Roy Imhoff

Penny Candy Memories of Oak Bluffs

My family, extended and otherwise, has been a part of Martha’s Vineyard, and Oak Bluffs in particular, since the 1920s.

My family, extended and otherwise, has been a part of Martha’s Vineyard, and Oak Bluffs in particular, since the 1920s. My memories and youthful experiences are still quite vivid. As the saying goes, getting there was half the fun. In those days we took the New Haven Hartford Railroad from South Station in Boston to the ferry. The Steamship Authority (although it was not called that then) had in its fleet four steamboats. The first motor car ferry was an old East River, N.Y. ferry.

Upon arriving in Oak Bluffs, one was confronted with the block-long Tivoli building, where the police station and offices now stand. The Tivoli building had open balconies on three sides and a very large dance floor. Directly across the street on the corner, where now we have the Santander Bank, was an open roller skating rink called The Sea Breeze where one could rent skates and attempt skating on a severely tilted track.

Directly adjacent was Bill Jones Bowling Alley 10. I believe the price was 20 or 25 cents per string. I attempted setting pins for .07 cents per string when I was 14 years old, taking my life, bruises and insults as they came. The pin setter sat on a small bench behind the pins in a pit. My mother made me quit as I was having nightmares at night, yelling “lookout” and “duck.”

Adjoining the Bowling Alley, where the Chowder House is now, was the Sea Breeze Garage, which I had the opportunity to purchase with Anthony Rebello. My uncle Jerry Barmakian — an aristocrat in his own mind — would call the garage and the attendants would clean and shine his car and deliver it directly to the Boston House which he owned.

Continuing westward was the Strand Theatre, in about the same state of disrepair then as now. Across the street was Alpha Leonards Texaco Gas Station, now Jim’s Package Store. I worked there two summers with Alan “Red” McPherson, pumping gas and refurbishing fishing rods. Alpha was a classic Damon Runyon character and quite frugal. He used to drain residue from used quarts of oil and could salvage a quart from 10 used quarts. He also washed his paper bills, usually single dollars only, and let them dry in the window.

Church’s Pier was where the smaller fishing boats came in. The bulkhead on the harbor had not been built and clamming and quahogging was ongoing. The harbor was not yet contaminated.

The pier was a busy place. Joe Pina operated a paddle boat fleet there, which he purchased from the 1939 World’s Fair, and Doc Amaral, the dentist, would go swordfishing from there every Sunday morning, weather permitting. If he caught one, he would sell them to Uncle Jerry to serve at the Boston House. My twin brother Diran and I would use a little red wagon to make the delivery to my uncle.

Our Market was still in its current location back then, although much smaller. It was owned by Brad Church but managed by Amos Amaral and two slightly overactive sons. Further around the bend, where now stands the Ocean View Restaurant, was a small hotel owned by Joseph Sylvia, the former State Representative for whom State Beach was named (then called Sylvia Beach).

I used to sweep the inside of the Island Theatre with my friend Donnie Glenn for about 75 cents per hour. Up the street a bit, adjoining the Boston House, was the epitome of temptation, Darling’s Salt Water Taffy. For many years Darlings was owned and operated by Mr. and Mrs. Arnold Carr.

Adjoining Darlings was an auction gallery operated by the Matarr family from Hot Springs Arkansas, and next store was an ice cream soda fountain, and then came Mr. and Mrs. Kligler’s fruit and produce store. Beyond Kliglers was a very fine Japanese gift and apparel store. Unfortunately, the proprietors were extricated and sent to a Japanese detainment camp because of the attack on Pearl Harbor.

Across the street, DaRosa’s print shop has been an eternal fixture and fortunately so. Next came Stan Garland’s Red and White meat market.

