A popular place for dogs and their owners, Trade Winds Fields Preserve is actually a working airfield and home to a fragile ecosystem.
Jeanna Shepard

When a Dog Park Is Actually an Airstrip

<p>The scene at Trade Wind Fields Preserve is like most dog parks, but the Oak Bluffs spot is actually an air field and protected land bank property.</p>

The scene at Trade Wind Fields Preserve is like most dog parks. Groups of owners gather, chatting as their dogs play together, frolicking about, sniffing through the nearby woods, or nosing at a pocket that conceals a bag of treats. It’s a time of socialization for the dogs and the people.

But Trade Winds is not a dog park. The open field located off County Road in Oak Bluffs is an active (intermittently) air field and protected Land Bank property.

Boo Radley and Angus are free to frolic.
Jeanna Shepard
Boo Radley and Angus are free to frolic.
Jeanna Shepard

The Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank bought the property in 1989 to preserve the sandplain grassland, home to species like the purple tiger beetle, sickle-leaved golden aster, bearberry, purple needle grass, sandplain blue-eyed grass and wild indigo. Over the years, enforcement has been lax in the area, with walkers only asked via signs to stay off the grassy strips and stick to the paths. Dogs have been allowed to roam freely, with no requested restrictions on their travel plans, as canine wandering was deemed less destructive than a person’s boots.

But recently the land bank has turned its attention to misuse of the property, leaving some in the dog community concerned.

Matthew Dix, conservation lands foreman for the land bank, said last year his board expressed concerns that the management strategies being used were not effective in conserving the sandplain grasses. Trails had been worn through the airplane runway and taxi strip by repeated use, and the fields were being used as places to play fetch.

Mr. Dix said he tried blocking the illegal trails with brush and keeping the grasses along the edge of the trails high to discourage people from walking into the middle of the fields, but to no avail. Signs were pulled out and fallen trees blocking the paths were dragged out of the way.

Popular destination for dogs and owners has traditionally been loosely managed.
Jeanna Shepard
Popular destination for dogs and owners has traditionally been loosely managed.
Jeanna Shepard

“This particular demographic is not usually one we have a hard time enforcing rules with,” he said. “Fifty to seventy year old people disregarding signs . . . the usual scofflaws are teens.”

In January, Mr. Dix appointed a part-time attendant, Patty Culkins, to visit the property and remind people to stay on the trails. Further plans include increased signage, a singular trail head that splits into the two existing trails off the County Road parking lot and regrowth efforts over some of the illegal trails.

On a recent afternoon, dog walkers circled the trails that surround the taxi and landing strips and wind through the surrounding woods. Rita Brown, Lee-Ann Yeddo and Marsha Eldridge were walking their six elderly dogs along the path in the preserve.

Ms. Brown has been coming to Trade Winds for 16 years with her four dogs, Ms. Eldridge for 11 years, and Ms. Yeddo for 13. They met up accidently on their walks today, which is often what happens.

“You get to know the dogs’ names and eventually you get to know the people too,” said Ms. Eldridge. “We can’t go to the beaches, we’ve kind of taken over this area.”

Daisy takes a moment by herself.
Jeanna Shepard
Daisy takes a moment by herself.
Jeanna Shepard

Ms. Brown recalled when she first started coming to the area, there were fewer walkers and nobody walked in the middle of the fields. She reckoned about 11 years ago people began to walk in the middle of the plains. The three agreed they had no problem with staying off the grass plains, but were hopeful that a cross-over path on the taxi-way could be kept.

“A lot of people who are older, run out of energy and a short cut back is immeasurably helpful,” said Ms. Brown.

Mr. Dix said the hardest part about keeping a cross-over path would be changing the management plan which would require hearings and going to the state. There are also safety concerns. Mr. Dix said that crossover paths make standing in the middle of the field tempting.

“As soon as they get out there, that’s where the main impact is, they’re throwing balls, the ground is torn up right in the middle of these places,” he said. “Multiple people have told me if you just give me a cross-over it’s fine. But it becomes an attractive nuisance, it’s hard to not stop and enjoy the open space there.”

