The Islands have long felt ambivalent about summer visitors, happy for the dollars they bring to a highly seasonal market, less so about the attendant traffic and congestion.
Season Recap The Islands have long felt ambivalent about summer visitors, happy for the dollars they bring to a highly seasonal market, less so about the attendant traffic and congestion. After Labor Day come the familiar questions: Was it busier than ever, or did it just seem so? Have we turned another corner on the economy? Are we reaching a tipping point, when the things we love about the Vineyard are at imminent risk of being spoiled?
That these are perennial questions doesn’t make them less important.
The first question may be the easiest to answer, though even here the data is incomplete. The Steamship Authority, which accounts for the majority of people coming to the Island, reports that more than one million passengers were carried to and from the Island in the past three months, while 148,000 cars made the trip. That is about 28,000 more passengers and 4,200 more cars than during the summer of 2014. (The numbers include travel in both directions, which complicates any analysis.)
The five-year trends are also on the upswing, with the number of people and cars carried by ferries in the summer months increasing by an average of about 16,000 and 2,000 per year respectively. These are not insignificant numbers. No doubt the number of people who arrive here on commercial and private jets and other marine vessels has also been on the rise.
But at least on the ferries, traffic to and from the Island hasn’t yet reached the peak years of the late 1990s and early 2000s. Longer-term residents will remember 1998 as the year that Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket both called on the Steamship Authority to impose a one-year moratorium on expanding passenger service to the two Islands.
“Many feel we are losing what made this place so special by the number of people who are on this island,” Noel Berry, the Nantucket business owner who launched the successful effort, said at the time.
As the Steamship Authority prepares to rebuild its Woods Hole terminal, there are concerns not only from Island residents but from many on the mainland who worry about erosion of their own quality of life from the heavy traffic passing through.
Here on the Island, there is renewed sentiment that a conversation that lost momentum during the national recession needs to be rekindled. Serious concerns about traffic and the ability of the Island to deal with it surfaced in a survey released earlier this summer by the Martha’s Vineyard Commission. Noted author Geraldine Brooks put it this way in a comment on the Gazette website this week: “The traffic jams in West Tisbury on Saturday and Menemsha Harbor every night, the absolute crush at the Farmer’s Market and the circus on Menemsha beach at sunset — this is not the peaceful, bucolic place that has lured people and made us fall in love with the Vineyard.”
Her question, “Who else feels that this summer was a tipping point?” received scattered agreement online, but it deserves a larger forum and more discussion.
As we leave the summer behind, there will be time for that.

Comments
The real loss is the attitude
Bill VirginiaThe real loss is the attitude, the vibe. And the Islanders are as much to blame as the visitors - impatient vendors, honking Range Rovers and Jaguars, indifferent service, and worst of all, beach restrictions, guards,and the avaricious real estate agents, interested in just booking, rather than developing relationships! Time to reset, and remember the Vineyard of our collective childhoods, Everett Poole, David Flanders, Barbara Nevin, and the other generous souls who made the Vineyard comfortable and familiar for so many.
it's a resort community. it's
jeffrey mcnary edgartownit's a resort community. it's baffling to hear attempts to define it as something other. it's there to serve...so those there should serve well.
The Vineyard wasn't always a
Mari Coastal New EnglandThe Vineyard wasn't always a pricey "resort destination" alone. Once, not all that long ago, there was a year round economy that could adequately support a hardworking, self-sufficient yet collaborative community. When the economy shifted to a neo-feudal model, based on seasonal tourism and overpriced unreal estate, solely, many year rounders were forced to flee our homes in search of a stable income. Islanders are generally helpful people but you must admit that some folks just don't make good slaves who will infinitely give up everything we love about the place in order to better "serve" the demanding, snobby and spoiled rich.
Really?
Chris OBReally?
I agree that the Vineyard is
Chris OBI agree that the Vineyard is changing. There is a sense of losing people who come year after year, generation after generation to people who come for a short visit, who barely care about the island or its ways. With that I, as a seasonal resident, am also dismayed by the lack of respect shown to tourists (and seasonal residents who get treated a little better). Workers give poor service and a "thank god its August 31st" attitude all the time. They act as if you owe them money, as if there is no other game in town (there is). Maybe, if island residents would realize that without tourists and seasonal residents there would be no income and if tourists and seasonals would remember that the island has its own ways and that needs to be respected, everyone would be happy. No one is asking for slaves, the relationship should be mutual.
I have owned a second home
MarieI have owned a second home for years. I have witnessed the attitudes on both sides.
I don't go to Aquinah or Menemsha anymore. Been there and it is too much trouble to go,back. I only go to Vineyard Haven for the ferry. Our young visitors went into Edgartown one night and came home after dinner. There were long lines and waits to get into the bars. Everything is too crowded. There is not much to do anymore because everything is so crowded.
Do you even know how lucky
Mari Coastal New EnglandDo you even know how lucky you are to own a second home? I raised my 2 kids on the Island. Paid a mortgage, taxes, bills and more bills. Worked like a dog. 13 years of whinging crap from "gimmme what I want, now!" people like you. Disgusting and boring. Can't afford to even visit my son, a native, in the summer anymore. Margo Datz, the famous artist, once said to me, "Don't be like Mother Weasel. She allows her children to eat her flesh so that they may survive as she dies." So, you got all the honey and we got all the turds. You still want fast and cheap service as if you're at a McDonald's in Chicago, Boston or New York City? What the hell are you doing there, then? Tsk, tsk...
Add new comment