<p>Using social media, a group of people are working to shed light on the Vineyard shuffle, the annual problem they say is afflicting the community even more severely this year.</p>
Lauri Bradway has been having nightmares. In nine days, she will become homeless, unless she finds housing she can afford for the summer season.
“There’s a lot of competition out there,” Ms. Bradway said. “There just isn’t enough housing.”
An Island resident for 27 years, Ms. Bradway is one of a group of people working to shed light on the Vineyard shuffle, the annual problem they say is afflicting the community even more severely this year.
Since the end of February, Ms. Bradway, a 57-year-old caregiver for the elderly and disabled, has been searching tirelessly for a rental. She’s scoured the newspapers, searched online sites, and posted many times on the Facebook page, MV Housing Rentals, all to little avail.
“I have looked at places on this Island that would make you cry,” she said at a meeting at the Oak Bluffs library on Saturday.
Some 20 people showed up at the meeting, eager to discuss the problem of housing scarcity.
There are 251 people on the waitlist for affordable housing at the Dukes County Regional Housing Authority. A list of displaced persons seeking housing that was posted on the MV Housing Rentals page had 28 entries Monday, including several families.
It was on Facebook that Ms. Bradway connected with Mellisa Zaccaria and Jayson Claypool, two Islanders who have been posting about their own desperate housing search.
Ms. Zaccaria and Mr. Claypool became homeless on April 25 after their landlord wanted to move his mother into their former apartment, terminating their lease.
Mr. Claypool, who owns a small technology solutions company, said he has two children in joint custody; a nine-year-old boy and a four-year-old girl.
“These are basic human rights — the right to have shelter, the right to feel stable,” he said before the forum began on Saturday.
Still, when Vineyarders hear his story, Mr. Claypool said they aren’t at all surprised. In a resort community where the cost of summer housing far exceeds the year-round price, twice-yearly moves from one house to another, or even a tent, are all too common.
“There’s this overwhelming apathy to the problem,” Mr. Claypool said. “People are falling back on that, it’s-the-way-it’s-always-been, so there is no sense in whining about it. My contention was, when there are children sleeping in cars, your point is invalid,” he added.
Ms. Zaccaria and Mr. Claypool slept in their car when they first became homeless. For now, they are crashing on a friend’s couch, but that situation is only temporary.
The couple has begun to document their struggles with film, and are calling the pseudo-documentary project The Shuffle.
Jeff Sullivan, who drives a taxi cab in the summer, said at the forum that housing has presented a constant hassle since he moved to the Island five years ago. “I am a classic example of the Island shuffle,” he said.
Jerimiah Miller said he and his wife and kids will be looking for housing July 1. “This is going on for us,” he said, visibly emotional. “We moved our family here for the community that we saw.”
“We have accepted the summer shuffle for really 30 years,” said David Vigneault, executive director of the regional housing authority. He said an improving economy has made year-round housing even more scarce.
“When the economy tanked in 2008, more year-round rentals became available,” he said.“Three years ago, there were still landlords.”
There is $53,000 available at the housing authority to assist year-rounders with their rent, but not enough landlords to provide affordable housing.
Some landlords are prejudiced against those receiving housing assistance; others have to charge too high a rent to make their mortgages.
Still others seem to assign extra privilege to tenants with strong Island ties over people who have recently arrived, Ms. Zaccaria said.
“There is an Islander-equals-community [mentality],” Ms. Zaccaria said. “If you are not an Islander in their eyes, then you are not part of the community.”
Mr. Vigneault said not to be cowed by that distinction. In reality, he said, no one votes you off the Island, alluding to the television reality show Survivor.
Unfortunately the majority of the people who vote are homeowners, he said, leaving few forums for the rental community to be heard. He suggested that the group take their cause to selectmen’s meetings to draw attention to the issue.
The group will host a public discussion on Wednesday, May 14. The location has not yet been determined, but updates will be posted at The Shuffle Documentary, a Facebook group.

Comments
Housing and feeling as though
Islander VHHousing and feeling as though you are part of your chosen community are not " basic human rights". You have a right to live in a place where your skills enable you to earn enough money to provide for yourself and your family. Not everyone has the ability to live in the community of their choice. If your work ethic or talents don't provide enough income to get by on the island then you must go elsewhere. It's taken me 20 years to even consider being able to afford a home here yet I never dreamed that somehow it was someone else's responsibility to help me make ends meet. The "everyone gets a trophy " generation must now confront the fact that life's not fair. If there's no housing where you're at then you have to go to where the housing is.
