As a long time summer home
John Aldeborgh Edgartown, MAAs a long time summer home owner I sit in awe of how the SSA is operated. In any free market business the rates go down as the numbers of customers increases, it's called economies of scale, a universal law of business. It's also not surprising that as they build a new monument to themselves (terminal building) the prices increase. The parking increase is on the order of 40%, not a trivial increase. The SSA is building in permanent cost, you build a big building, you have to staff and maintain a big building, there's no going back. And why not, you have no competition so with just the stroke of a pen you can do anything you want and 'rationalize' to the customers why it's want a "critical necessity". Without competition things will never change and we can all look forward to ever increasing prices with no incentive to improve customer service. This is why free markets are so important. There is absolutely no need for a government protected SSA.
A couple weeks ago a small
Todd RebelloA couple weeks ago a small informal group of us met with management in a sort of workshop. Management plans to meet with others as well to better understand our needs. For example they will be meeting with the MVC. We discussed the rates and were successful in holding off the islander excursion rate increase. We also talked about traffic concerns and ideas on how to protect revenues but also provide the incentive to leave cars behind. Some really good ideas were discussed about in season off peak travel. Maybe different rates for more desired travel times. This could help seniors and families who travel to appointments. Renters using peak time on Sat. And Sunday turnovers may pay more. Maybe diff. Rates for parking lots in peak periods based on proximity to create that incentive. We have to find balance for everyone. Some people want quality of life, some affordability, some have business interest, and some want just get off to see their kids play school activities. The more people who are part of these talks with management
Either individually or by e-mail the more they will come to understand our needs
It is time to consider
Bob EdgartownIt is time to consider reducing seasonal cars coming over. We need to better utilize our public transportation system and bike paths. Both could be improve at a far smaller cost (financial and island beauty) than futher growth of the SSA. Its role in transportation needs to shrink if our island is to remain viable. Less is almost always more and more always leads to less of something in the long run.
Add new comment