Tiny school cafeteria does not meet state codes for space or food prep, the town health agent said.
Holly Pretsky

Tour Highlights Substandard Conditions at Tisbury School

<p>Inadequate conditions at the town school were on full display during a tour this week attended by a large group of town officials.</p>

Floors buckled from moisture, failed windows, a cafeteria so small it fails to meet state codes, mold in a kindergarten classroom, an outdoor trailer used for instruction that has no bathroom.

Facilities manager Kirk Metell shows failed windows.
Holly Pretsky
Facilities manager Kirk Metell shows failed windows.
Holly Pretsky

These were just a few of the inadequate conditions documented during a tour of the Tisbury School this week attended by a large group of town officials.

School principal John Custer led the tour on Tuesday morning.

He was joined by the Tisbury school committee and board of selectmen. The brigade also included members of the planning board, the board of health, police department, facilities management, department of public works, school staff, wastewater management, the superintendent’s office and the public.

On a hot, sticky morning in the busiest week of summer, three weeks before the start of school, the message was clear: the Tisbury School needs serious work. Mr. Custer said the problems threaten the ability of school leaders to provide students with a safe and equitable education.

“We want to make sure that safety issues are addressed and accessibility issues are addressed,” he said, outlining immediate priorities.

One primary concern has been an outside trailer unit, dubbed the Little White House, where many English learning and remedial support classes are held. “Those are our neediest students,” Mr. Custer said during a walk through the unit’s small classrooms. He said the unit has no bathroom and effectively segregates students with special needs from the other students in the main building. “It’s a civil rights issue,” the principal said.

Mr. Custer said the Tisbury School serves the highest number of English learning students on the Island, about 75 last year.

Issues with the building’s exterior abound. Town administrator Jay Grande provided an estimate for building envelope renovations totaling more than $5 million.

“Basically we have 150-plus windows in the building that are getting to the age when they’re fogging . . . and in need of repair,” facilities manager Kirk Metell. He said rusted and cracked lintels had allowed water and moisture to seep inside classrooms.

“The floors are in bad shape because of water getting into the building,” Mr. Metell said. Mr. Custer later showed the group many of the windows that have become so foggy they obscure views outdoors.

Concrete steps leading to the school’s main entrance are crumbling and need replacement, Mr. Metell said. The school’s main parking lot is cracked and lacks proper signs and lighting.

Tour included a view of the boiler room.
Holly Pretsky
Tour included a view of the boiler room.
Holly Pretsky

“This is stuff that shouldn’t wait for a building project,” selectman James Rogers observed.

Police Lieut. Eerik Meisner said he would like to see better security outside the school, including more fencing and security cameras. Proximity to busy roadways was also a concern.

“The school is nestled in a neighborhood,” Mr. Custer said, “and because we are so conveniently located in a neighborhood area, we get a lot of traffic.”

Inside the school, limited classroom space is an ongoing challenge. Mr. Custer led the way to a single resource room on the second floor that houses special education courses for students in grades K through 4.

“This is one of the rooms the state is less than pleased with us about,” Mr. Custer said.

Space problems were evident throughout. The gymnasium is not regulation-sized, so the bleachers cannot be fully extended during games. The school band practices in what used to be a locker room beneath the stage. Some grades take computer classes in the library. The small cafeteria means there are five separate lunch periods, ranging from 18 to 25 minutes.

“It’s substandard and undersized,” said town health agent Maura Valley of the lunchroom. “It doesn’t meet any of the current codes for food prep or floor space for kids.”

Ventilation is also a concern. Many areas of the building lack air conditioning. Moisture in the air has caused floorboards in some rooms to swell and buckle. A frozen ventilator in the library last winter led to a leak that caused mold in the kindergarten classroom below. Remediation is underway in the space.

The problems are not limited to the oldest parts of the building. An addition that dates to the 1990s has problems as well. Mr. Custer said that area of the school has suffered the largest number of roof leaks.

“The new is in worse shape than the old,” Selectman Rogers observed.

A plan for a $46.6 million new school failed to win voter approval in April.

