Jack Koontz wrote On the Line, a fishing column for the Gazette, for nearly a decade in the late 1970s and 1980s.
Editor’s Note: Jack Koontz wrote On the Line, a fishing column for the Gazette, for nearly a decade in the late 1970s and 1980s. Word reached the Vineyard this week that Mr. Koontz had died on July 16 at the age of 70. What follows is a column he wrote in May 1980.
I remember my first fish. I was very young — probably four or five years old — when my father placed a small fishing rod in my hands. He assured me that eventually, something would bite the piece of bloodworm on the end of my hook. I must have patience, he said. I believed him. And he was right.
We were at a small pond behind my grandfather’s house near Annapolis, Maryland. The pond was brackish and through a series of culverts it emptied into the Chesapeake Bay. Somehow a small perch found its way into the pond and to my hook, just as my father had said. It was no more than six inches long and probably younger than the fisherman. But it didn’t matter. It was a fish: I had caught it myself.
The fish didn’t make it to the dinner table, or to the breakfast plate. It was too tiny for any fixings. The perch went to the freezer, wrapped in a sliver of butcher’s paper — my frozen prize.
That fish remained solid in my grandfather’s freezer at least a year. I would look at it, show it as proof to my friends that I had indeed taken a trophy from the back door pond. It was a frigid mount and could I have hung it on my bedroom wall, there would probably be a telling stain there today.
It all happened almost 30 years ago. Things have changed. These days my father comes north to fish with me. It’s a pleasure to repay the favor.
I remember his first trip to the Vineyard. West Tisbury Pond had been opened to the ocean — it was spring. Striped bass were in season. They had, as my father, made a trip up the Atlantic coast from the Chesapeake Bay to New England. I hoped there would be a meeting between the traveling fisherman and the migrating fish.
No. It didn’t really matter if we caught anything, my father assured me. The day was gorgeous. It was great to be on the Vineyard. It was fun to be together, he said more than once. I knew he was sincere. We had had many fishless days on the Chesapeake — there are dues to be paid. The first day of Island surfcasting would not necessarily be any different. Yet we both knew that it is much more exciting to catch fish than not. And I wanted a fish for him probably more than he wanted one for himself. It was a good day, fish or not, but a striper would surely help.
The first day was a leisurely one. No dawn sorties to the beach, no plugging the surf at midnight. Dad had driven 500 miles the day before and this was, after all, a vacation, not the first day of surf fishing boot camp. We arrived at the pond opening at the gentlemanly morning hour of 11.
The first hour was spent practicing with the long surf rods and casting lures over the high breakers. No fish were sighted, no bird diving, there was no activity other than our own exertions on the beach side of the waves.
Time for lunch. Sandwiches for us and fresh squid set on bottom hooks for a hungry striped bass. I’m not a master sandwichmaker, just basic stuff, but the piece of squid that I stuck on my father’s hook had the same effect as that little piece of bloodworm he had fastened to my own hook many years before. This however was no small perch.
Dad’s line suddenly went tearing from the reel — the sandwich was discarded. My father’s face went blank with the sudden hit. For an instant, he wasn’t quite sure what to do, but only for an instant. Quickly the rod was grabbed from the spike and his expression changed from blank chagrin to excited concentration. There was a fish on the line, and it was a good one.
The striper swam down the surf line to the west, moving with the tide. The fisherman moved with it. I went for the gaff as the fish pulled the line at an angle into the surf. Soon the fish tired and beneath the foam of the breakers was its sleek body, ribbed with black stripes, and framed in the curl of a wave. Now the fish was clearly visible — it was a fine bass of about 25 pounds.
Next came the precarious task of landing the fish in the surf — the peril of carefully working it through the waves. The tug of the receding wave had to be considered against the pressure on the line. Mr. Koontz, senior, did just fine. I — the junior Koontz, waded out with the gaff.
As I took the fish, relieved that the job was done, I turned to see my father standing in the sand, beaming a smile so large and so happy, anything broader would have broken his face.
Now there are three of us on the beach — an ecstatic fisherman, a happy host, and a 25-pound striped bass who should have been pleased by the memories and happiness his catch provided. And the bass was the centerpiece for some wonderful meals cooked for a very proud Marylander.
