Dr. Michael Goldfein with one of his many patients, Ari Dagostino, age three and a half.
Ivy Ashe

Vineyard's First Pediatrician Hangs Up His Stethoscope

The Island’s first pediatrician has announced his retirement. Dr. Michael Goldfein of Vineyard Pediatrics, one of the few remaining private practices on the Vineyard, will retire on June 1 after 38 years on the Vineyard.

The Island’s first pediatrician has announced his retirement. Dr. Michael Goldfein of Vineyard Pediatrics, one of the few remaining private practices on the Vineyard, will retire on June 1 after 38 years on the Vineyard.

His practice will be taken over by the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital, which has hired Dr. Sonya Stevens, a Sudbury-based pediatrician, to take on his patients.

In a letter sent to patients and parents, Dr. Goldfein said he originally intended to continue on a part-time basis but could not reach an agreement with the hospital. But during an interview this week with the Gazette, the physician said, simply, it was time.

Beard before moustache, Dr. Goldfein in the early days, March 1980.
Alison Shaw
Beard before moustache, Dr. Goldfein in the early days, March 1980.
Alison Shaw

“I think I would rather end the practice while I’m still at the top of my game rather than when I’m starting to fail,” Dr. Goldfein, 75, said. More family time is also a priority. Dr. Goldfein’s children live off-Island, and he plans to spend more time visiting them.

Despite a career in medicine that spanned more than four decades, Dr. Goldfein did not always plan to be a physician. Raised in Brooklyn, Dr. Goldfein attended the City University of New York, and initially planned to be an astrophysicist. But after a difficult bout with advanced calculus he switched his major to biology and chemistry.

“I thought biologist or chemist, and that just kind of led to medicine,” he said. Dr. Goldfein attended medical school at the State University of New York’s Upstate Medical Center in Syracuse. After residencies at Case Western and Massachusetts General, he was drafted into the Army and worked as a pediatrician in Nuremburg, Germany, for three years.

After the Army, Dr. Goldfein returned to Boston, where he stayed busy with a part-time private practice and part-time employment at several area hospitals. While working in the pediatrics unit at McLean Hospital, a psychiatric hospital in Boston, he met Gretchen Jacobs, whose husband Michael was an internist on the Vineyard with the late Russell Hoxsie.

“They invited me to come down here and do some evaluations for some of the school children who were having a lot of problems in school,” Dr. Goldfein said. “So I started to come down on a periodic basis and started to do some work.” The general practitioners began to ask if Dr. Goldfein could meet with their young patients, too.

“It became very apparent to me that this was a population that could use some pediatric care,” he said. “My wife and I thought we would come down and try it out for a year or two, and here we are, 38 years later.”

Many doctors operate within a support network of fellow specialists, and can rely on collective knowledge to help make decisions in their practice. But that didn’t exist when Dr. Goldfein first arrived here. He was the first pediatrician the Island ever had.

“I think, frankly, my experience in the military, if it weren’t for that experience I don’t think I would have been able to do this,” he said. At the Nuremberg base, self-sufficiency was a must for pediatricians, he said.

“It forced me to become very self-reliant, and that ability really, I think, helped me do my work here pretty much on my own where I didn’t have other pediatricians to ask for help.” He stayed in touch with his Boston contacts, sending patients to the city if they had special concerns or needs.

It took time to build a practice from scratch. Many patients stayed with their general practitioners, and for a couple of years Dr. Goldfein split time working on the Vineyard and in Falmouth so he could make ends meet. But the early years had their own distinct appeal.

“It was very exciting for me, because I was uncovering a lot of issues, a lot of problems in the patients I was seeing, and I really felt like I was doing good work here,” he said. One patient came in who was four years old and yet hadn’t grown at all since he was 18 months. He was hypothyroid, but the problem hadn’t been recognized by other physicians. Dr. Goldfein prescribed treatment, and “We managed to start him growing again.”

Dr. Goldfein now helps the newest generation of physicians learn more about the needs of small-town communities. For more than 15 years, he has directed the Practice of Medicine in a Rural Environment course at Harvard Medical School, which brings students to the Vineyard to rotate through the hospital.

“It’s very rewarding,” he said. “The medical students at Harvard, their only exposure to medical care happens at the major medical centers. This is a very different exposure, and I think they benefit from that. The faculty benefit from having them here, and the patients benefit from having them here.”

Pediatrics is far different now from when Dr. Goldfein first started. In many ways, he said, it is unrecognizable. There are more regulations from both the government and insurance companies to keep up with. One of Dr. Goldfein’s nurses spends a whole day at the office just doing insurance referrals. And being in private practice is a challenge for any physician. Dr. Goldfein rents his office space from the hospital and covers his own health and malpractice insurance.

“It’s a financial hit, but at the same time there’s something about being my own boss that’s very appealing to me,” he said.

In many ways, though, the field has seen considerable improvement. Technological advances in imagining and better understanding of genetics make for better diagnostics. And one of the biggest advances has been in the decrease of vaccine-preventable illnesses. During his tenure, Dr. Goldfein has seen the disappearance of haemophilus influenzae meningitis in infants and young children. Though children can and do still get meningitis, that particular strain is all but eliminated. Only those who are not immunized get the illness, Dr. Goldfein said.

