Tisbury's properties valuations jumped by 35.2 per cent in 2022.
Ray Ewing

Property Values Soar in Tisbury, as Median Home Price Approaches $1 Million

Pandemic-era home sales in Tisbury have pushed property values up by 35.2 per cent, signaling a lower tax rate for the year to come.</p>

Pandemic-era home sales in Tisbury have pushed property values up by 35.2 per cent, signaling a lower tax rate for the year to come.

“The overall assessed value for fiscal year 2023 is $4,621,978,338,” said assistant assessor Ann Marie Cywinski, as the town select board opened its annual public hearing on tax rate classifications Wednesday night.

While the white-hot real estate market of 2020 and 2021 may have cooled somewhat, Ms. Cywinski said she doesn’t see values declining significantly next year.

“We really haven’t seen, this year, much of a difference in prices or listings that are going to warrant an adjustment to go down for 2024,” she said.

The median home value is now $988,400 in Tisbury, where more than 90 per cent of all property is classified as residential, treasurer/collector Jon Snyder told the board.

The new valuation isn’t official until the state has certified it, a process that is taking extra time because the jump up from last year’s $3.4 billion assessed value has triggered extra scrutiny, Mr. Snyder said.

“That 35 per cent increase in values is way outside the norm for property in communities in Massachusetts, so the department of revenue has been analyzing in great detail and causing Ann Marie to have to do a great deal of legwork, more than most years,” Mr. Snyder said.

Mr. Snyder said he expected certification as soon as Friday.

The select board continued the public hearing to Dec. 14 at 3:30 p.m., when they are expected to hold two votes on how the new $31,105,441 tax levy will be assessed.

State law allows towns to shift some of the residential tax burden to commercial property, which accounts for so little of Tisbury’s total that the board has voted not to do so for much of the past decade.

The second vote will determine the residential exemption, currently 18 per cent, for Tisbury property owners living in their homes year-round.

Town officials have suggested raising the exemption to 21 or 22 per cent, to help offset the impact of $26 million in additional borrowing for school construction approved at a special town meeting earlier this year.

Out of 2,933 residential properties in Tisbury, Mr. Snyder said, 1,100 are subject to the residential exemption.

Ms. Cywinski said the number of exempt properties grew by 50 in 2022, and that she has recently sent more than 20 additional applications to owners who may be eligible.

In other business Wednesday, the select board reappointed Greg Martino as its representative to the Martha’s Vineyard Commission and approved police chief Christopher Habekost’s request to appoint police administrator Samantha Gitschier as a traffic officer so that she can fill in as needed.

“She’s doing a great job in her present position. This would be above and beyond that,” Chief Habekost said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/09/2022 - 13:23

Permalink

Donbob Malibu

Lower tax rate... That's funny

Pandemic-era home sales in Tisbury have pushed property values up by 35.2 per cent, signaling a lower tax rate for the year to come.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/09/2022 - 16:40

Permalink

Gary Tisbury

A lower tax rate does not mean a lower tax bill. The "rate" is the number used to to multiply against your property value to find the amount one will pay. So if your property is worth 35% more, they can reduce the rate by 35% and you will still be paying the same amount. I don't think taxes are going down.

Bob Edgartown

The best way to lower tax rates is to participate in town government and vote at town meetings. Often times the correct vote is no when it comes to spending. What we do at town meetings determines the upcoming tax rate. That’s where it all starts.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/09/2022 - 17:31

Permalink

Helpful Persom MV

It is dead accurate reporting. The tax levy is already determined before values are set. This is a simple division problem. Tax rate is the tax levy divided by total value of all taxable properties. Tisbury taxpayers don’t pay more because values went up. The tax rate falls in lockstep. Hope this clarifies things. California may be different.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/09/2022 - 23:28

Permalink

Appraiser of Smoked Mirrors Anywhere yet Everywhere

As an appraiser of smoke and mirrors, my specialty, I am delighted to be called upon for my expert opinion. I can state with absolute certainty that this is not a genuine mirror clouded by smoke. It is math nearly everyone here uses every day and doesn’t even think about. It is measure twice cut once. The town meets and decides what to spend. The accountant estimates what will come in before property taxes are required. What is left are the property taxes. The assessor figures out what all the property is worth so they know how to portion out those taxes. The total amount collected by the tax collector is the same no matter what the assessor decides about values. Nobody said taxes are going down. The reported said the tax rate is going down. The reporter is correct. The taxes OVERALL are going up by what town meeting decided to spend less what is expected to come in from other sources. It is easy to try to sell a smoke and glass mirror. But I am not buying this as a genuine smoke and glass mirror job. It is much more boring and common these days. The truth and a bit of third grade math.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 12/10/2022 - 07:30

Permalink

Eric Tisbury

Tisbury has one of the lowest exemption property tax rates of the towns in Massachusetts who offer it. The rate can be increased to 35% yes that is correct 35% which would be another way to have the LLC's that are buying up housing stock to pay a higher share of the property tax of our town, the higher the exemption for year rounders the more tax being paid by non-excempt properties. I see that as a win win. Please read the rates supplied by the state on exsisting excemption rates my question is why can't Tisbury lead the way in using this valuable tool.

The following is a list of some municipalities with the residential exemption.
Provincetown 25%
Boston 35%
Malden 30%
Nantucket 25%
Tisbury. 18%

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 12/10/2022 - 12:50

Permalink

Charlie callahan So Boston edgartown

The tax rates are actually pretty low on the vineyard, compared to the rest of the state,so stop whining

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.