Though only two pilots have registered to use Trade Winds so far, it is an active airfield. Mr. Dix has set up a small committee of private pilots to address their needs and wishes for the property.

“We want to get all of our users to the table,” he said. “The dog community has their needs, but we do want all the angles, ecologists, dog walkers, mine and pilots.”

Rose Cecil, Jane Hawkes, and Mary McManama.
Jeanna Shepard
Rose Cecil, Jane Hawkes, and Mary McManama.
Jeanna Shepard

Although there have been rumors that trails from the parking lot through the woods and to the main trail would be shut down, Mr. Dix said he did not plan to close those trails. Instead, he plans to move all the openings to one gathering area just past the parking lot and stock it with signage and waste stations. The original management plan shows the trail closed, he said, but the community was too attached to it.

“There’s no way to close the trail down,” he said. “It is so important to them to have a loop system, I backed away and allowed them to maintain it. I will still allow that but angle to start from one point.”

Still, some dog owners and Trade Wind abutters fear the property will become yet another place that limits dog use.

“We lost Lambert’s Cove Beach, which was one of the safest, most wonderful places for dogs to run, because people didn’t pick up after themselves,” Kerry Scott said. Ms. Scott is a long time user of Trade Winds and can see the property from her home window.

“From my vantage point, there was never a time when people respected the limits, not once,” she said. “Signs disappeared within days. I’m honestly so sorry it has come to this.”

Two pilots have registered to use Trade Winds so far.
Jeanna Shepard
Two pilots have registered to use Trade Winds so far.
Jeanna Shepard

Lindsay Webster comes to Trade Winds often, looping the fields twice for a three-mile walk with her two dogs, Belly a spaniel mix, and Radley who she described as “part-dinosaur.” Belly and Radley were off-leash wrestling together, running a few yards away before returning and sniffing near Ms. Webster’s feet. For her, keeping the property open for unleashed dogs is important. “A dog on a leash is a different dog,” she said. But the majority of recent changes made by the land bank, she welcomes.

“I’m thankful they installed the waste stations,” she said.

While Mr. Dix said the land bank will not be enforcing a leash law on the property, a pamphlet available on the land bank website states “Owners must keep dogs on designated trails. Owners must keep dogs off the runway and taxi way; leash pets if necessary.”

Mr. Dix said the pamphlet is not finalized and they do not expect dogs to stay completely off the open fields. He explained that a dog will run varied paths in the grass and not damage the grass. It’s the owners he’s worried about.

“We’re not saying their dogs can’t run free, we’re saying the people need to be on the path,” he said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/30/2017 - 21:28

Permalink

Haven girl Vineyard haven

Dos and their owners are still allowed on lambert cove beach

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/31/2017 - 01:50

Permalink

C Taylor Oak Bluffs

My residence abuts Tradewinds Airfield and I also have a dog. The visitors to the airfield with their dogs often let their pets run freely and many times end up on my property and occasionally onto County Road thru my property. The owners who don't have their pets on leashes do not even have their pets in their site so are not even under voice control. We all have to be considerate of our neighbors, their property and pets.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/31/2017 - 06:21

Permalink

David Wilson Oak Bluffs

We have walked our dog at Trade Winds daily for 13 years. We live in Oak Bluffs and cherish both our dog and nature. Anyone can see the great damage that has been done to the center of the runways by overuse. We use the perimeter path exclusively to walk our dog, and at the Land Bank's request, now avoid the one cutoff we formerly used. We are surprised and disheartened by the ignorance or disregard some show to the property, and immensely grateful to the MV Land Bank for preserving the natural heritage of the Island.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/31/2017 - 08:07

Permalink

Jan DeLisle Oak Bluffs

We're grateful to have places where our dog can run off leash and socialize with other dogs. Many thanks to the Land Bank for keeping MV animal friendly.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/31/2017 - 09:45

Permalink

Pam Thors Edgartown

Whatever we (the users of the park) can do to help in this situation, let us do it in order to have the use of this great asset to the dog loving community. Need help with the signs? Count me in. thank you for bringing these issues to the forefront. Would hate to lose the dog park.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/31/2017 - 10:50

Permalink

Idalyn Gilstad Vineyard Haven

I am disheartened by these comments by people who don't know the history of the back and forth relationship between the landbank and the dog walkers. The runway is damaged by planes and weather more than anything. It's a runway after all.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/31/2017 - 10:51

Permalink

Islander Too

Dog owners need to get together and purchase their own dog run.