“In the past, before we had that vaccine, I would see at least a couple of children every winter with haemophilus influenzae meningitis, and now it’s gone,” he said.

Dr. Goldfein has about 2,500 active patients, a number he says is typical of pediatric practices. But perhaps not typical of pediatric practices is the sport of fencing, which over the years Dr. Goldfein has introduced to many children and parents on the Island. In college, Dr. Goldfein fenced competitively at the national level, but in order to attend medical school he had to turn down a spot on the U.S. national team in the Maccabiah Games, an international competition for Jewish athletes. Dr. Goldfein continued fencing while stationed in Germany, and on the Island he has for years held twice a week fencing classes at the high school.

“I’m not retiring from that,” he said.

“I think the most rewarding thing, or one of the most, is my being able to see a whole generation of Island children grow up and become parents in their own right,” he added. “And there’s a fair number of children in my practice now whose parents used to be patients of mine.” He has not yet seen grandchildren of former patients, though.

“Not yet,” he said. “I guess I won’t.”

But Dr. Goldfein will now have the chance to spend more time with his own grandchildren. There are seven.

“Soon to be eight,” he said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/05/2015 - 22:25

Permalink

June Manning Aquinnah

All the best to Dr. Michael Goldfein, whom I met when he consulted with a few patients at the office of Dr. David Rappaport. May he and Dr. Michael Jacobs continue to enjoy and celebrate their shared birthdays together. For several years, I enjoyed working in the social service deparment with his wife Donna Stevens-Goldfein. For two weeks, I had the utmost pleasure of working with Dr. Goldfein in his office for his vacationing secretary as we all worked in the doctors wing at Martha's Vineyard Hospital together for a long time. For nearly forty years that I have known Dr. Goldfein, he has always remained calm, with dignity and such a truly admirable bright spot in our daily lives while at work in the doctors wing. May he enjoy every moment of his retirement. Dr. Goldfein will be greatly missed by all who worked with him and his many patient.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/05/2015 - 22:39

Permalink

Ron Dagostino

We will miss you, Dr. Goldfein. With warmest regards and much gratitude, Ron, Sheryl, Eli, and Ari Dagostino

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/06/2015 - 05:30

Permalink

Bonnie E. Josephs Oak Bkuffs & woodstock, NY

What a lovely get to know all about someone, well written, interesting and informative article about what is: a lovely, sharing & caring human being ~ Dr. Goldfein.
Thank you for sharing.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/06/2015 - 06:22

Permalink

Rex Jarrell West Tisbury

Thanks for a respectful farewell to a gifted doctor who epitomizes professionalism and compassionate care.

Dr. Goldfein, we will miss you in the office and will know and love you forever as part of our family's experience of well-supported health and nurturing community.

Sincerely,
The Jarrells

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/06/2015 - 07:54

Permalink

Anna Cotton

We will miss you, never knew you were a fellow City College grad but makes sense as it's always a good sign!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/06/2015 - 09:31

Permalink

Geraldine Brooks West Tisbury

We've been so lucky to have Dr Goldfein, whose attention to the individual is matched by his advocacy on public health issues that affect all our kids, whether his patients or not. Personally I'm chagrined the hospital didn't come to terms with this treasure of a physician. But I'm glad he'll still be fencing…it's very reassuring for a mother when her son is sword-
fighting with a trained pediatrician.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/06/2015 - 18:46

Permalink

Patty French OB

Thank you for all your years of service. You will be missed. Thank you for taking care of this Islands children.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 03/08/2015 - 19:02

Permalink

Jesse Herman Albany,NY

Thank you for everything doc. You were very caring and professional. We will miss you.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/12/2015 - 10:06

Permalink

Michael Jacobs MD

It's been a privilege to work with you and serve the Vineyard community for 40 years- " you did real good, doc."

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 06/11/2015 - 15:59

Permalink

Rex Jarrell Raleigh, NC

I remember when we first met. You were on your first visit to the Island, and special needs programs were one of my areas of responsibility. I believe the new special needs law had just been instituted, and Gretchen Jacobs had recommended you as the pediatrician for our core evaluations. You were a very accomplished pediatrician then, as I know you are today, but what I saw most in you was your kindness and compassion for the children....such a warm and gentle manner. You have meant so much to our family, both professionally and personally. We will miss you as our pediatrician, but will continue to see you as our friend. Enjoy! Rex

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 07/02/2015 - 18:04

Permalink

Sanford werier Bklyn N.Y.

Ages ago when we were children we lived across the street from each other.We became friends and shared many experiences together.
We climbed MT Marcy the highest peak in new york state and Mt Katadin the highest peak in Maine, It was a time before rockets to the moon. Yet Michael built his own rocket ship having dreams of venturing to the moon or to the planet Mars
I am sure thatMichael was a great Pediatrician and will be missed.
I wish him the well on his retirement.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 11/18/2019 - 19:55

Permalink

Laurie Sexton Pelham, Massachusetts

Sad, this man saved my life! LITERALLY! But, I am happy that he will now be able to enjoy the beauty of life, well deserved!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.