It was a unanimous vote by the Martha's Vineyard Commission to create a manual to preserve the Island roadscapes.
From the tree canopies over North Road to the bike lanes along Beach Road, a project to preserve rural Vineyard roadscapes took a step forward last week.
The Martha’s Vineyard Commission voted unanimously at their Feb. 20 meeting to create a manual to preserve and protect the Island’s roads.
The project is the brainchild of Craig Whitaker, an architect who approached the commission about taking measures to preserve Vineyard roads. He has worked with the commission’s planning and economic development committee to bring the idea to the larger group.
Mr. Whitaker has long been an admirer of the Vineyard’s rural roads, he told the commission. A longtime seasonal resident, his interest in Vineyard roads dates back his first visit to the Island when he saw moonlight come through the tree canopy on North Road.
“Anyplace that can do what had happened on North Road was worth getting very serious about,” he said.
From that memorable moment, Mr. Whitaker recalled a more jarring recent sight: driving on Beach Road toward Oak Bluffs, he thought there was an accident up ahead. Instead, he said, he was looking at “Fourteen separate reflector signs over the two bridges.”
North Road and the bike paths on Beach Road drew Mr. Whitaker’s praise, while he said places like the Tashmoo Overlook could be improved. Using a modest grant, Mr. Whitaker started to look into how the Vineyard could take control of its roads.
Those plans now call for creating a rural roads manual, which would set guidelines for everything from utility poles to signage.
The first step, commission executive director Mark London told the Gazette, is to have commission members and staffers meet with town planning boards to solicit feedback.
Mr. London said the aim is to create a working group with representatives from each town and anyone else who is interested.
“It’s going to be an ongoing effort,” he said, including negotiating with the power company NStar about utility poles, dealing with upcoming projects and narrowing down priorities.
A starting point will be gathering a library of manuals from communities that have already worked on similar projects. Mr. Whitaker pointed to the National Parks, the San Juan islands in Washington State and Nantucket as examples of communities that have accomplished similar goals.
“The first step for this kind of work is getting a good understanding of existing situations,” Mr. London said. “One option we’re looking at is possibly getting an intern this summer to get a better inventory of existing roads — how wide are they, how wide are the shoulders, how far back is the vegetation.”
The committee could explore the cost of putting electric wires underground, he said, an option that surfaced recently with concerns about new and larger NStar poles on the Island.
Mr. Whitaker estimated the cost of the roads project at $150,000. Mr. London said the ultimate price tag will be determined by what the commission decides to do. While the commission doesn’t have $150,000 to spend on the project, he said, they could look at grants.
Mr. Whitaker said he thinks the next step should be to get professional help to accomplish the work.
Commissioners were largely supportive of the project, and voted unanimously to pursue it. Some had concerns about the process.
“My concern is we do an awful lot of talking and meeting with people,” Aquinnah commissioner Kathy Newman said, suggesting that the commission get the project underway and come up with examples before going to the towns.
“It’s worth doing but it’s hard,” Chilmark commissioner Joan Malkin said.
Mr. Whitaker said he was heartened by the outcome. “The underpinning of it all is this would offer the Vineyard the chance to take charge of its own roadscape,” he said, adding that he hoped the project wouldn’t be buried under too many meetings.
He said he’s heard positive feedback about his presentation, and that the project is necessary to maintain Vineyard character.
“Many of those roads are the first thing people see,” he said. “They really are our front door.”

Comments
Sounds like a futile effort
Xerxes EdgartownSounds like a futile effort if they expect to have positive co-operation from NStar.
It's roughly $1 million per
Ken Esq EdgartownIt's roughly $1 million per mile to put utility wires underground. I'm sure if the citizens of the Island were willing to pay for it then NStar would do it. I don't know how many miles the total would be, but just thinking Barnes, State, Vineyard Haven and West Tisbury roads would probably be well over $30 million for starter and require a whole lot of digging, displacing/removing trees, etc.
I do like the idea of a manual although it would have to be law with penalties for non-compliance to really have any effect.
I'd also like the manual to cover property that are easily within view of the road. It makes no sense to spend millions to bury a utility line to have a property behind it that looks like a junk yard. We have a lot of residents and businesses here that take no pride in their property or the Island. Just starting with cleaning up the litter would be an improvement.
The $1.0MM cost per mile --
skip OBThe $1.0MM cost per mile -- presuming that to be an actual cost and not a PR number -- is a balance sheet item; capitalized improvement that becomes an asset of the private company, thereby increasing it's value. It is also treated as a cost that is amortized via tax deductions over several years and/or is essentially depreciated away. The usefulness (besides a reduction in taxation) comes when/if the company is sold and that asset is added to the value so shareholders reap more money from the sale. Agreeing about certain properties, beauty is only skin deep -- and those NStar poles are ugly to the bone.
MV Commission strikes again
Ver Vineyard HavenMV Commission strikes again to limit and strict!
I think this is a wonderful
SteveF Chilmark & CambridgeI think this is a wonderful effort. I am wondering if this will include encouraging more brush to be cleared to allow for more views of the water from our roads. it wasn't so long ago that South Road provided many ocean vistas from West Tisbury, all the way out to Aquinnah.
Wouldn't it be nice if we
Gail A. EdgartownWouldn't it be nice if we could see bits and pieces of the ocean that surrounds us when we drive that route.
There have never been any
S.A.M. ChilmarkThere have never been any "ocean vistas" off South Rd in West Tisbury. The first stretch of visible ocean you can see from South Rd is just East of Abel's Hill. Also, South Rd ends at Beetlebung Corner, which is a good four miles from the Aquinnah town line.
The Vineyard Open Land
Skip OBThe Vineyard Open Land Foundation's 'Looking at the Vineyard' from 1970 and it's Byways Study of 1976 remain valuable tools--even 40 years later. Hope Mr. Whitaker will check them out as part of his ever so worthwhile project,
Just remember YOU PAY FOR ALL
J. Baker MaineJust remember YOU PAY FOR ALL PIPE,LABOR,WIRE,for ALL utilities going to your house !
ALSO if the wires fail,YOU pay to fix it and YOU have to find someone to fix it !
N_STAR does NOT fix underground for free YOU PAY IT !
Also like someone said you can kiss ALL TREES good buy !
Here's an easy experiment:
Richard Vineyard HavenHere's an easy experiment:(first make sure your will is in order)-- get on your bike (or rent a bike), and do this simple route: from the ferry terminal grab a sandwich at the Scottish Bakehouse, and put it in your backpack with your beach towel and then head to Eastville Beach on the left after the drawbridge. After you have done that, see what your opinion is on changing the roads a bit to allow a more relaxing commute on your day off...or on your vacation...
Sounds nice, but Mr. London
Dean Rosenthal EdgartownSounds nice, but Mr. London needs to look beyond free labor in his suggestion of acquiring an intern. Not only is the use of interns becoming more and more an excuse for those who just want help for free, thus taking advantage of Island interest that could instead use real income, but the old adage 'you get what you pay for' almost always proves true. I support the process, however.
Add new comment