Dad’s fish spent no time in the freezer. The big bass went directly to a charcoal grill in a backyard just south of Annapolis. Just a few miles down the bay, I had caught my first fish many years before.

Comments
RIP Derby Jack. It was great
Jesse Reinfelder NYCRIP Derby Jack. It was great to have known you.
We lost a great fisherman,
Richard Garcia West TisburyWe lost a great fisherman, writer and friend.A brave and gentle soul who fought to the end.
Thank you for reprinting my
Bonnie Adams Kapp Columbia, South CarolinaThank you for reprinting my favorite cousin's story. I could feel his spirit and love of the Vineyard, Nantucket and Cape Cod as I read this. He was born to breathe salt air and have his feet wet. A great fellow, a thoughtful, sensitive gentleman. I'm so grateful to all of you, colleagues and friends. Thank you, thank you.
I wish I had known him better
Hester Martin Wells, MEI wish I had known him better but I agree he was a wonderful man. I am sorry we didn't get together more often.
Love,
Babe
Sail on, Derby Jack. The
Glenn Murphy BostonSail on, Derby Jack. The Vineyard, and the World, are smaller without you.
I was stationed at Menemsha
Ned Casey EdgartownI was stationed at Menemsha in the Coast Guard. I was 18 Years old. I spent some of my summers on the cape. Fishing the Brewster flats with a hand me down fishing rod and not enough line on the spool. Throwing a small Atom popper and tried catching schoolie bass. Here I was on the Vineyard. It didn't take long to find out that fishing here was serious. And great sized stripers abounded in these waters. I used to see Danny Bryant, Whit Manter, and Jack unload their catches of the night before at Pooles fish market. They were all big fish. I wanted one too. Jack was at the chandlery making rods, smoking his pipe. selling assorted tackle. I would visit his shop almost daily. Jack finally asked me about getting a surf rod to be able to catch a large striper from the surf. He made me my first saltwater rod. And fitted it with a green Penn 704. A few assorted lures that he guaranteed would work under the right conditions. After many trips learning and following these men of the surf. I caught my first striper in the waves of Quansoo. Jack was always kind and somewhat mild mannered. I followed him to West Tisbury where he opened his new shop and wrote his column. He was a fishermans friend and I shall never forget the night I Happened to bump into him below the cliffs of Gay Head at some ungodly hour. He had 2 fine bass on the beach. And all he said to me was they're here. We fished till the sun broke the morning twilight and it was time to go. I caught one nice fish. Jack caught 4. I helped carry his catch, dragging them in the surf tripping over rocks and boulders. When we reached the truck he smiled and said thanks. He said fishing was all timing, tide and much luck. This was 42 years ago. I will remember his smile, pipe and good advise to this day. Fair winds Jack, Fair tides. And tight lines old friend
Jack was a good friend of my
Erika Andresen Boulder,CO and ChilmarkJack was a good friend of my Dad's and I will remember him fondly.
RIP Jack,you were a great fisherman and a beautiful writer,thank you for the stories.
Fair well friend. Your heart,
Ted Oquinn Wrightsville Beach NCFair well friend. Your heart, as broad and deep as the sea has touched many shores.
I wish I had known Jack when
Deborah Hood Gulf Shores, ALI wish I had known Jack when he fished the Tisbury Pond and had the tackle shop. We met a few years later when I joined Salt Water Sportsman. It was then that I became part of the Salt Water family and found in Jack a big brother. There were no people that I grew to love more than this tight knit and very successful family.
Jack was one of the kindest and most gentle men I've ever met. He was protective of the people he cared about and was willing to fight for whatever he felt was "the true North".
Jack had known the love of his life for years before they fell in love and married. Jaye and Jack were truly a match like few others and their love helped him endure and live probably much longer as a result.
It's so hard to say goodbye to such a dear friend. But Jack will always be just a memory away.
Derby Jack, you will always
Betty Murphy Getzville, NYDerby Jack, you will always be one of my boys. A favorite cousin and friend of all the Murphy family, thank you for all the wonderful memories.
Add new comment