Phillips Hardware was smaller back then, and the Herald Drug Store was really only a long ice cream and soda fountain operated by two rather comical New York City transplants. Next was Clayton Hoyle’s Clothing and Apparel store, above which was the Rod and Gun club, wherein some private stock was isolated per patron and some raucous personal gambling ensued. Beyond Hoyle’s was the Victorian Metropolitan Hotel, a true white elephant as we say today. It was perhaps built in the 1880’s and unoccupied. It was purchased by my Uncle Jerry, he did circulate. Later, the hotel was knocked down and in its place today stands the Corner Store, the Post Office, Back Door Donuts etc.

Ritchie Giordano’s grandfather and grandmother operated the original Giordano’s restaurant opposite where Back Door Donuts exists today. There were about six or seven booths all painted with enamel orange and black. On one side of the store front was a white metal statuette. Every June, Mrs. Giordano would place a long length of macaroni there. By August it would dehydrate and fall, never to be replaced as it was too close to end of season.

The journey continues on to Frye’s Shoe Repair, Dr. Glenn’s Medical office, Guy Clement’s Gift Store and Buddy Pease’s Ritz Bar, smaller then but up to the standard of a true gent’s pub.

Today, Giordano’s Restaurant and Clam Bar anchors the corner spot. The property was previously occupied by a seafood restaurant. Across the street and always in flight was and is the Flying Horses. A tall and rangy fellow I knew drew a record 13 rings at one pass. Back then a ride cost five cents and they always had penny candy. I’ve always felt moderately guilty that I kept two rings and still have them to this day. Should return them? Who would know?

My journey to the past could continue on and on, but I feel an awake audience surpasses a sleeping one, at least most of the time. Questions and vagaries are always welcome and are perhaps of valid concern.

Vaughn Barmakian lives in Winchester and Oak Bluffs.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 05:55

Permalink

Pat Hughes Oak Bluffs

My mother, Margaret Ferriera Valenti born in 1913 often told me stories about her years growing up in Oak Bluffs. She especially loved dancing at the Tivioli. She was a waitress at one of the restaurants on Circuit Ave. She would come home, change her clothes and run off to the Tivioli. I enjoyed this look back in time of downtown Circuit Ave. Thanks.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 06:27

Permalink

John Wiener Boulder, CO

Thanks for the memories -- our father and his brothers and parents and aunt had such wonderful times in the 1890s - 1920s....
Then, grandfather was captain of a minesweeper in WW 1. After that, the boys fell in love with Gay Head and the fishing. But even into the 1960s there were penny candy memories of O.B. and Edgartown even though they were far down island...

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 10:14

Permalink

Vicki Divoll Chilmark

Wow, even for those of us who have been coming to, and now live on, the Vineyard only since 1980, this brings up great memories. My children, now in their 30s, will love the stories of places they went to as kids, though they will highly doubt the 13 rings legend!! Flying horses followed by Giordano's is part of our family's memories, and you bring it back to the 20s! Well done!!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 12:54

Permalink

Charlie Shabica Oak Bluffs

Wow, thanks Vaughn! Brought back great memories of arriving on the train in Woods Hole in the 1950s. Beyond the end of the track was Poole's Fish Market. As kids in Oak Bluffs we were thrilled with Ladies Wrestling at the Tivoli, followed by a round on the flying horses and watching the taffy machine at Darlings! With luck Grampa Arthur Wright bought us ice cream at the Arcade.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 14:11

Permalink

Jim

Great story I can relate. You pumped gas at the Jim's Package store site when it was Leonard's Texaco and I pumped at the Jim's Package store site when it was BenDavid Motors Texaco. Great summers!!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 17:55

Permalink

Steve OB

Great historical review! My family joined the history in the early 50's when my mom visited the island with friends. Her uncle owned the bike shop that was in front of the Flying Horses. My dad worked weekends fixing bikes in the shop basement. We stayed on Circuit Ave. ext next to the Andersons. Now we love our MV life on Trinity Park across from the Tabernacle.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 18:02

Permalink

Nyx Edinburgh

I LOVE reminisces like these! Oral history is a wonderful thing and really brings the past to life for those of us who came later to O.B.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2017 - 20:52

Permalink

Dan Hastings McLean, Virginia

13 rings at one time?? Maybe I wasn't putting rings out that day. The record to my knowledge was always 8.

