Discipline policies have come under the spotlight at the regional high school.
Maria Thibodeau

High School Leaders Air Discipline Policies

<p>Recent issues at the regional high school continue to weigh on the community. Nearly 100 people gathered Tuesday night to hear about disciplinary policies.

Summer is under way, but recent issues at the Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School continue to weigh heavily on members of the school community.

Nearly 100 people gathered in the Performing Arts Center Tuesday night to hear about disciplinary policies at the high school. Parents, community members, students and teachers wearing purple MVRHS shirts gathered to voice concerns, make suggestions and share support for the school and the administration. The meeting ran for more than two hours.

The forum was scheduled after a popular teacher retired amid criticism of the school administration. Shortly after, another teacher painted over some murals in the history department, causing another wave of concern. School culture and discipline became topics for discussion.

On Tuesday, high school principal Sara Dingledy opened the forum with a short presentation, including some statistics.

In the past five years, the number of students who have had in-school or out-of-school suspensions has declined, she said. Last year 81 students were suspended compared to 55 this year. For the same period there were a total of 228 infractions compared to 103. Five years ago, 93 students were suspended and the year saw 264 infractions.

“We’re hoping to have fewer infractions in general, when people talk about reducing the suspension rates, my question is always what about reducing the infraction rates,” Ms. Dingledy said. This year she said 360 detentions were handed out to 151 students, 22.5 per cent of the school population. Detentions are given mostly for repetitive tardiness and cutting class, Ms. Dingledy said.

“Our absence rate is going way up, we need to look and see how we can both create a culture that makes kids want to come to school, because that’s a big thing,” the principal said, adding: “And also simple things we put in place like robo-calls that we instituted about three-quarters of the way through to make sure parents are informed if their child is not in school,” she said. A similar call policy is planned for students who cut class, she said.

The forum saw discussion about the role of the school resource officer and touched on topics like communication and respect.

The school resource officer is a police officer who is on school campus five days week. The position was created in 2014 and filled by Sgt. Mike Marchand from the Oak Bluffs police department. Originally created to facilitate good relations between the students and the police, some people expressed concern that the officer is now used to take punitive action against students.

Ewell Hopkins, an Oak Bluffs planing board member and parent, asked if the resource officer role has changed.

“I’m very concerned about law enforcement in the role of raising my children within school, where I understand the key issue should be creating an environment of learning,” he said.

Gwyneth Wallace, a parent, said increased communication would help parents understand changes in disciplinary actions.

“When we only get one side of the story . . . it’s hard not to wonder what’s going on in this building,” she said. “If the community knows 22 per cent of kids are late, tardy or cutting school, it makes a lot more sense why discipline is changing here, but the community doesn’t have access to that information.”

Ms. Dingledy said school leaders are looking into better communication methods and invited people to share ideas with the school advisory council.

“The hard part is figuring out where and what to start with . . . do you make information easy to find, or do you send it out and blow up people’s inboxes,” she said.

Emily Hewson, a rising senior, requested more resources for the guidance department.

“Please, please invest more in the guidance department, we need more of them, we need more opportunities from them, we need more reach out from them. I am a student who has been on both sides of coin, I’ve been really helped and I’ve been really ignored,” she said.

While concerns were aired, parents also took time to point to positive outcomes of the year under the new administration. Cindy Flanders said the revolving door of leadership in the administration at the high school in the past four years left her children with no clear understanding of what was expected of them.

“This year I’m so grateful for the leadership of Sara and the superintendent’s office, through their work. I know my children are clear with what is expected of them,” she said. “I encourage the administration to find a way to engage the students in this conversation . . . if we are holding our students accountable for their behaviors, I think we also must be prepared to hold educators and administrators accountable for theirs as well.”

Jackie Callahan, a member of the school advisory council who sat on the principal search committee, also praised the work of Ms. Dingledy this year.

“We were not looking for someone to come and fix the discipline . . . we needed someone to come in and be a leader for our school, that’s why we chose Sara,” she said. “The discipline code has been in effect for several years, as the school advisory council we look at it each year and try and tweak it a little bit, part of the concern is this year, it’s being enforced.”

Comments

Parent Oak Bluffs

Elyse: Maybe if parents raised their children instead of expecting the teachers to do so you would not have as many discipline problems. Prison, really. Maybe a swift kick in the butt would straighten out more parents and more students.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 06/29/2017 - 10:46

Permalink

Ken Edg.

The school should tell you what you can do, not what you cant do. That just sets up an environment for rebellion. High school is a transition between middle school and college or a job. It should be a positive experience. Heck Id have job fairs every month so the kids that dont want to learn can work. Sometimes work experience is better than all the guidance the school can offer.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 06/29/2017 - 11:54

Permalink

Just Saying VH

Holding people accountable when they skip school or cut class or break a rule sounds like a prison? I suppose you believe that you can break whatever law you choose without any consequences. That's a great lesson to teach the next generation.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 06/29/2017 - 15:58

Permalink

Bev WT

Another purpose of a resource officer is SAFETY. Why does everything have to be so political? That is just very close minded.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 06/29/2017 - 21:13

Permalink

Miles Williams Tisbury

Given the choice between professional adults keeping order and self-absorbed teens trying to set the agenda, I'll take the adults 100% of the time. Kudos to this principle for holding the line against the lunatic relativism and self-centeredness that is rotting out our culture!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/30/2017 - 06:12

Permalink

Brandon Edgartown

The students are taking over the school. I have never seen such disrespect from students to faculty, and that comes from leadership. As for the resource officer, the top priority is safety. I know many people think the Vneyard is Disney Land, but it's not. Second is building relationships and trust with students, not doing the principals job of internal discipline. If a crime is committed on MVRHS property, the school resource officer should deal with it.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 06/30/2017 - 09:17

Permalink

Mr. B Chilmark

Data and stats can be helpful, but they need to be explored carefully. We see an example in the article: "This year she said 360 detentions were handed out to 151 students, 22.5 per cent of the school population." Having dealt with such issues for decades, I have learned the lesson of what I will call "clumping" when it comes to these issues. We used to see issues like this in my school, and some faculty would be loudly aghast that (I'll use MVHS figures) 22% of the kids were cutting classes or being involved in other "detention-level" offenses. But when looked at closely (and not so closely) another picture emerged. First, a closer look at the data revealed that if the numbers were spread evenly, it meant that 22% of the kids were at detention 2-3 times per year, a 180+ day event. That's not much. Second, a closer look (in the school I was in) revealed that the the largest number of students had only a single detention per year--and those were most often at the beginning of the year. They got burned and didn't do whatever they did again. This next went to the "clumping" I mentioned earlier. A look at the five "big hitters" among the offending students revealed that they accounted for just over half of the infractions. If they could be successfully counselled/managed, our stats would look great!

So the lesson of the numbers is that they can be both revealing and misleading. They need to be looked at closely. While I would not expect Ms. Dingledy to reveal everything, my bet is that she looks at the data closely and uses the numbers effectively in her directing her counseling and daily work.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.