Five babies in five months for four Oak Bluffs police officers and one state trooper. “I guess the stars aligned,” said Officer James Hagerty.
Det. Jeffrey LaBell and his wife Missie LaBell welcomed the arrival of baby Lark in March. Officer Seth Harlow and his wife Bonnie Kingsbury had baby Gunner in May. Island state trooper and former Oak Bluffs police officer Dustin Shaw and his wife Morgan Shaw had baby Lowen in June. Officer James Hagerty and his wife Alessandra Hagerty had baby William in July. And just last week, officer Tim Millerick and his fiancé René Will had baby Julian.
That’s five babies in five months for four Oak Bluffs police officers and one Island-assigned state trooper stationed in Oak Bluffs.
But there was no pact. There was no discussion.
“I guess the stars aligned,” said Officer Hagerty.
If there is any coincidence at the Oak Bluffs police department, it is the age of the young officers. In the group of fathers, all are from 28 to 36 years old, said Officer Hagerty.
Evidently, this happens in cycles. A group of young officers will enter the department. They grow up together and reach a certain age where adding to their family seems right. Oak Bluffs police chief Erik Blake recalled when he was having his children about 10 years ago, Lieut. Timothy Williamson and Officer Christopher Wiggin were right there with him.
So it’s happened before. “But never on this scale,” Chief Blake said. And while there are some scheduling issues with paternity leave, the department knows what to expect. “We cover it,” the chief said.
On Wednesday, all the mothers, fathers and newborns gathered at the station for a group portrait. It was the first time everyone had been together at once. Mothers chatted and smoothed cowlicks. Fathers stood in uniform on the sidelines, watching. The officers discussed whether they should pose with hats or without them.
“It’s nice to have a group of people to bounce things off of,” said Morgan Shaw. Her baby Lowen is seven weeks old. The main question she had was about diapers and what size to start with. “It takes a lot of practice. Other people have different soothing techniques too.”
Officer Shaw had diaper concerns as well — he’d recently learned how to change them. Ms. Shaw said she was hopeful that the kids would grow up to be close friends. The group of mothers get together for their older children’s birthdays and she hoped the tradition would continue.
Everyone made their way to the front steps for a group picture. First, the mothers held their babies with the officers close behind. Then the moms carefully handed the babies over to the dads. When Ms. Will saw that young Julian was catching the noon sun on his face, she gently suggested to Officer Millerick that he hold the baby in his shaded arm.
“You’re a genius,” he said with a smile.
Chief Blake pulled in as the families were milling about. “I got to see how happy they are,” he said. “Becoming a parent really grounds you. It gives them roots in the community more than they already have. When we hire people we look for people that want to be part of the community. Millerick and Harlow are not from here but they assimilated, they love Martha’s Vineyard, they love Oak Bluffs. Settling down, it kind of cements them into the community,” he said.
Seeing the new families prompted the chief to reflect on the balance of his own family and his demanding career. “When you’re at work, you give all your time and energy to the people of your community and that’s what you get paid for,” he said. “But when you get home, you get to receive some of that energy back. Spending time with my kids, I’d rather do that than anything.”
After the picture, the families chatted in the shade. Ms. Kingsbury wondered about the status of another child’s belly button. A woman walking by, Sue O’Shura, stopped to look at all the young babies. She said her son was a Pennsylvania state trooper with young kids of his own.
Detective LaBell hesitated when he thought about whether Lark would join the police force. “We’ll see . . . we’ll see. It’s a good job for me but she can do whatever she wants . . . . We see some things that I wouldn’t want her to see. That’s what I’ll say about that.”
Trooper Shaw added that he thinks being an officer helped prepare him for fatherhood. “Being a good trooper taught me to be a good dad. You have to care for other people,” he said.
But there was no hesitatation when considering his life and the recent changes. “I just have to say, being an officer is the best job. Being a dad is even better.”

Comments
I love this - I love this PD
Skip OBI love this - I love this PD - I love this Town. NO where else is this found
Great story, great photos.
Sara Piazza EdgartownGreat story, great photos. Love these families.
Congratulations Officers!
Congratulations! Oak BluffsCongratulations Officers! Finally an article about what is most important in our little town and the correlation about being a good Dad makes you a good Officer is spot on. Bless you and your families.
This is a great news story.
Tom Wills ChilmarkThis is a great news story. This is what I want to read. Love this community. God bless these families.
There will be many tired
Ann Marie OBThere will be many tired policemen. God bless.
In the print addition ("From
skip OBIn the print addition ("From March to July, Babies on Parade", pg. 7) note that the 5, born from March to July, were born progressively heavier.
The OBPd has always been a
Sarah Whisley Oak BluffsThe OBPd has always been a family friendly department. Their officers have the most adorable children-always have! What a wonderful chief to be so family ortiented.
What an amazing story! Neat!
Donald Thompson AquinnahWhat an amazing story! Neat!
Great story. My son in law is
Pete Radigan Seasonal vineyardGreat story. My son in law is a detective off island with their first, a 8 month old son. He is a tough kid on the street but just a wonderful dad when at home.
It takes the edge off a tough job.
Now this put a BIG smile on
Nannie Bee South ShoreNow this put a BIG smile on my face. Lovely story.
Couldn't be prouder of Seth,
Chris Harlow Westminster, VermontCouldn't be prouder of Seth, Bonnie and Gunner. Vermonters who vacationed in MV their whole lives then chose to make it their home. Congratulations to all these young families. There is hope in the world..
Adorable story! This is why
Thayer Santerini OBAdorable story! This is why we love the vineyard gazette newspaper.
Wonderful news story. God
Bob Manadar EdgartownWonderful news story. God Bless these beautiful families!
Touching story. Beautiful
Wilma Park Oak BluffsTouching story. Beautiful young families.
thank god something wholesome
debbie dean oak bluffsthank god something wholesome .. parenting makes/keeps us all the more humane .. thank these fellows & gals for their belief in the near future & beyond .. I don't buy newspapers in general but needed this photo as a reminder of all the good there is yet to come
I also don't but newspapers
Joan West TisburtI also don't but newspapers but sure bought this one. I enjoyed how this highlighted our unique community.
What beautiful blessings.
Roberta Toner Oak BluffsWhat beautiful blessings. This is the best news story there is. Celebrate love. Peace.
Darling journalism.
Wanda Oak BluffsDarling journalism.
Aww! Babies are blessings
Lisa Oak BluffsAww! Babies are blessings that bring out the best in all of us! LOVE this story. Congrats to the families. Peace, love and naps!
What a wonderful story! With
Anita Kent Vero Beach, FlWhat a wonderful story! With my late husband we spent 7 lovely summer vacations there and I fell in love with MV.
When people ask me if I had a choice where to live I always say the Vineyard. Was introduced to it by my husband's
Aunt in law, Fran Stewart and we shared cottages over several summers. I'll never forget the beauty, the people, the
lovely events and performances. You are so very lucky to live there! There is no place like it for me anywhere.
Enjoy!
Add new comment