Capping a summer of tense community relations and damaged confidence in the leadership at the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital, the interim president and chief executive officer pledged this week to do better by the Island.
Capping a summer of tense community relations and damaged confidence in the leadership at the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital, the interim president and chief executive officer pledged this week to do better by the Island.
“We’ve done a lot of listening this summer,” Timothy Walsh wrote in an open letter that appears in this week's edition of the Gazette.. “We’ve heard calls for greater transparency, accountability, responsiveness and communication.” Mr. Walsh came out of retirement to retake the helm at the hospital amid a swirl of controversy surrounding the sudden ouster of CEO Joseph Woodin in early June after just 13 months on the job.
The firing was led by longtime hospital president Timothy Sweet and vice president Edward Miller, who have stayed out of sight all summer despite repeated calls for public meetings, including by an ad hoc citizen group formed following the firing of Mr. Woodin.
An online petition that among other things calls for a change in leadership had gathered nearly 500 signatures as of this week.
In his letter, Mr. Walsh said a search is underway for a new CEO, using the Hingham executive search firm PhillipsDiPisa, and that consultants at Orlikoff & Associates Inc. have been retained to review board governance. He also outlined a strategic planning initiative led by Stroudwater Associates aimed at helping the hospital steer into the future. “The strategic plan . . . will be the hospital’s roadmap for improving the health of our community,” Mr. Walsh wrote.
Stroudwater is not new to the hospital and in fact was hired for a strategic planning initiative more than 15 years ago. A report from a consultant at the time outlined a troubling picture of mistrust and poor relationships inside and outside the hospital. The report was kept under wraps by the hospital board for nearly a year before it was made public.
As Mr. Walsh’s letter circulated this week, calls for a public meeting were renewed.
“Every Islander wants our hospital and Windemere to succeed. That’s what all of the commentary and discussion of these past few months has been about,” said Vineyard Haven resident Len Morris in an email to the Gazette Wednesday. Mr. Morris is a documentary filmmaker who signed the online petition and whose brother in law is a resident at Windemere. “At this point, the question is whether or not the current leadership at the hospital will listen to the community and work to restore the trust that has been lost,” he wrote, adding: “It’s time for the board of directors and Partners to meet the Vineyard public in a series of forums — to answer our questions in person, hear what the community has to say and create a real blueprint for community involvement going forward.”
Victor Capoccia, co-chairman of the ad hoc citizen group, declined comment on the Walsh letter until his group meets on Monday to discuss it.
But he confirmed that spokesmen for the group had met with a small contingent of hospital board members on August 25, and he forwarded to the Gazette a followup email to the board from the group. It said in part: “We see
ourselves as an ad-hoc group that has come together to assist hospital management and board build community confidence by achieving greater transparency, accountability, responsiveness and communication.” The latter phrase appears word for word in Mr. Walsh’s letter.
Speaking to the Gazette by telephone last week, Mr. Walsh talked at length about the strategic planning initiative and the complicated and daunting changes that hospitals are grappling with around the country. Many are aimed at improving the quality of affordable health care for all under the 2010 Affordable Care Act.
“The best way I can describe it, they have designated these accountable care organizations they expect will be all around the country,” he said, adding: “The big thing for us is to become a patient-centered medical home for primary care — it’s a goal of the Partners system to have all primary care offices in their system become this — it is on a fast track.”
The Vineyard hospital has been owned by Partners Healthcare since 2010, with Massachusetts General Hospital as its parent company.
Meanwhile, the latest fallout at the hospital comes over the recent firing of Ken Ivory, a longtime employee who was head mechanic. Mr. Ivory, a known supporter of Mr. Woodin, was one of a number of people who spoke at a community potluck gathering held for Mr. Woodin earlier in the summer. He was fired in August after 43 years on the job.
Mr. Walsh confirmed that Mr. Ivory was no longer working at the hospital but said he could not comment further.
On the advice of a union representative, Mr. Ivory also declined comment through his wife this week.
In other hospital news, Mr. Walsh confirmed that Wildflower Court, the residential unit at Windemere, the Island’s only nursing home situated on the hospital campus, is due to close any day. The closure was initiated by Mr. Woodin last spring, due to low residency and unsustainable financial losses. “We are down to one resident who is moving off the Island,” Mr. Walsh said. “When that patient moves we will have the unit effectively closed.” he said. The remaining units at Windemere, where residents require skilled nursing care, are full, Mr. Walsh said.
Future plans for Wildflower Court, which includes 13 private rooms with bathrooms, are still unclear, but Mr. Walsh said there has been some discussion about using the space to house traveling nurses. He said the hospital had received a letter from the Martha’s Vineyard Commission this summer noting that any change of use at the nursing home would require a return to the commission for public review.
“And we will comply with that,” Mr. Walsh said.

Comments
Jamie Orlokoff is very good.
Kate Putnam EdgartownJamie Orlokoff is very good. I hope they take his advice.
glad to hear that... we need
Marina Tisburyglad to hear that... we need "very good" when it comes to governance of MVH at this point...
They've done a lot of
Marina Vineyard HavenThey've done a lot of listening-- not sure they've succeeded in hearing the essentials. There's a difference between listening and hearing. Just as there's a difference between looking and seeing. Speak up, Islanders!