Spoken like a true elitist
Jeremy USASpoken like a true elitist jerk! I went to school with that man in this article.. Who the hell are you to tell him where he can and can't live... The trophy generation comment is stupid as well... We are Gen Xers who are left with the crumbs the baby boomer generation flushed right down the toilet...Affordable housing should be a basic human right everywhere. Articles like this are a sad reminder of a nation on a slow but steady decline...Oh and I signed my name...
Jeremy- How is this elitist?
Sally Shore Vineyard havenJeremy- How is this elitist? Please explain. I too am a "Gen X'er." I have no expectation that society will provide me with housing. This is my responsibility. I have been a renter on MV for 20 years and am now in the process of looking for a house to buy. Home ownership is hard work, not the government's responsibility. If you cannot afford to live in a particular community, then you need to go elsewhere. Stop blaming others.
"These are basic human rights
Benoit Baldwin West Tisbury"These are basic human rights, the right to have shelter, the right to feel stable, [Mr. Claypool] said." No. Shelter is a human need, not a human right. Shelter is the product of human labor, and you do not have a right to the product of any human's labor except your own. If the product of your labor in a particular market is not sufficient to trade for shelter adequate to you, find a market where it is. "There is an Islander-equals-community [mentality]," Ms. Zaccaria said. "If you are not an Islander in their eyes, then you are not part of the community." Welcome to Homo sapiens! So sorry whichever tribe raised you did not explain to you the rules. TL;DR: leave.
I have lived here for 23
Carole Vineyard HavenI have lived here for 23 years. I did the shuffle for many years and now live in the basement of a house year round. Pretty good deal for the past few years. I am close to 60 and will soon have to move as the family is selling the house. I love living here, and have many Islander and community connections, but the sad reality for me is that the availity and cost of year round housing will make it impossible to stay here. If you are sleeping in your car with your children, why are you here? This island owes no one a living. Some folks work 2 and 3 jobs for the priviledge of living here. There are less expensive places to live. The resort economy is a tough one, I know that first hand. Look how many people have moved off Island and commute back to work here. Interview the riders of the Patriot ferry. Many born and raised here, Islanders, faced with the increasing cost of living here have sold out and moved. Living on this Island, with low income is not for the feint of heart. Take your kids where your income can afford to house them.
"In reality, he said, no one
Lauri Bradway Vineyard Haven"In reality, he said, no one votes you off the Island, alluding to the television reality show Survivor." -- (said David Vigneault, executive director of the regional housing authority.) So why are the above comments slanted towards kicking off the island a really nice couple who have a business here (full time) and children here (part time) just because there is a lack of housing due to "There is $53,000 available at the housing authority to assist year-rounders with their rent, but not enough landlords to provide affordable housing." and "Some landlords are prejudiced against those receiving housing assistance; others have to charge too high a rent to make their mortgages." and "Still others seem to assign extra privilege to tenants with strong Island ties over people who have recently arrived." and who knows how many other reasons, including one of my own "Landlords are renting to College aged people in preference over mature long term Island people." Can anyone give me a really good reason why a couple who has been living here and calling this Island their "home" and has enough finances to pay a reasonable rent shouldn't feel they are entitled to housing here? Don't you feel the same way about yourself? Or do you ONLY feel that way about YOURSELF?
To the previous commenters:
JamieTo the previous commenters: Should our sales clerks, gasoline attendants, elder care providers, teaching assistants, and those who stock the supermarket shelves all leave because their skills and labor are not valued enough to pay exorbitant housing market prices?
I am a former supermarket
Benoit Baldwin West TisburyI am a former stocker of supermarket shelves, under both A&P and Stop & Shop. The washashore hippie socialists and their ilk, agitating against Stop & Stop's Vineyard Haven property redevelopment, have chosen to make "living" wages and "affordable" housing issues of concern. "Wages of ten bucks an hour, even working full-time, simply can’t sustain a decent life on Martha’s Vineyard."--Nis Kildegaard [Soundings: Stop and think, MV Times, Dec. 31, 2013]. "Part-time jobs at low wages are harmful and unprincipled."--John Abrams [Letters, MV Times, Apr. 23, 2014]. Lies. At the age of 20, I had a year-round, unsubsidized apartment in Vineyard Haven, on A&P part-time wages alone, when they were between $7-$8 an hour. And I had little trouble finding a year-round apartment at the same hourly wage/monthly rent ratio I had in 1995--six years ago, or three years ago. These apartments were advertised to everyone; no secret "Islander" handshakes, winks, nods, or blood oaths were required. If you are an adult of sound mind and able body, and are jobless or homeless on this island, then you are too lazy, or too stupid to be here. The island's seasonal resident/tourist economy is a goose that plops out fat golden eggs to anyone with the diligence and patience to adjust to her cycle. If Americans can't afford a visit to Martha's Vineyard this year, then it will be Canadians, or Indians, or Chinese, etcetera--but people will return, in the hundreds of thousands, every year, without fail. If you cannot make a decent living here--whatever "decent" means to you--then leave. I guarantee you there is someone willing and able to take your place and make a successful go of it, without complaint.
