Building inspector Mark Barbadoro said Tuesday he did not have faith repairs will be finished on Island Theater.
Mark Lovewell

Repairs Resume at Island Theater, Amid Talk of Demolition

<p>One day after Oak Bluffs officials threatened legal action that could lead to demolition, repair work was underway at the theater.</p>

One day after Oak Bluffs officials threatened legal action that could lead to demolition, repair work resumed at the deteriorating Island Theater. After a long period of inactivity, a crew of roofers were on the site Wednesday.

Oak Bluffs building inspector Mark Barbadoro told selectmen at their Tuesday meeting he had no faith that the Hall family, which owns the building through a trust, would finish the work.

“I’ve had a lot of complaints about the Island Theater,” Mr. Barbadoro said. “The bottom line, it’s been a very long time. If I don’t see a contractor there, I will have to move forward with the unsafe structure process. I have been trying to work with them, because it’s the easiest and best solution.”

Town officials said they receive complaints about deteriorated state of Island Theater.
Mark Lovewell
Town officials said they receive complaints about deteriorated state of Island Theater.
Mark Lovewell

The first step in the legal process took place in June when the town posted notices on the building at the foot of Circuit avenue declaring it to be seriously damaged and unsafe to occupy. Brian Hall, and contractors he hired, began repairs within a week, but the job remains unfinished nearly seven months later.

The next step, according to Mr. Barbadoro, is to have the building inspected by an independent structural engineer.

“If it’s unsafe, then we get the lawyers involved and order the building demolished,” he said. Mr. Barbadoro said he anticipates if a demolition order is issued, the matter would wind up in court. The town would have to pay for the cost of an engineer, the cost of any legal action, and the cost of demolishing the building. Mr. Barbadoro said the town could try to recover the costs by placing a lien on the property.

“There are so many people complaining about it, and asking us to get something done,” said selectman Walter Vail.

Mr. Barbadoro said the selectmen have the authority to order a demolition, under less stringent standards than the unsafe building process.

“Selectmen can knock down buildings,” Mr. Barbadoro said. “Your criteria is just urban decay.”

In other action, town administrator Bob Whritenour presented a $28.6 million town operating budget for fiscal year 2017, up 3.3 per cent over the previous year. He said he does not anticipate asking voters for more funding through a Proposition 2 1/2 override. Last year voters authorized a $650,000 override to make ends meet.

“With the growing demand for regional services, especially in the areas of education and elder services, the town has had an extremely difficult time in meeting our service delivery costs within the small amount of new revenues available each year,” Mr. Whritenour wrote in his budget recommendation report.

The town administrator said the town’s proportional cost of educating students at the Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School has increased 25 per cent over the previous two years, but is expected to be flat this year. The town’s proportional cost is based on the number of Oak Bluffs students at the school.

The proposed budget includes the addition of an assistant town treasurer, a position that went unfunded when the town ran into financial problems in 2009. It also includes a half-time position in the planning department, promotion of a patrolman to sergeant in the police department, an additional summer laborer in the highway department, and an additional summer laborer in the shellfish department.

Funds from increased building fees are earmarked to hire a full-time building inspector. The budget would also convert part time positions in the library to one new full time position.

Scheduled spending includes a 2.5 per cent cost of living adjustment for town employees.

Mr. Whritenour recommended $188,000 to pay for employee health care benefits, based on an estimate of a 10 per cent increase in health insurance costs.

Also Tuesday, selectmen voted to apply for another round of Community Development Block Grant funding, which provides home repairs and child care subsidies for income qualified residents. Oak Bluffs serves as the lead town for the grant, which also benefits Tisbury residents.

Program manager Melissa Vincent said the fiscal year 2014 grant helped eight households in Oak Bluffs and eight households in Tisbury with energy efficient repairs. A total of 52 children benefited from child care subsidies.

She said the fiscal year 2015 program is just getting underway with 16 more homes slated for repairs, and 52 children scheduled to receive child care subsidies.