The next steps have not yet been mapped out, but selectmen and the school committee plan to convene a working session in September.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 08/16/2018 - 16:41

Permalink

Kate Declineville

Keep touring. We all know it’s a stalling tactic. Nothing ever gets done in our little town. I feel badly for the kids. You get the government you vote for.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 08/16/2018 - 20:12

Permalink

Miller G

I can’t believe we are sending our children to school in such un-safe conditions. Serving unsafe food is a huge issue. Mold? Buckling floors? No air conditioning? Sectioning the special needs away form general populations? There’s is a need for change. I’m sorry this meeting did not happen in June and the NECESSARY changes were not addressed over summer vacation. This school makes all parents sign a waiver in Kindegarten stating only injuries are covered under the school’s plan- not illness from mold, poor air quality, or any of the other cancerous conditions this school is forcing our children to.

MikeD WT

This is what happens when a building is ignored, improperly cared for, and no accountability from the town stewards.
Repairs and updates should have been made continuously over the course of time.
Now there is a much bigger problem to fix - everything.
Why weren't these things fixed/repaired - oh I know - the town was gambling on getting a new one - so why fix the old one.
That's really good logic -when you are spending money you dont have and thinking the town residents would accept a large tax increase to pay for it.
Very irresponsible.
Sign a waiver for my kid to be in these conditions - not a chance.
Gut it and renovate it to today's and future standards.
That 14M would have gone a long way if the town was not so short sighted.
And keep up with repairs!
I am sure the Charter schools enrollment will increase this year.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/17/2018 - 11:26

Permalink

Abby Normal The Rock

And yet, our K-8 students, after high school go to the best schools in the country. We could have gotten money each year for specific projects through the state. One year would be windows, next year the HVAC replacement, the following lighting and electrical. MikeD is correct, it was left and neglected and still, the proud lady stands. Has withstood several hurricanes and various Nor'easters. We live in a world with finite resources and that is a fact. The building can be saved and renovated. Space can be added, via modular. We all need to live within our means. And that does not mean "you hate children" if you do not want to spend funds on a new school. It means you are realistic and want to preserve the past and add for the future. The renovation is around $18 to $20 million. Modular space can be added for $8 to $9 million dollars. Total, less than a completely new school and we have a cherished land mark saved for future generations of students. Stop the insanity!!!

Julie G. Vineyard Haven

It must be nice to know everything, Abby Normal. Apparently you are a contractor and an educator because you seem to have all the school building answers, complete with facts and figures. Why do you value an land mark over a child’s education? If the town decides that the building should be saved, it would serve well as a town hall, police station, sernior center, etc. it will cost much less to renovate the current building for town offices than for a school for over 400 people. As you know by your vast knowledge of construction and education, there are many more restrictions on school building learning spaces than town offices when considering renovation or new construction. As i recall, the renovation that meets the needs of our students was considerably more expensive than new construction. Bringing the outdated school up to code doesn’t address the educational needs of our students ... it only saves a “cherished landmark”. Is the school project about preservation of a landmark or meeting the educational needs of our future generations? It’s time to get our priorities straight and take care of our kids and staff.

VH Resident Vineyard Haven

Abby!!! Thank you. Finally someone close to normal! Seriously, 40M is ridiculous. Give the architects a budget and make them hit it! We would have all approved a lower number. Heck. 13M from the state, we could have just approved 7M and there’s your renovation.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 08/20/2018 - 13:02

Permalink

Huh? Vineyard Haven

3 and a half year process the last time around and now the town officials take a 2 hour tour. We paid 700+ thousand dollars to consultants. I guess their assessment of the building is of no use to all the “non experts” out there. I wonder if the town leaders have read any of the materials generated by these paid experts? Staring at cracked walls, stairs, windows, where on island have you been for the past 3 years. Not one bit of this is new and the consultants you paid told you this. Shameful. Everyone can stop with the deferred maintenance complaint. Revisionist history if you think choices were not made along the way to avoid repeated proposition 2 1/2 overrides to fix the building.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 08/29/2018 - 12:37

Permalink

B by the Shore Vineyard Haven

These conditions are going to make our children sick- if you think a new school is expensive, just wait until the lawsuits start rolling in..

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.