exactly,JAMIE, the lower
jessica my home of birthexactly,JAMIE, the lower paid employees , of gas stations, supermarkets, convenience stores, and so much more , retail people, farm workers, ect., by statements made above , should move off island as their wages do not support them living here.... ,due to the rental prices .... then may I ask, where will you shop for groceries as most here would be severely understaffed and empty.... or care for your elderly aunt so she can stay in her home?... all communities should be able to house their elderly and disabled, their lower income families... this I believe... not handouts....but a community with strong infrastructure , a diverse community, where there should be enough elderly housing (and disabled) , more lower income aupported housing for your lower income employees, some subsidized, some not...to me it is just common sense... or maybe we should just ship them to some other island, and let them figure it out... and some of you are cruel and insensitive...pointing fingers, being unkind ,,, it is sad...
"The right to housing is the
Lauri Bradway Vineyard Haven"The right to housing is the economic, social and cultural right to adequate housing and shelter. It is recognised in many national constitutions and in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights." and "Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights recognises the right to housing as part of the right to an adequate standard of living. It states that: “Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control." SOURCE: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_housing
Yes, of course. Argumentum ab
Benoit Baldwin West TisburyYes, of course. Argumentum ab auctoritate. Quote any authority you like who declares housing to be a human right. There is no one, anywhere, at any time, ever, who has made a convincing argument that it is.
Laurie- if you want to have
Sally Shore vineyard havenLaurie- if you want to have any credibility, do not cite Wikipedia as a source.
And what about my friends,
JamieAnd what about my friends, have lived here for more than 20 years and can pay up to $2,400/month and still have no place to rent? It would seem that they have the skills and income to make it here. It's not only "poor folks" that can be excluded from the joys of island living.
At 57 and having lived on the
John Gault Oak BluffsAt 57 and having lived on the Vineyard for 27 one would have saved enough money to purchase a home if you wanted to live here permanently.I would think that it's time for tax to support all the 251 people on the waitlist for affordable housing at the Dukes County Regional Housing Authority - What do you say let's tax everyone to support these poor souls?
Do the math! My income is
Lauri Bradway Vineyard HavenDo the math! My income is more in the summer, yet considerably less in the winter, most years during the winter I have been on Unemployment income of $110./week! In the winter, I might get a rental for $700./month, yet the heat last winter was $200./month for electric and $200./month for Propane to heat only 2 rooms! Total monthly expenses for everything (all bills and expenses): about $1,500./month. I barely scraped by! One person cannot "afford a home" on Martha's Vineyard unless they have a steady job and low rent and bills....and a huge bank loan (good credit). It's just not feasible for me. I make less than $10,000. a year! No one is saying to Tax everyone to support the homeless, let's find other solutions!
Mr. Claypool's dilemma while
gina nyc/menemshaMr. Claypool's dilemma while frustrating, is not unique to many areas of the US.. It's a fact of life if one cannot afford to live in a certain place , you must move to an area more conducive to your level of income..
It is definitely not a Selectman issue in my opinion..
I would like to know why if a
Sara Oak BluffsI would like to know why if a family can afford $2400 a month in rent one would not purchase a home. I am a single parent who has just purchased a home. It wasn't easy but I have received tremendous support from local banks on this island and working all 3 jobs for years has paid off. I understand the housing issue as it's a problem off island as well. Time to explore other options people......rally..find private donors, work with the landbank, the only solution will come from the community.
Sara, not everyone wants to
ShellySara, not everyone wants to be a homeowner. Some people want or need to remain more flexible.
Yes, for some of us it's a
Liz Toomey West TisburyYes, for some of us it's a matter of affordability. There is a huge gap between wages and housing affordability. But for many others, it's a lack of rental housing not money that is the issue.
