As I listen to the morning news reporting the upcoming milestone of 500,000 dead in the U.S. from Covid-19, I think of my mother.
As I listen to the morning news reporting the upcoming milestone of 500,000 dead in the U.S. from Covid-19, I think of my mother. She along with undoubtedly many more souls has not been included in this statistic. I am not comforted by this oversight.
As a child of the depression and a housewife and mother in the 1950s and early 1960s pre-women’s movement, she was possibly used to being part of the great uncounted, unlike my privileged generation, enlightened by the writings of Betty Freidan and others.
The credit for most of my parents’ many accomplishments were given mostly to my father. My mother was used to being overlooked as were so many women of her generation. It was their lot in life. I don’t know for sure if it bothered them but think it certainly must have. I do know that when I asked my mother what she wanted in her later years when life decisions needed to be made it always seemed like a foreign concept to her.
Even so this feels to me like the final insult.
In the final few days and hours of my mother’s life, she refused to get out of bed. Refused is an overused word in hospitals. “Patient Refuses”. Being a nurse, I am more than familiar with the term sometimes used to mean nursing staff are too busy to bother with a reticent elderly patient. Maybe this was the case with Covid-related staff shortages. We will never know.
On Monday I contacted the director of the rehab facility in Florida where Mom was a patient post hip fracture. She would look into why my mother was left in bed all weekend.
Before she could return my call, I had a phone call from the nurse in charge on my mother’s unit saying my mother was short of breath and had had a dry cough all weekend. During her one-week stay I had received four emails telling me caregivers had tested positive for Covid-19 at the facility. Bars and restaurants and gyms were open in Florida. People were militantly opposed to wearing masks. The virus was spreading mostly unabated.
Earlier in the week we tried to send my mother flowers as a reminder that we loved her and were thinking of her. No. Flowers were turned away at the door. They cannot be sterilized we were told. Seriously I think? Isn’t anyone there familiar with the spread of a respiratory virus?
I had a friend beg for pictures of family to be brought from her apartment to her bedside. We FaceTimed her on the iPad my son and his wife had thoughtfully sent to her. At first we were hopeful. The hip fracture was a crack and she was feeling better and getting up and about. She would be able to go home. Maybe finally we would be able to convince my still independent mother now in her 90s to move here to the Vineyard to be closer to family.
And then the phone calls came. My mother died alone in a rehabilitation hospital in Florida. Family was not at the bedside. No one held her dying hand as she struggled with her final breath.
A few weeks later I received the death certificate. Cause of death: Old age. No mention of Covid. No test done. The facility retained a clean record for Covid-related deaths.
My mother was uncounted.
Sue Carroll lives in Edgartown.

Comments
This is heartbreaking. I
Dimitra Arneson Naples FloridaThis is heartbreaking. I knew your mom as she raised 4 wonderful daughters, was a wonderful cook, and could host a dinner party worthy of royalty. She made sure you and your sisters had everything you needed before your dad was a financial success. My heart goes out to you and your family for this tragedy. The saving grace is that your son named his first born child after her, ensuring that her legacy will live on.
Sue that is so terrible!
Susie M West TisburySue that is so terrible! Makes me so mad at that rehab! I had no idea this had happened. I am glad you have written about it. I know how good you were to your mom, and am so very sorry about this.
In the end, we’re going to
Chip Coblyn OBIn the end, we’re going to judge ourselves not by how we defeated Covid-19, but by how we reacted to the suffering of those who died. With masses of Americans refusing to behave like Covid is even real, we’re failing miserably in the empathy test.
It broke my heart and made me
Lynnea Brodeur N Palm Beach, FLIt broke my heart and made me angry when the state and county made the ruling that those in rehab and long term care facilities could not receive any visitors. I know my dad would have not understood why his daughters were not coming daily as they usually did. The depression, loss of the will to live, that ensues due to this isolation I am sure led to many deaths at these facilities. My heart goes out to you.
As a fellow nurse, I find
Liisa Berger NC, formerly Vineyard HavenAs a fellow nurse, I find this appalling! I know this will haunt you and anger you for the rest of your days but I hope you will keep your great memories of your mom close to your heart and know that she knew how much you all loved her.
I am so sorry for your pain
June West Palm BeachI am so sorry for your pain at your loss. I know there are no words that could help you right now. Florida has been very scary throughout this whole pandemic. I am watching people walk around without masks, sneezing into the air, hanging out in bars and nightclubs and that is just the beginning of the state of affairs in Florida. Once again I am so sorry for your loss.
I'll never forget your mom
Steve Ewing EdgartownI'll never forget your mom Sue. Bob may have been out running hotels and restaurants but Lucille and all our other mom's were busy trying to keep us fed, clothed and probably alive. Edgartown in the fifties and the sixties was a different place. A lot of local families lived downtown. Lucille was one of the last of our generation's downtown mothers. It didn't matter how far us kids would roam there was no hiding from their seeming cabal. Each one had absolute authority to dispense immediate justice as if we were one of their own kids. I will always remember Lucille's big broad smile. Like my mom JoAnn always giving comes to mind when I think back on Mrs. Carroll. Sue, your mom might not have gotten counted in the Covid ledger and it must have been hard not to be there to hold her hand but you know she sure counted to you, your sisters and all us kids growing up in Edgartown. She sure counts in my book.
Well said Steve, but of
Edward Pachico MDWell said Steve, but of course I would have not expected anything less from Edgartown Poet Laureate :)). Sue, your description of the last few months of your Mother’s life are both personal and helpful for those of us that may be facing similar challenges in the future. Thanks to you both.
Thanks for your kind words
Sue Carroll EdgartownThanks for your kind words and for sharing your memories Steve. Both of our mothers were doers and givers. As kids we used to think too much so when that pan of brownies or that nice cake were for the church and not us! Times have changed for certain. I feel so fortunate to have been part of that time and place. Such good memories.
Praying for you, Sue. Your
Kate EdgartownPraying for you, Sue. Your words are so powerful. Thank you for sharing.
We are so sorry for your loss
From KatamaWe are so sorry for your loss Sue! We lost two uncles in NY nursing homes. We were totally upset and understand your sadness. Neither of then could face time which made it worst for all of us here. Covid
was not listed for them either! Cuomo with get his punishment because even many of his die hard liberals have gathered together to force him out and will be held accountable which will help our grief just a speck. GOD BLESS YOU!
Add new comment