The Katharine Cornell Theatre atop Tisbury Town Hall on Spring street remains the daily work space of two finance office workers who were relocated in 2020 to allow for Covid-19 distancing downstairs.
While nearly all of the Vineyard’s performance venues have reopened to the public, the Katharine Cornell Theatre atop Tisbury Town Hall on Spring street remains the daily work space of two finance office workers who were relocated in 2020 to allow for Covid-19 distancing downstairs.
The bequest from Ms. Cornell’s estate that paid to renovate the hall, and commission its soaring Stan Murphy murals, does not preclude using it as office space, town administrator Jay Grande said, but the town’s intention is to preserve it as an auditorium.
“I respect the tradition of using it as a theatre,” Mr. Grande said. “There’s not going to be any permanent office space established.”
But space issues remain, Mr. Grande said, and at present there isn’t enough room on the main floor of the converted 1844 church to fit all town employees, even now that distancing is no longer required.
“We have less than 2,700 square feet of usable space,” he said, adding that his own, unheated office is nowhere near the workspaces of his assistant, Elena DeFoe and human resources coordinator Pam Bennett.
“I don’t even have my two key people in proximity,” Mr. Grande said.
And town hall is getting more crowded as Tisbury grows.
“We need space for an additional employee we are recruiting and hiring,” Mr. Grande said.
To make more room — and consolidate both the finance department and administrative staff — he plans to move the two isolated finance workers currently located on the auditorium level back downstairs and use a smaller portion of the auditorium for his, Ms. DeFoe’s and Ms. Bennett’s workspaces.
The rest of the theatre space — known as Association Hall until the 1970s, when it was renamed in memory of the stage actress and seasonal Tisbury resident Katharine Cornell — would host select board meetings and, if possible, public events as well, Mr. Grande said.
“If we have [a way] to secure our space, then others could use it for small venues or recitals,” he added.
“The center of the theatre and the two front wings where the piano is located and the stage and the elevators will all be accessible,” Mr. Grande said. “It’s less than ideal, but we’re trying to figure out how to get it open.”
Details are still being worked out and some elements could change, he said, but the transition should be completed by March, when the state’s remote meeting option for municipal governments is due to expire.
“We’re going to take it slowly and see how it looks and, frankly, if it doesn’t work, if it’s too intrusive, we’ll regroup and acknowledge,” Mr. Grande said.
Using the auditorium for offices will buy Tisbury some time to properly plan for a renovated or new town hall, Mr. Grande added, although that prospect remains far in the future given the $81 million school project now underway, he said.
“A few years to do the planning is certainly worthwhile,” he said.
In the meantime, Mr. Grande said, he’s issued strict instructions for the theatre’s interim use.
“I made it quite clear that nothing permanent should be affixed to the floor or the ceiling or anywhere... I want to make sure the murals can be viewed [by the public] to the maximum extent possible,” he said.
“The goal is not to occupy the space in perpetuity.”

Comments
The citizens of VH and the
Jeff Walker VHThe citizens of VH and the island need to keep a close eye on the accessibility and functionality of this space as a theatre and venue. The town is overstepping greatly by burdening this space with their presence. This has always been a public venue for the people and not just to be co-opted by the town employees because they feel entitled to using a theater as their personal office.
Well said Jeff Walker
Wolly AQWell said Jeff Walker
Agreed!
Sam EDGAgreed!
Well said. The Art that Stan
Tom Engley West TisburyWell said. The Art that Stan Murphy painted is being wasted many people have never seen the murals. Tisbury needs a new town hall. But the tax payers are already getting whacked by the new school project. We need a story on how the kids are doing in those trailers. Please and Thank You.
As someone who stage-managed
Susanna J. Sturgis West TisburyAs someone who stage-managed and/or acted in and/or assisted with quite a few theater productions back in the heyday of Island Theatre Workshop, I am glad someone is paying attention to this. Over the years I've also attended many concerts, forums, and other programs at "KC". The island is suffering from a lack of accessible (financially and physically) public performance spaces, especially those where admission can be charged or donations accepted.
Such a great venue, for music
Bob EdgartownSuch a great venue, for music and theater and have seen many great performances in there. It is a shame that it is not used more often.
The iconic Stan Murphy murals
Constance Ellis Chilmark and New York CityThe iconic Stan Murphy murals are a Vineyard treasure and need a curator and a safe space.
How about transfer of them to the MV Museum, to be preserved in a temperature-controlled
environment and to be seen by all visitors.
I was lucky enough to get to
Jesse Dennerlein Clearwater, FLI was lucky enough to get to play the piano in that theater a few years ago. The sound was incredible. I fell in love with that piano immediately.
It is sad to see the
Frank Brunelle TisburyIt is sad to see the magnificent hall devoted to the arts used as office space. It is understandable that people need to be able to function somewhere. However, like any company or organization there is always the option of renting space and allocating that rented space as a way to bring back employees. It employees could work from home then it seems logical that a rented space could work also. There are in fact, some empty store fronts on Main Street for example a short walk to Town Hall. That is one possibility. I am sure that there are others. But please, this really is not proper.
It really is a shame that no
Bob EdgartownIt really is a shame that no one can have a lasting memory and bequest. As years pass, everyone seems to be forgetful. The island loves to hang onto the past, but only when it helps the present.
WAIT...WHAT! Katherine
Terry HinghamWAIT...WHAT! Katherine Cornell would be rolling over in her grave to see this beautiful theater taken away from the public and absorbed by bureaucrats (no disrespect) And town gov't, in one of the richest most expensive towns on EARTH and can't afford office space to run town government? Is this waht you folks are saying! Really...this is incredulous...so creativity with the boomers just comes when their lining their own pockets with more cash and objects? Pathetic!!! Put an assessment on every home in the town that has a market value of $3M+ and you'll have the funds to run town gov't in office space in a NY minute!
Add new comment