A neighbor group has been working diligently for seven years to restore Sunset Lake in Oak Bluffs to its former beauty.
Mark Lovewell

Neighbors Roll Up Their Sleeves to Restore Ailing Sunset Lake

<p>The sandy shores and clear waters of Sunset Lake in Oak Bluffs once made it an attraction in its own right. Now the Friends and Neighbors of Sunset Lake want to bring it back.

It was once the sparkling gateway to Oak Bluffs. The sandy shores and clear waters of Sunset Lake made it an attraction in its own right. In the summer there were paddle boats for rent and crabbing was abundant.

That picture is mostly lost to memory now, and through most of the 20th century the lake declined. Today it’s known mostly as the place where the town floats a handsome lighted Christmas tree every December.

Donna Hayes, president of Friends and Neighbors of Sunset Lake.
Mark Lovewell
Donna Hayes, president of Friends and Neighbors of Sunset Lake.
Mark Lovewell

But for the past seven years, an ambitious group of neighbors who live near Sunset Lake have been working diligently to restore the lake to its former natural beauty.

Formed in 2010, the Friends and Neighbors of Sunset Lake (FANS) faced a daunting task. Invasive species, including phragmites and Russian olive, have colonized the lake’s shores. The marshy area and nearby streets are prone to flooding. The slope of the hill below Greenleaf avenue is eroding. The brackish lake is rich in nitrogen from limited tidal exchange and septic runoff.

Today progress has been made. Using Community Preservation Act funding from the town, the friends of the lake hired the Horsley Witten Group, environmental consultants based in Sandwich, to complete a wetlands delineation and plant assessment. A management plan was written and work began to restore portions of the shoreline.

Long-range plan calls for total restoration with walking paths, stormwater retention and dog pickup stations.
Long-range plan calls for total restoration with walking paths, stormwater retention and dog pickup stations.

For group leaders Donna Hayes and Jaye Shelby, it was a crash course in town government. “Donna and I have been to a lot of meetings,” Ms. Shelby said. They listed a few: the parks department, shellfish department, conservation commission historical commission and the Oak Bluffs selectmen.

Last fall the group secured a second small CPA grant to help with permitting fees and soil sampling costs — all laying the groundwork for an extensive future rehabilitation effort.

The friends group envisions a multi-phase restoration that could cost millions and take years to complete.

The town would need to approve the plans and the group still must secure funding.

But the friends of the lake are determined. “We’re in it for the long haul,” Ms. Hayes said.

One priority is to address flooding in the area by creating a stormwater garden. Native species plantings and a walking path are also priorities, along with slope stabilization. Ms. Hayes hopes that work could begin by October 2018.

Hidden jewel at the entrance to Oak Bluffs.
Mark Lovewell
Hidden jewel at the entrance to Oak Bluffs.
Mark Lovewell

Oak Bluffs selectman Gail Barmakian praised the community initiative as a good example of a public-private partnership. Amy Billings, chairman of the Oak Bluffs parks department, agreed. “Basically the Friends of Sunset Lake are the best thing that ever happened to that area,” she said.

“It’s our home, that’s why we do it,” Ms. Hayes said. “We always knew it was going to take a long time to do what we want to do.”

Originally part of Squash Meadow Pond, Sunset Lake has a former long history as a saltwater estuary. When a causeway was built that eventually became Lake avenue, it split the pond, forming Lake Anthony (today the Oak Bluffs harbor) and Sunset Lake.

The friends group, which now includes about 50 people, has a future vision for seeding the lake with shellfish, installing dog pick-up stations, creating a walking path that leads to the Arts District and bringing back the swans that once swam there.

But that is the long view. In the short term, they’re focused on incremental progress and on keeping the area clean by picking up trash and discouraging the public from feeding the wildlife.

Each year they host a cleanup day in August where they routinely collect 40 to 50 bags of trash. Ms. Shelby keeps this going all year round. “It’s constant,” she said.

“Every day we walk the dogs around, and every day, winter, summer, fall, or spring, we go up to the top and my heart leaps at how beautiful it is.”

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 09/03/2017 - 07:28

Permalink

Mr. B Chilmark

The Mute Swan is an invasive species, brought from Europe as a decorative plaything for the ponds of the wealthy. Their feeding habits are voracious and will drive out native species. And they are very nasty creatures. For reasons understood only by folks who don't have to deal with them, they are a protected species. I counted 54 of them in the upper part of Tisbury Great Pond this June, eating the bottom grasses hour after hour.

My apologies to the wealthy: my indiscriminate use of indefinite pronouns after the first sentence might mislead people as to the subject of my warning/rant. Of course wealthy people don't eat bottom grasses.

