<p>An 88-year-old Colonial revival home on East Chop Drive known as Big Bluff was demolished Monday. Neighbors gathered to share memories as the bulldozer did its work.</p>
An 88-year-old Colonial revival home on East Chop Drive known as Big Bluff was demolished Monday.
The house facing Vineyard Sound was owned by three families and associated the longest with the Ivisons: Sterling and Katherine Ivison raised their family in the home before passing it down to Sterling (Skip) Ivison 3rd and his late wife, Leigh Ivison.
Last October, the house was sold for about $2.2 million to Paul and Gretchen Massey. Oak Bluffs building inspector Mark Barbadoro said no special permits were required to demolish the house. As the house is less than 100 years old, it is not eligible for the demolition delay bylaw that gives the historic commission oversight.
Plans to rebuild a house on the property are with the board of health now, Mr. Barbadoro said, and once approved construction can begin.
On Monday onlookers gathered to watch the demolition and share memories of Big Bluff, where the Ivisons hosted parties that would spill from the back porch to the first floor of the house.
“It was a beautiful party house,” said Ted Meleney, the husband of Kate (Ivison) Meleney. “Everyone on East Chop was invited to parties here.”
A pile of beach stones from the fireplace were piled behind the house. Shutters from the house can be placed in a trailer behind Mr. Meleney’s car. Katherine (Tottie) Ivison used to paint closed eyelids with lashes on the shutters in the winter, putting the house to sleep, he said.
“We spent a lot of time in that house, that’s for sure,” Mr. Meleney said.
Kate Meleney also kept a section of wall where visitors dating back to the first years of the house had written messages about their stays, according to David Stephens, her brother Skip’s best friend.
Mr. Stephens said he had been coming out to the house nearly every day since work trucks arrived, taking pictures each time. On Monday he arrived after the demolition had started.
“I was going to paint my house today,” Mr. Stephens said. “But now I’ve got to watch the old lady go.”
Skip Ivison bought a piece of land nearby, where he plans to build a small house. And while Mr. Stephens said he has many memories from the old homestead, the memories stem from the family.
“The people who are here, who make a house a home, are gone,” Mr. Stephens said.
“The Masseys, I’m sure, will put up something beautiful,” he added.
Martha Wilder, a friend of the late Leigh Ivison, watched as a claw-foot bathtub from the servants’ bathroom was pulled out of the left side of the house.
“Those walls have lots of stories to tell,” she said.
Joan Jecoy arrived as half of the front side of the house was reduced to a pile of boards. She didn’t know the Ivisons personally, she said but her daughter had cleaned the house for the Estelle family, who owned the house before Ivisons.
“It was always such a pretty house,” Ms. Jecoy said.
Bicyclists paused mid-ride to watch and nearly everyone present documented the demolition with cameras, including some of the crew. And though many onlookers said they were sad to see Big Bluff go, they also noted the beating a house on the bluff takes from the open exposure to the wind and water.
“You feel kind of nostalgic,” said Ms. Wilder. “At the same time, it was inevitable.”

Comments
Remember this house well
jack conway Sarasota flRemember this house well
What a colossal waste, they
Gabrielle West TisburyWhat a colossal waste, they should have at least salvaged the building. Demo laws should make it mandatory that it be advertised in the paper as a house available for moving. I believe Nantucket does this, what a waste.
I agree...how can they do it?
Dorothy wass Ft,wayne, INI agree...how can they do it? We bought a used kitchen stove from them years ago and always found it sad when the little shutters with sleeping eyes appeared in the fall!
Dorothy - you can look for
Kate Ivison Meleney East ChopDorothy - you can look for those sleeping eyes on my little cottage on Crystal Lake this fall. We hope to resize them to fit. You should be able to see them from East Chop Drive.
Shame on the town board of
Christine VHShame on the town board of Oak Bluffs or whoever else lets island history get knocked down.....
Come to Edgartown they do it
diane edgartownCome to Edgartown they do it all the time and by the time the landscaping is done you would never know it wasn't a historical home. It's amazing. I am sure the owners will build a beautiful home and create their own memories. This is becoming a year round island and people need heat etc to enjoy their home year round. The island has bigger worries to think about. Let's welcome the new owners and wish them luck and happiness.
Well said Diane
Scot East Lyme CTWell said Diane
That was a nice home., it
Steve Boyleston Summer dale AlabamaThat was a nice home., it should have been relocated., that happens all of the time ., reset up. You think what kind of money does a person have to pay 2,200,000.00 then tear a house down. It seems to me that the more money a person has the less caring that they are. I mean how much does a person need., that the old home was knocked down? Also the. Framing materials in that house are way better than they can buy. Salvage at last resort. Oh well time and history and uncaring people erase it all.
In this instance you know not
Patsy McCornack Vineyard HavenIn this instance you know not whereof you speak! The new owners of the Big Bluff are fine, caring people and will build an equally beautiful, non mega mansion home. Because they had good fortune financially, due to the hard work of building a successful business, is no reason to castigate them! Shame!
Have been in Big Bluff many
Bob Reagan East ChopHave been in Big Bluff many times and it was a grand old lady that needed a ton of work. The Massey’s are class people and I am sure they will build a house that we will admire for the next hundred years.
Agreed Bob, my understanding
Joseph Paul Uranker Oak BluffsAgreed Bob, my understanding was the family tried to do restoration on the home and with all the new building codes it made it unreasonable to do so. The Massey family did what was the only logical choice left to them.I find it interesting that those who have no financial interest with the project are experts on how to save the home or move it. Running by the home almost daily the home had been empty for a long time and in need of repair. I think the new home will be a fine addition to the neighborhood, also it will be enjoyable to see the building being built.
My husband and I were
Jodie Falkenburg Oak BluffsMy husband and I were saddened to learn that Big Bluff is gone. We live on the Campground in Oak Bluffs permanently now but when we came on vacation, we always would drive to East Chop to see if the eyes on Big Bluff were opened or closed. When we left for America after our vacation ended we would check out Big Bluff once more to see if those eyes were opened or closed. We really will miss them as they were always special and so funny to see. Jodie Falkenburg
I had a lot of fun with the
Christopher L. Sparks Maastricht, NLI had a lot of fun with the son of Skip, Will, and some other good friends. Was lucky enough to meet the Rileys and some other friends of the family while I was there. Sad to see it go but there is only so much land on an island like that and others should be allowed to create their own memories as well.
I always get a kick out of
deshandra brown mvI always get a kick out of the strong opinions here.
If you thought it was so special, why didn't you buy it.
Just because something is old doesn't mean its worth restoring and preserving.
I'm sure the owner will put something nice there, its not like they bought it, knocked it down, and put up a shopping mall with a bunch of condos.
Big Bluff was a wonderful
Nancy ProtzmannBig Bluff was a wonderful home. I had the good fortune to live just a few houses down, for all of my childhood and much of my adult life. The Ivisons are classy folks and I have known Skip for years. I also am very fond of the Masseys and have also known them for a very long time. They are very good people and I know they went into this project with care and thoughtfulness and sensitivity. If you don't know the ins and outs of the project who are you to judge. I have no doubt they will build a lovely and classy home that fits right in. And good for them. Paul built a wonderful company from the ground up, and a lot of his success was his attention to his employees - treating them right and providing them the opportunity to thrive. They love East Chop and I know they will build a wonderful home that will thrive for generations to come.
Big Bluff is not going away.
John Miller Milton MassachusettsBig Bluff is not going away. It just got better!! There is no better family to recreate this historical house. Congrats to the Massey Family.
Add new comment