While I appreciate what Mr
MAM Reading/EdgartownWhile I appreciate what Mr Walsh is saying about medicine in America being held in a vice grip, the powers that be still need to treat employees and the community with respect in action and intent; that has nothing to do with reimbursement or the shift in medicine. Earning trust and respect takes time and effort. While you state there will be future attempts in communication, you are not starting on good footing in my opinion. In your explanation as to why the hospital is behaving the way in which it is, and perhaps will be, you cite, "the big thing for us is to become a patient-centered medical home for primary care " What does this mean? Jargon like this does not help anyone understand and effective communication means understanding is prevalent on all levels. Perhaps if this is done, residents and employes alike will understand some choices to be made in the future.
Great job Ms Wells on reporting a very sensitive and complicated topic! One request, for the sake of gender neutrality, would like to see the use of the word spokesperson(s) instead. Even though it is grammatically correct, I read it as though there are no women on the board.
Just because you didn't
Islander MvJust because you didn't understand a statement doesn't immediately turn it into useless jargon.
Jargon - "special words or
MAMJargon - "special words or expressions that are used by a particular profession or group and are difficult for others to understand". For the sake of explanation, I have been in the medical field for decades and did not understand his intent. As I noted, when making an important statement, the aim of comprehension should be for all levels. I don't understand the concept of " a patient - centered medical home for primary care". Isn't that what they have been doing? Or is it a new philosophy the community needs to understand? Will primary care be their only focus thus requiring specialty medicine to be procured by alternative methods either by leaving the island or via telemedicine? So yes, I did feel like the majority of the population reading this, including myself, would refer to this as medical jargon. Perhaps I am wrong.
We have repeatedly asked for
Alan NYC/ChilmarkWe have repeatedly asked for changes to be made at the board level, this is far more important to the community than putting up a Facebook page, or issuing a few more press releases (although this is appreciated, however behind the times it may be). The fact that they fired Ken after so many years working there for having a difference of opinion is chilling to say the least. This board must be changed now, we cannot have our hospital handled in this way any longer.
Partners HealthCare claims on
Jody Vineyard HavenPartners HealthCare claims on their website to be "committed to conducting its affairs in accordance with the highest ethical and legal standards. In order to maintain these standards, all those associated with Partners perform their duties with integrity and honesty."
Firing Ken Ivory after 43 years with little or no cause is the exact opposite of this claim. It is disrespectful of Kenny and all Islanders. We need to speak up and let them know this is not how we treat each other on Martha's Vineyard.
So - Joe Woodin fired, no
RH ChilmarkSo - Joe Woodin fired, no explanation, a project manager who also uprooted from Vermont was fired, again without explanation. The board has a community meeting, admits it was all handled poorly from a communications standpoint, but has heard the community, and a few weeks later the fire someone who has been with the hospital for 43 years - no comment, no explanation. All we know is that he gave a wonderful speech in support of Joe at a send off. My question is "what has changed?
By the way - anyone else think they will be spending many many thousands of dollars in a search for a new CEO, and then decide that the best candidate just happens to sit on the board?
For everyone defending ken
Islander MvFor everyone defending ken ivory, do you know why he was fired? If the answer is no then you shouldn't jump to conclusions.
Telling the truth would seem
Margaret Vero BeachTelling the truth would seem to be the answer. It will end speculation, suspicion and unnecessary gossip. Why the mystery?
yes, I do and it is
Concerned citizenyes, I do and it is unbelievably petty. It supports all the concerns and complaints against Partners and the Board.
The hospital is obligated to
Gale Vineyard HavenThe hospital is obligated to protect the confidentiality of its current and former employees and is therefore meeting its responsibilities in not releasing information regarding Mr. Ivory’s dismissal. It is unfortunate that in fulfilling its commitment to confidentiality, the hospital administration is being maligned due to pure speculation and innuendo. While I do agree that the historical behavior of the administration has been characterized by a lack of transparency and community engagement; in this situation, they are acting ethically and responsibly and in Mr. Ivory’s best interest.
The parrot's name is Chico
Nancy DeCamp Gary Media PaThe parrot's name is Chico deCamp. We brought him from Panama in 1962. He is 55 years young and loves visitors. He is very chatty.
Very cool!
Islander MvVery cool!
Our beloved Chico, Windemere
Betsy Burmeister Vineyard HavenOur beloved Chico, Windemere's Parrot for many years, passed away on Friday, September 8th. He had been in very ill health. We will miss him tremendously. He was a part of our Family and we were with him until the end. We held him,and told him how special he was, and how much we loved him. He knew that he was loved. We were blessed to have him with us for so many years.
I read and re-read the
Bert Oak BluffsI read and re-read the article and each time I failed to see either of the following facts : (1) That Mr Ivory was terminated because of his support of or allegiance to Joe Woodin or (2) That Mr Ivory was terminated without cause .
What if the hospital just did
Island Kid MVWhat if the hospital just did the right thing and brought back Woodin and Ken Ivory with reasonable raises and very public profuse apologies and admitted they were completely wrong, and promises not to ever do anything like this again? Then maybe this whole thing could be taken care of and be behind us. Until then it's hard to imagine the island community having a lot of faith or trust in the decision makers at the hospital.
Add new comment