One big problem is the amount
William Oak BluffsOne big problem is the amount of property not being used. There is a famous writer who built a house in OB. Then he purchased the two affordable rental houses next to him. They have been empty for more than 7 years now.....thats sad.
why is it sad? it was his
mike swhy is it sad? it was his money, he earned it he can spend it anyway he wants, and besides hes dead now so im hoping his wife will tear them all down and build a super mansion just to hear you complain more
Keep in mind, these are the
Island Community West TisburyKeep in mind, these are the people who wire your town halls, help establish clinics, staff your Red Cross, teach in your schools, staff your banks, work in your grocery stores. Where's the community spirit? What I'm hearing is not consistent with the friends, family, and many town officials Island-wide - all homeowners who pay taxes and live here full time - are saying.
I agree housing is not a
no name Oak BluffsI agree housing is not a right. It is a need. The real shame is all the property not being used. There is a famous writer who built a house in OB. Then he bought the two affordable rental houses next door and they have remained empty for quite a few years.
Does the island want a
Karin EdgartownDoes the island want a sustainable year-round community into the foreseeable future? Yes, the “shuffle” has a long history on the island, but that’s not evidence that it’s either good for the island or sustainable in the longer term. Renters who shuffle between towns are not permanent town residents of any town and thus not able to fully serve any town community by volunteering their time on town committees, etc., and large amounts of time and energy that could further contribute to the island community is taken up by the search for housing and repeated household moves. The island would be well-served to keep on bright, energetic folks with leadership skills, like the ones discussed in the article - through greater housing security.
we live in a house with the
Mr. B Vineyard Havenwe live in a house with the rent hovering $2000 and our monthly utilities are around $600 plus all of our other bills. we have two incomes. We scrape by every month. we have absolutely nothing left over to even consider saving to buy a house. We do not even qualify to buy a house with the prices here so we never will. If we loose the house we are in now we will have to move off island, probably move to Chatham. I feel for all the folks looking for a home but we live on a resort and the island is only so big. We could build a bunch of housing so everyone looking has a home BUT many more people will move to the island with the same issues and we will be back where we started from, then what? build more housing? after a couple years of this the atmosphere that we all strive to live here in the grand island of Martha's Vineyard will be gone. We all live and work here because it reminds us of when we were young and there was no crime, and community was very important, just as it is here, however if we drop rental prices and allow many more to move here all that will disappear. We need to seek out the other islands in the area and see what that have done to ease the housing issues. If you build a house here and only live in it for 6 weeks you should have to rent it out the rest of the year or if you build a big house here, you must also build a carriage house to house islanders. maybe those you employ to clean or cut the grass of the house. we need ideas here not just complaints. Look forward to reading ideas here. I send all my best to everyone in this housing crunch.
Just to clarify for those who
Jayson ClaypoolJust to clarify for those who are mistakenly thinking that the issue at hand is affordability. That is definitely a component of the problem, but it's not the immediate concern.
The issue for myself and many other folks right now is a straight up lack of housing available for rent. There's no sense in counting vacation rentals as part of the equation or solution to housing (at $1500-$10,000 per week), it's an obvious impossibility for middle income workers and even small business owners like myself.
There hasn't been a good
islander VHThere hasn't been a good inventory of year round rentals on the island in decades and that's not likely to change. You either adapt or move to where there is sufficient inventory.
Actually, that is not
Liz Toomey West TisburyActually, that is not accurate. For the past several years, due to the economic downturn, there have been rentals available. The statistics collected by DCRHA attest to that. 29 years here and I've never known it to be as bad as this.
Its a luxury to live in the
deshandra brown obIts a luxury to live in the town where you work and its not a 'right'. It's also NOT the responsibility of the taxpayers to subsidize below market housing for the employees of businesses. In the 'real world' people commute, sometimes 2+ hours each way to work. If the ferry service to New Bedford was expanded to make it easier for commuters, then that would solve any labor shortage. The wages for unskilled labor are high enough here to attract commuters. Just see all the construction workers arriving on the boat every day. You won't find sympathy from those who worked hard, saved their money,and bought a home here.(and while we were working 2 or 3 jobs, we didn't have a new SUV, boat, or eat dinner at expensive restaurants)
No one has any sort of divine
The Lorax Oak BluffsNo one has any sort of divine right to live on the island. It's still beautiful in part because not everyone can live there. Building more housing is like building more highways, increased capacity always leads to increased demand.
What does it say about the
ShellyWhat does it say about the people in a community who want all the benefits and amenities that low wage jobs bring, but don't want to support the people who fill those jobs? Low and moderate wage workers are the least able to afford transportation costs that include cars and ferry rides. It's not cheap to commute to the Vineyard. Sadly, there will always be people who need a job badly enough that they will take the jobs and scrape by, always on the fringe. But this doesn't let people who are unwilling to be more gracious and creative in finding better solutions off the hook.
Add new comment