Dilapidated Entwhistle building on the harbor will likely be demolished.
Mark Lovewell

Last Building Standing: Selectmen Order Demolition at Boch Park

<p>Tisbury selectmen will take steps to remove a derelict building on the harborfront property known as Boch Park, owned by Ernie Boch Jr. Mr. Boch said he is happy the building will come down.

Tisbury selectmen will take steps to remove a derelict building on the harborfront property known as Boch Park.

Last week selectmen gave the town building inspector the go-ahead to demolish the building at 20 Beach Road owned by Ernie Boch Jr.

For the past three years building inspector Kenneth Barwick has been working with spokesmen for Mr. Boch to have the building razed. Mr. Barwick told the selectmen last week that talks had broken off after he tried to have the property owner apply for a demolition permit and take down the building at his own expense.

Bought by the late Ernie Boch Sr. in 1987, the property has been the source of on-and-off legal disputes between the owner and the town over the years. At one point the senior Mr. Boch wanted to operate valet parking on the site but was denied a permit by the planning board. A series of appeals and court disputes followed, with the town eventually prevailing.

Following Mr. Boch’s death in 2003, his son took ownership of the property.

Four buildings originally stood on the site, which had housed Hancock Hardware and Builders Inc. Currently only one remains, the dilapidated Entwhistle building.

In a process allowed by state law, Mr. Barwick now plans to assemble an assessment team that includes the fire chief, a professional engineer and one lay person to inspect the building. If they concur with the building inspector’s findings that the building is dangerous, unsafe or a public nuisance, demolition can begin.

If the town pays for removal, a lien will be placed on the property to recover costs. Tisbury finance director Jonathan Snyder warned it could take awhile to get the money back.

“Especially given this particular customer, we may create a lien and liability, but there is no guarantee he will be pay that any time soon, we could be carrying that lien for a very long time,” Mr. Snyder told the selectmen.

But reached by telephone later, Mr. Boch said he was happy the building would be coming down.

“I wanted to knock it down, but I wanted to retain the footprint,” he said. “I talked with my guy, and I guess everything is all set, we’re going to knock it down.”

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/10/2016 - 20:15

Permalink

Sara Piazza Edgartown

Kinda sad to see these old buildings go, buildings with character and history. Even sadder to see the Island sanitized and gentrified.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/10/2016 - 21:31

Permalink

Lori Edg

I can still see Eleanor standing in the doorway,another bit of history...going

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 05/11/2016 - 11:12

Permalink

Cara Slats Braintree / West Tis

About time!! It's unfortunate the Boch family let the building fall into such disrepair, as it was far from this condition in 1987. Hopefully the property will be developed into something that suits the needs and style/character of the town. An extension of the cute boutiques on the Black Dog side would be great and suitable for people on foot.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 05/11/2016 - 12:57

Permalink

Rick Heath Chatham, Mass

If I understand the article. Ernie Boch Jr owns the building. The town negotiated in good faith with a Boch representative to have him take out a permit and have HIM pay for the demolition cost. The talks fell through and now the TOWN? is absorbing the cost to have this torn down? Are you kidding me? Put a lien on that trophy home of his at the very least to get the cost back.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 05/11/2016 - 18:36

Permalink

deshandra brown mv

I'd have to guess that in order to preserve the right to build on the current footprint with the pre-existing setbacks it had to come to this. I doubt Mr. Boch is expecting the town to absorb the cost( and no worries the town/taxpayers will not) From what I have read about him (and I don't know him or his daddy (RIP Ernie)) he is a philanthropic person around the Island so I'm sure things will work themselves out.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 05/12/2016 - 00:56

Permalink

frank brunelle

It took a long time for this to happen. There are three oil tanks that are also condemned at the other end of Beach Road and a falling down fish processing plant as well in an area that could be a huge asset to the town. However, the selectmen do not consider this area important and are fine with the structures as they are. And it is understandable that the town does not want to pay for the removals. It would be very expensive to the taxpayers, and so the same issue exists wherever there are condemned properties.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 05/12/2016 - 08:32

Permalink

Noreen Flanders Tisbury

If I remember correctly, Mr. Boch, Sr. wanted to tear it down as it was in bad shape, but was told since it was "historic" he could not. The Bochs have been blocked with the parking lot idea, but the SSA and the town were looking at it for parking?? I may not know all the details, but this seems to me to be good for the town. What a great vista has been opened up by the removal of the other buildings on that site.

Steve Jenkinson

I believe that's pretty much true. Ernie Sr. was facing opposition to any of his plans, because he wasn't so popular with some people. Time kept passing and the buildings just kept getting in worse and worse shape. It's a shame, I remember going to get hardware and paint there with my father, but all things pass.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.