Ms. Vincent encouraged home owners and renters to apply for grant funds through her office at The Resource Inc. in Vineyard Haven, or online at town websites. Households who earn 80 per cent of the average median income are eligible.

“Once you’re income qualified, we set up a home visit with a housing rehab specialist and myself,” Ms. Vincent said. “We have five contractors on the Vineyard that bid on our work.”

The grants, which average more than $30,000 per property, come in the form of a 15-year loan, which does not have to be paid back unless the owner sells the home.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/07/2016 - 08:53

Permalink

Kirk

What is the background story with the owners of this building? Are they allowing this building to become disgraceful because they have a grudge with the town government? This building looked bad ten years ago!

Farmer5 Chilmark

Who cares what the background story is? Haven't we seen enough weird and inexplicable evidence that this family has absolutely no regard for either the community or even their own assets. They have consistently over the course of decades let their properties deteriorate while blaming everyone but themselves. They have not kept any of their promises and will not take any action to mitigate the various shameful situations they've themselves have created without threat of legal action.
Oak Bluffs, Edgartown and Vineyard Haven selectmen and building officials should adopt a coordinated approach to combat their dysfunctional management of high-profile properties.
Just weeks ago we were entertained by Buzzy Hall's protestations of not having assets to pay a court-ordered fine. A few hours in jail was enough for him to remember where the $83,000 was.

Steve

It's been discussed with some acquaintances, we ponder if he has some form of hoarding thing. He could sell some property to up keep the others, but, he seems to be allergic to that idea. I'm glad an independent engineer is coming in, I see some details on that building that make me worry about it coming down (moss instead of mortar between the blocks of the buttresses, what state some of the rafters are in, etc.).

deshandra brown mv

Interesting observation. What I have seen with many large property owners is a reluctance to sell because they have some sort of delusion that if someone is actually willing to pay them for something, they are selling it too cheap (and since most landlords ARE cheap they want every dime in their pocket)-or the other excuse is that they will have to pay a large capital gain tax bill to the IRS.(which is avoidable with a 1031 exchange) I call it the 'real estate disease'. Its very common among landlords. However most would NEVER allow their assets to deteriorate, or sit un-occupied without a steady rent check coming in. That more than anything is puzzling, that they let these dumps that could produce income fall apart, like this theater or that yellow dump of a house on main st in Edgartown. I'm sure minimal maintenance would have allowed a substantial rent roll.

Anti Hall

Kirk, where have you been hiding? This family has been like this their entire lives now new generations of them are being produced.
My favorite picture of all of this nightmare story was Buzzy having handcuffs put on in he Edg court house.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/07/2016 - 10:33

Permalink

Don

If they tear it down I hope they keep the facade. At least then it will be the best looking T-Shirt shop on Circuit Ave.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/07/2016 - 11:05

Permalink

Vineyarder OB, NYC

The Halls have demonstrated they have no desire to further the development of Oak Bluffs or any town they have properties (e.g. Main St., Edgartown). While a wonderful building and example of old Oak Bluffs, demolition will be the only saving grace of this corner of Circuit Ave. as clearly they will never sell. Upon demolition, blame will lie squarely with the Halls.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/07/2016 - 11:51

Permalink

Sue O'Brien Oak Bluffs

Someone PLEASE do something....The building currently looks like a chicken coop.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/07/2016 - 12:40

Permalink

No Shame Edgartown

All the people on the island cant even shame them into compliance, and shunning them means nothing! Jail with No Bail for one year for the three of them then when they get released force them to live in that Theater until they totally fix it up or destroy it!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/07/2016 - 17:20

Permalink

coolmoeD OB

Does any one working on the building have a contractors license? Or workers comp ins?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/07/2016 - 18:13

Permalink

Skip OB

The Island is the 4th or 5th (specifically and originally designed and used) oldest movie theater in America. What a shame on all fronts.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.