At 86 years old, Tisbury School is structurally sound but lacks adequate space.
Timothy Johnson

Tisbury School Feasibility Study Set for Town Meeting Vote

<p>The Tisbury school building project comes up for a pivotal decision in two weeks, when town voters will be asked to approve funding for the initial phase of the project.

The Tisbury school building project comes up for a pivotal decision in two weeks, when town voters will be asked to approve funding for the initial phase of the project.

In late January school leaders learned from the Massachusetts School Building Authority that the school had advanced to the next step of a grant process that is expected to lead to funding and planning assistance for a new school. Out of 96 schools that applied, eight were accepted in this round.

The red brick school situated a few blocks from Main street Vineyard Haven was built in 1929 and has not seen a significant upgrade in two decades. The K through eight school is known for its academic excellence.

A 19-member school building committee that will collaborate with the MSBA held its first meeting Tuesday, followed by a PTO meeting and tour of the school.

At the annual town meeting April 12, voters will be asked to spend $825,000 for a feasibility study, schematic design and site and environmental testing for the new school. The estimated cost was developed based on projects of similar scale in Bourne and Hanover, with an added 10 per cent for the so-called Island factor.

The feasibility study is considered a crucial first step for the town in developing plans to upgrade the elementary school.

The article needs a two-thirds majority on the town meeting floor to pass and also must be approved in the ballot box April 26 where voters will be asked to exempt the borrowing from the provisions of Proposition 2 1/2.

The feasibility study and schematic design will outline the type of design, location and estimated cost. Whether to rebuild or relocate the school remains be decided, with guidance from the school building authority.

“Tisbury is a small town — there are limited options for where it can be,” school principal John Custer said at the meeting.

The town will be eligible for reimbursement from the state for part of the cost of the project; currently reimbursement is pegged at 41.26 per cent, but that number could go up, Mr. Custer said. The percentage would increase for features such as an environmentally-friendly design.

The Tisbury School is the oldest elementary school building on the Island. The gymnasium was built in 1938. The last major addition was built in the 1990s and included a library, two kindergarten classrooms and two science classrooms. But the primary issue with the school is space and not age, Mr. Custer said, noting that the building is structurally sound.

Overcrowding at the school has been well documented. Five lunch periods are needed to accommodate all 315 students in the eight-table lunch room. The gymnasium doubles as a classroom when needed. Language arts, special education, technology and science spaces all need upgrades, Mr. Custer said.

“Competition for space creates scheduling challenges,” he said. “Consider two different teachers working with fifth graders and eighth graders trying to teach at the same time . . . it’s just difficult.”

Two modular units leased in 2002 for temporary space needs are now owned by the school.

“We could not function without that space,” Mr. Custer said. “It’s not suitable, but it’s what we have right now.”

HVAC and electrical systems are becoming increasingly difficult to maintain, Mr. Custer said.

On Tusday Mr. Custer urged the PTO to help get out the vote at town meeting.

“1930 — 2016, Tisbury doesn’t build a school very often,” he said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/31/2016 - 09:58

Permalink

Seamond Roberts Pineville, LA

I really understand the crowding situation; back when I attended 1946-1957, it was already overcrowded THEN; we had Latin and French in the teacher's cloak room; music on the storage room behind the stage; and library was part of our study hall which at the time was about to be turned into another two classrooms. So, even with converting this to a K-8, it has to be extremely difficult. The lunchroom situation described in the article is unimaginable to me - why has this not been fixed a long time before this? If the school continues as it is, how about buiding as an addition a whole cafeteria? If I were an island voter, I'd surely support upgrading and improving our Tisbury School

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/31/2016 - 10:46

Permalink

Very Annoyed Vineyard Haven

I find the lack of planning from the school committee appalling regarding the school building budget!!! Remember, the High School needs to repaired or replaced!!! The school committee did not plan for that project which comes from the same money pot (taxpayers) that will happen in two years plus they want to start the building process for $825,000, that is not final price, remember that!!! We are talking millions and a huge building built per the state grant specs!! The nurse's office will be 1400 sq ft which is larger than most of the islanders homes especially the new affordable housing on Water Street. Be very careful of the emotional aspect of this warrant article because it will drain our wallets dry!!!!

Rachel Orr Vineyard Haven

I'd like to clear up misinformation, which most likely originated with me. I recently mentioned at a public meeting a figure I read in a Massachusetts State Building Authority document several years ago regarding square footage requirements; the figure I mentioned is not the current standard. Current Authority specifications require nurse's quarters serving k-8 schools to be 410 square feet. For anyone interested in learning more about what the Authority requires of its community partners, I suggest visiting the Authority's website at www.massschoolbuildings.org. The website provides a wealth of information about the process and the standards set by the Authority for the various types of schools: elementary, k-8, middle school, high school.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/01/2016 - 11:41

Permalink

Christine, VH

$825,000 for a feasibility study??? Seems that money could serve a better purpose. I won't vote for it!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 04/02/2016 - 15:07

Permalink

Ruth Campbell WT

I loved my 22 years working in the Tisbury School, with such fine faculty and students, but my health didn't.
My ground-level classroom was never renovated 20 years ago, and continued to have mold, asbestos, and ventilation
Issues my entire time there ( and the students time there). Students with asthma would have to go to the nurse
After 10 minutes. Four teachers on my level had severe vertigo attacks, frequent pneumonia, sinusitis and migraines,
As did many of the students I would suspect.
Before the renovation I had leaky Windows in my room, after new Windows it was much worse.
When I asked the installer why the sagging, rotting frames weren't replaced, he said new frames " weren't in the specs",
And I should expect it would continue to leak.
I solved my ventilation problem by keeping the door to the outside open year-long.
Before Principal DeLoach left, she agreed the many broken htiles in the classroom floor might be asbestos filled,
And the white- suit guys ended up grinding them up and replaced them.
They left me the ground dust on the table tops, on top of the light fixtures, window sills, and everywhere
Else it might have landed. Clean- up clearly wasn't in those specs either.
I loved that job, and did complain, to every principal, but it wasn't the sexy repairs my room needed: the
Frequent tours to show off the new looks skipped my room, and the home ec. Room, and sometimes the shop,
If the fumes rolling out the doors were too strong. Three rooms that your kids spent/spend many hours over
The school week in.
As you decide to renovate or build, get the specs right for All the rooms, for the kids sake, please.l

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.