Bob Dumais Oak Bluffs/Naples Florida

You always had enough time to practice getting the rings since your father owned the place you could and did ride when ever you wanted! I hope your well, happy memories Dan.....seems like only yesterday.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/11/2017 - 13:09

Permalink

Barbara Carmel, NY

I really enjoyed reading about OB long ago. I look forward to more articles!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 03/12/2017 - 13:37

Permalink

LynBugbee Florida

I so remember the 13 ring legion ... I was jealous of one would got 11 and we all ad to wait while they counted out his free tickets, one per ring. I was so upset when they replaced all the candy with pin ball machines as I was no longer allowed to go without an adult. The wrong crowd gathered there now. At the far end way outside the main stream was Billiards where we were allowed a molded chocolate lollipop. It was always a struggle to choose. There so many, but scallop and horse usually won my eye!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 03/12/2017 - 14:50

Permalink

Bill McGrath Oak Bluffs

Love your stories and memories, Vaughn. What do you recall of the Pawnee House?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 03/12/2017 - 18:53

Permalink

Sarah Costa East Machias Maine

I enjoyed the trip back in time! It was such a fun place to be in the summertime! Always lots of action! Thanks for the memories.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 03/13/2017 - 12:29

Permalink

Ginny Coutinho Tisbury - but Oak Bluffs native

Fun article. Grew up in OB so recall every bit of it. Also recall my parents stories of their younger days ballroom dancing at the Tivoli to well known bands that came to OB harbor on their own boats. But my penny candy memories were all at Leonard's gas station! Thanks for the trip down memory lane.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 03/14/2017 - 11:02

Permalink

Joan Boyken New Jersey

Thank you for the trip back in time. My mother grew up in Oak Bluffs in the 1920's and 30's and I've been coming to the Vineyard since the early 1940's.
My parents were friends of the Jones's (Bill & Bertha) who owned the bowling alley and I grew up with the the Jones boys, Will & Richard.
I also set pins a couple of times but decided quickly it wasn't for me.
Darling's was always a stop on the way to the movies for a popcorn bar.
Another place on Circuit Ave that was a regular stop after the movies was the Frosty Cottage for ice cream.
Thank you again for the memories and for bringing some to mind that I'd forgotten about.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 03/14/2017 - 19:58

Permalink

Bijan Bayne WASHINGTON

Only in those days it was called 'S.S. Pierce' (in a S.E. Mass accent "ess-ess-pious"). As for rings at the Horses, by the time I was around eight, I could grab eight if I leaned back.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 03/14/2017 - 20:15

Permalink

Greg Robinson Naples, Fl

I worked at the same bowling alley for a summer at .09 cents a string, plus tips (according to Mr. Jones) which no one ever gave you. I also was Ring boy for a month for Mr. Hastings at the Flying Houses, best job ever. Coin diving was my day job bringing in a buck or 2 but it was enough for some french frys from the Clam Bar and pin ball at the Flying Horses for the night.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 11/08/2017 - 17:11

Permalink

Deborah

Does anyone remember the Penny Candy Store in Edgartown in the early 1960s? Better yet, does anyone have any photos. My family vacationed there in 1962 and I remember the shop so well. You really could get a bag of candy for a nickel, or something like that. Also, I wonder if any of the commentators here remember a girl's camp in West Chop called the School of Creative Arts? A Facebook group has grown up around it for former alumni, as well as for Islanders and people who are just interested in the fascinating history of that summer school.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 10/23/2024 - 02:43

Permalink

M. Glenn-Nash California

I have no idea how I ended up in this article, but thank you so much for recounting these memories. Don Glenn was my grandfather and seeing his name made me so happy. I am retracing his roots, and I never expected to find a first hand account of him AND the location of his dad’s office. Thank you, thank you, thank you!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.