Over the years people have asked in that incredulous voice, how are the winters out there? Isn’t it freezing? You get away for a few months, right?
I think I’m partially responsible for the winter population explosion here. And this is my formal apology. Over the years people have asked in that incredulous voice, how are the winters out there? Isn’t it freezing? You get away for a few months, right?
I’m afraid I have been honest and said it’s so gorgeous on the Vineyard during the off-season, you can’t even imagine. Because of the ocean, it’s actually milder than you’d expect. And there’s no traffic and no lines, and lots of things are still open and the community is so alive. You get the best of a small town and the best of a big city; you get support if you need it and privacy if you want it. There are concerts and plays and movies and, well, it’s kind of utopian.
I know its my fault because they all moved here. And now I can’t get a parking spot in front of Mansion House mid morning, mid winter.
I remember in the early 1970s (I know, I know I’m still a washashore), after Labor Day you didn’t see a car up-Island. And after January? Forget about it! The snow stayed white for weeks. And even though the stores were closed, it made me have to make do with what I had. Which I love doing. I love making do. Soup with whatever’s in the larder. Now all that’s changed. I just saunter down to the Chilmark store and get lunch off the food truck from my favorite chef (my son), give my tip to my favorite daughter in law and wait for the plethora of cars to pass so I can take a left back into my own driveway.
But I have learned a few things. Now I have new responses to those old questions. Because people still ask. They email me or they call. I’m sure after hearing about Clinton and Obama, and Carly and James, and Geraldine and Tony, and Brooke and the other Tony, and Bob Brustein and Peter Farrelly, and Harold Ramis and, and, and . . . they understandably just want to come out and be a part of the Island, too. Bring their kids, and move them into all the great schools I’m afraid I once told them about. Isn’t that exactly what I did?
If you were to eavesdrop now, however, you’d be so proud of me. They ask, how are the winters out there anyway? I say OMG you think Buffalo is bad? You can add two feet easy. My husband’s back is still sore from last year and he had to shovel us out this morning.
This morning? they ask. You had snow this morning?
Oh yeah, I say. They don’t even report it anymore. Phone lines are down. Internet, no way. Television? Once in a while we can get a little cable. That’s why there are so many babies born in October around here.
Jeez, they say, we were thinking of coming out and looking for a little something to buy.
Yeah, well, I say, you know who has some really good real estate bargains and their winters are much milder?
Where? they ask.
Nantucket, I say.
Nancy Slonim Aronie is the author of Writing from the Heart (Hyperion/Little Brown). She is a commentator for National Public Radio’s All Things Considered and founder of the Chilmark Writing Workshop.

Comments
I don't blame you, Nancy!
Sarah Wenig BostonI don't blame you, Nancy! However, if vacation rental mass marketed companies like Vacasa follow through on their plans to enter the MV market - I think there will be plenty of blame to go around. This is a firm that specializes in managing and renting out absentee owners' investment properties all year round - not homes belonging to real members of the community.
Some gloved and bundled
Donna Russell Braddock Bay, NY formerly Edgartown, MVSome gloved and bundled person may be grinning into the bitter morning wind today from the icy bow of the ferry to MV. She may have rented that vacant dwelling down the street, throwing evening light onto the dusting of snow from the last “storm”. During her stay, she may write some poetry, begin a novel, or finish a painting that exactly captures the Vineyard and its people. She may perfect a guitar etude or find a rare winter bird along the beach. She may bring a peaceful word to a troubled soul or add laughter at the local coffee shop. She may send an ironic and entertaining commentary to the Vineyard Gazette. She may look for real estate. Isolation has its comforts, and immigration carries risk. The biggest? Just who did we turn away?
Let's not be too hard on
Mr. B ChilmarkLet's not be too hard on absentee landowners. After all, they pay lots of property taxes and use comparatively few public services.
Everytime I see an article
Mike & Mari-Anne Delaware, OhioEverytime I see an article about MV or a President takes a vacation or HGTV gives away a house it makes me cringe. Pretty soon the whole world will know of our hidden gem. My wife and I never talk about our time on the Vineyard except to each other. Let's keep it on a "need to know" basis!
Cheers,
Mike
Thanks to "The Notebook" for
Ginny Durham, NCThanks to "The Notebook" for reminding me of carefree childhood days. And to Mike, sadly the word about magnificent Martha's Vineyard had been out for a good 15 years now and how I wish we could turn the clock back. Since we can not, I hope you can find a place to hide...
Personally as an artist I
Joseph Paul Uranker Oak BluffsPersonally as an artist I truly enjoy having patron visiting my studio and see me work and having a long and pleasant conversation. The summer is a constant flow of visitors and new patrons that see my eagles through out the Vineyard. I always amazing me how some can't wait until September and our summer guests leave and the island starts its slow process of slowing down. I remember back to 1990 when I moved to Vineyard from Pittsburgh, PA and how deserted the Island was, only a few restaurants where open year round and those had to do 2 for one specials, the Black Dog being one that did and they had great specials. Now we have them and Atria, Off Shore Ale, Henry's to name a few. If home owners want to come here and depress from the madness of America I think that great and I am sure the staff and people who work in the fine restaurants would agree.
Bravo for you and your
Donna Russell Braddock Bay, NY formerly from EdgartownBravo for you and your generosity of spirit ...and beautiful carvings. No surprise that visitors enjoy conversing with you....they feel welcome. I started coming to the island in 1958. Many of today's grumbling year-round residents were the interlopers of yesterday who populated the TRULY rural Martha's Vineyard I so well remember (when I, too, was an intruder). Perhaps the Wampanoag should add their voices to this discussion!
I wonder if the Mainlanders
Wash AshoreI wonder if the Mainlanders have similar thoughts about those Islanders that come there to shop and stock up on goods and services because they are more competitively priced.
I would love to come in the
Laura Dubek Mesa ArizonaI would love to come in the winter but the winters in Arizona cant be better anywhere ..... now if we only had a ocean.
Add new comment