It is unacceptable that land bought with public funds, to preserve the environment, biodiversity, etc. for animals and thus, indirectly, for humans too, gets taken over by one species---the domesticated dog. This is a travesty.
Dogs off LB lands, unless the lands have been purchased specifically for the use of dogs and their owners.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/31/2017 - 14:46

Permalink

Rebekah Vineyard haven

Once again it comes down to the haves and the have nots. This land is all of ours and since only two pilots actually use airfield it shouldn't be considered a airstrip. It should be used and enjoyed by all its a field and woods and cutting a new path across it doesn't affect anything it's just a way to keep out the public from yet another place on the vineyard. First we can't go on the beaches then we can only look at land but not walk through it so a mansion can have a view of the water. It's disgusting people complaining about a sand path ruining a field please give me a break.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 04/01/2017 - 00:55

Permalink

Sarah Oak Bluffs

I am an abutter to Tradewinds and the dogs occasionally come into my yard, have even come onto my porch, and do [seldomly] crap in the yard. The owners are still out in the field, blissfully unaware and letting their dog experience canine "freedom". One time I was pulling my child in a sled (on the dirt path only and NOT a hard or bladed sled, conservation crew!) and an unattended orange Chow Chow cornered him and lunged at him. It IS a dog park, but the owner was nowhere to be seen and we narrowly escaped a face bite. 2 other times I was jogging and had dogs approach me suddenly and not in a friendly way: unleashed, no owner in sight. I was a dog owner for years, and love dogs, but some of the owners are completely negligent. I've stepped in crap and had to clean my shoes a bunch of times.
I think my problem with the leashless aspect is that the shape of the path has blind spots, this is a safety issue. The dogs that don't mind their owners are all over the place, in the middle of the field, and also wrestling 5 other dogs over tennis balls. They get nuts and though they are just being dogs and having fun, I don't see how that is lower impact on the endangered grass and beetles (?). I have also seen the planes land [also seldom] and of course it beats up the grass!
If someone would make another decently sized, designated area for dogs it would lower the impact on Tradewinds by default: adding another outlet is key for dog lovers. When you only have a handful of places that you can go, they will be overused.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 04/03/2017 - 11:13

Permalink

Phil Regan Oak Bluffs

On a separate but similar note, unfortunately Penn Field, which is just a couple of hundred yards from the dog park, has become a favorite for dog walkers. I have crossed paths with 20 or so dog walkers since last fall and had to remind each of them that Penn Field is for youth baseball play, not dog walking. Many have said they appreciate the fenced area, and they always clean up after their dogs. Maybe so, but the reality is that many do not clean up after their dogs which results in an unapologetic setting for the kids. Equally disappointing is the damage done to the grass by dogs that like to dig. The holes need to be repaired so ankle injuries and/or bad baseball hops are not the result. A lot of effort went into building Penn Field as a safe place for "kids" to play. Please walk your dogs at the dog park.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/04/2017 - 13:46

Permalink

Diane Nicholls Oak Bluffs

This is a wonderful place for us and for our dogs. I stay on the path and while my 16 year old dog can no longer walk the entire loop, we take shorter walks starting on the perimeter path and then returning through the woods - there are wooded trails at each end of the airfield. I started walking around the airfield before it was purchased by the land bank. There were more planes in those earlier years and yet the field was in a lovely natural state. It has certainly deteriorated over the last 15 years. Let's voluntarily restrict our use in order to preserve this lovely property for our use far into the future.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.