John Divver Riverside

I can't help but think how native Americans felt when they realized the invaders (the white people) were here to stay. Adapt & survive. Our Island neighbors are still struggling with the most recent business (bingo hall). Some people just refuse to let them succeed. Don't rain on their parade.

Donna Russell Braddock Bay, New York

Thanks for the morning chuckle! Thousands of these creatures escaped from the wealthy and set up housekeeping along the shoreline of Lake Ontario. NY State Dept. of Environmental Conservation previously culled our local invasive population by shooting them, but public outcry insisted they be allowed to live. The DEC now resorts to addling and oiling eggs to prevent future generations of the nasty critters, but their desire to replicate themselves is as voracious as their appetites and every year we see their young learning how to cause trouble for animals less able to protect themselves. The (sadly, long gone) indigenous peoples who lived here tried so hard to prevent invasive species from establishing nesting sites, but lost the battle. (My apologies to any swans who took this personally.)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 09/03/2017 - 10:11

Permalink

Lisa Hampden MA and Oak Bluffs MA

A huge thanks to Donna Hayes and Jaye Shelby for leading this effort. We enjoy the park and Sunset Lake twice day when were on The Vineyard, especially Tully! I helped with the cleanup last year and it was great to spend the day with such dedicated neighbors. Please keep us informed of ways we can help from America. With his environmental and biology background, Karl may be helpful as a consultant in that area.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 09/03/2017 - 10:53

Permalink

Betty Surbeck MVIi

I've been coming to oak bluffs for 60 years and I don't remember paddle boats and crabbing at sunset lake. When was that. I remember the swans that my children were delighted with and scarred of. I would love a path around the pond.

Stephen OB

The paddle boats started out in lake Anthony (now OB Harbor) in the late 1940s. When The Methodist Camp Meeting Association (now the MVCMA) sold the harbor and surrounding lands to the Town, the paddle boats were moved to Sunset Lake; I am not sure why, probably for safety reasons. Paddling was not as much of an adventure as when the boats were in the harbor and by the early 60s, as I recall, it was all over.

Donald Andrew Everett, MA

Gerry DeBettencourt was responsible for getting the swans. They were a nice sight in Sunset Lake in the summer.

George Blythe Vero Beach Fl

Betty, I remember you from a dinner at the Young Republic’s Club in 1972, when you tried to alert us thick headed Elephants that we were creating “progress” with out thinking of the repercussions. I think of your quiet unheard alerts every I time pick up tossed plastic off the streets or put a “Dont throw anything away, there is no away” sign on my car. You were right then, and you are right now; keep up the good work and get in touch if you are ever in Vero Beach. A reformed George Blythe

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/05/2017 - 05:04

Permalink

Judi West Tisbury

Thank goodness.Just took a drive by there with a friend to show them some of Oak Bluffs, and stopped short of telling them of the beauty of the Lake years ago, seeing it now,and remembering the Paddle Boats in days of old with my Dad.Thank You.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/05/2017 - 06:28

Permalink

Heidi West Tisbury

Great job! With the talent of Jaye Shelby and Donna Hayes, this project should move forward nicely! Best of luck!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/05/2017 - 09:26

Permalink

Cynthia Sheffield and West Tisbury, MA

Congratulations to all involved with this impressive effort. Your hard work and dedication to seeing it through for "the long haul" are an inspiration!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/05/2017 - 11:18

Permalink

Kathryn Oak Bluffs

Thank you to my neighbors, Donna and Jaye! You are Superwomen, navigating through so many hurdles....Can't thank you enough. The check is in the mail...LOL, actually will hand deliver it.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/05/2017 - 14:32

Permalink

Nick & Denise Bauer 8 Siloam Ave

Jaye and Donna have done a wonderful job! Keep up the good work ladies.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/05/2017 - 17:43

Permalink

Scott Prescott South Carolina

The paddle boats were originally in the harbor and were moved to Sunset lake. Keep up the good work.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/05/2017 - 20:59

Permalink

Charles Shabica Oak Bluffs

Was it Joe Pina at Church's Pier who ran the paddle boats in the 50s, later moving from the harbor to Sunset Lake?

Scott Prescott South Carolina

I was to young to remember names. My reflection is that, the guy who seemed to run all things around Church's Pier was a fella who was always dressed in a khaki shirt, matching slacks and hat. You are probably correct, as that is where you rented the paddle boats.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 10/14/2017 - 13:55

Permalink

Donald Andrew Everett, MA

Joe Pina owned and rented the paddle boats, first in the harbor and then in Sunset Lake. It was very easy to get stuck in the grass and muck and have to be rescued. I bought two of the boats from Joe in the 1970s. Too bad they're not still there. They were a lot of fun.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.