On my second night after moving to the Vineyard I heard the Old Whaling Church clock chime out the hour as I was falling asleep.
On my second night after moving to the Vineyard I heard the Old Whaling Church clock chime out the hour as I was falling asleep. That was when I realized this place was going to break my heart.
I could see then the outlines of my life here. I could see myself walking through town to work at the Gazette every day and hearing the Whaling Church clock marking my hours. I knew I would love it, and I knew it wouldn’t be forever.
I didn’t know yet about all the other things that would break my heart over these last few weeks, as I think about what I’ll miss as I prepare to leave the Island. I didn’t know about the spot where one of the green crosses on St. Elizabeth’s Church lines up with the Whaling Church steeple in a way that pleases me, the fence where the catbird perches in the summer, the birdsong that greeted me, along with Zoe, my neighbor’s cat, when I turned the corner onto my street. I didn’t know yet about the tree at Sheriff’s Pond where the red-winged blackbird sat in the summer, the swans I would watch nest and raise and lose cygnets every spring. I didn’t know about the stories I’d write, the people I’d meet, the sound of the press running on Thursdays, the early fall smell of ocean and wood smoke. I didn’t know about the sky so full of stars that I still catch my breath when I look up at night.
My corner of the Vineyard for the past six and half years was mostly within earshot of that clock bell, which I could hear from my desk at the Gazette and all the way out at the pond. I like to think about the town mapped out like the little village buildings that came with my dad’s old train set. Here is the town hall and across from that, the courthouse. Here are the four downtown churches, there’s the lighthouse.
Here is the newspaper office, in an 18th-century building with a quill-shaped weather vane that creaks in the wind. The old drawers of paper clippings made me think about reporters who wrote about whaling ships arriving at Edgartown ports, who covered the extinction of the heath hen. Like me they spent their days thinking and writing about this Island. Edgartown was my beat, and I watched years of selectmen’s meetings and Fourth of July parades, annual town meetings when the Whaling Church filled with golden hour light and townspeople. I covered controversies and tragedies. I talked to people at their best and worst moments. I was there the night town hall filled with firefighters, who clapped and cheered as the retiring chief walked out of the building and drove off into the sunset in a fire truck.
Two blocks off Main street was my dead-end street. I knew where to look for Jupiter, easiest to find in the early summer sky, right above the neighbor’s fence gate. That’s where I would find Zoe the cat, who welcomed me right after I moved in more than six years ago. She had an owner she loved, my landlord right next door, and friends up and down the street and blocks away. She was the feline mayor of Mill street, coming in and out of her house through a little cat door with steps leading down to the lawn. She was a calico with a black patch on her face and yellow snowy-owl eyes, relentlessly social, a free spirit, a fierce huntress.
Zoe died a couple summers ago, at age 15, and the whole neighborhood mourned.
When she wanted to visit me she scratched at the window or the screen door, and many mornings I was surprised to find her asleep on her blanket at the foot of the bed, forgetting I had let her in during the middle of the night. In the winter she left footprints in the snow, going to and from my door. In the summer she climbed trees while I looked at the stars.
One summer night I ran home in the rain after covering President Obama’s departure from Martha’s Vineyard Airport, and Zoe ran along with me for the last block or two. I filed my story as she sat next to me, having a bath.
The farthest I ever heard the Whaling Church bells was out at Sheriff’s Pond, which borders a smaller pond, a mudhole really, and then Eel Pond and Nantucket Sound. I walked there almost every day and looked for swans and herons, turtles and muskrats, and let out a deep breath. At sunset there, when the swans were dipping their necks into the water and the buoys were clanging out on the sound, everything felt right in the world.
On my last night in Edgartown I wrapped myself in a blanket and went outside in the early morning to look at the stars. I found Jupiter above the Whaling Church steeple. During my last weeks in Edgartown I’d been woken in the night, for the first time, to the hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo of a barred owl. That night it was quiet, just me and the landscape I’d mapped in my heart.
I had seen the heartbreak coming. So much happiness caught me by surprise.

Comments
Wonderful piece. Will miss
Diane Crane Oak BluffsWonderful piece. Will miss your contributions to the VG and to wcai. Best wishes!
What a beautiful and brave
Kiri BostonWhat a beautiful and brave story. May we all find the strength to find so much peace and joy in our surroundings, in ourselves.
According to Roger Cohen in a
Rob Burnside Kingston, PAAccording to Roger Cohen in a recent opinion piece, the French say, "Great loves always end badly." Sara, you've shown us the French are not always right. Thanks for all your fine work over the years, though it seems you've saved the very best for last. Fair winds, following seas, and a calico cat's meow be with you.
Sweet memories, Sara.
thomas dresser Oak BluffsSweet memories, Sara.
We're so glad you were part of the Vineyard community for six years. Your observations and research and perspective added a great deal to the Gazette and the Martha's Vineyard Magazine.
You will be missed, but you are always welcome back.
Have a good life.
So lovely, and so true. You
Holly Gleason today, Cleveland, OhioSo lovely, and so true. You captured the Vineyard's essence; it captured your heart.
But as someone who also fell in love, then had to move on, I can tell you: the weather vanes, mother of pearl moments before sunrise, stillness of the ponds at vespers + all that you write live in your heart -- wild and unfettered -- forever.
I've never met you. Having
Barry Adler Meshacket Road, EdgartownI've never met you. Having read this piece, I will now miss you. Hope you find more happiness where you go next.
Lovely. Thank you.
Bruce PennsylvaniaLovely. Thank you.
great story , reading it puts
rob the roofer new jerseygreat story , reading it puts you on island a great place to be. "don't cry because it's over smile because it happened"
The Vineyard has a way of
Joyce Guelli Waltham, MAThe Vineyard has a way of stealing our hearts, sounds like it got yours too. Very nice piece, I wish you luck. I’m sure you’ll be back.
Beautiful writing, thank you
Dean Rosenthal EdgartownBeautiful writing, thank you for your contributions over the years and best of luck to you.
Such a lyrical writer. I know
Linda Malcouronne Center ConwaySuch a lyrical writer. I know we will hear more from you in the future. Wishing you peace and happiness, wherever you roam.
dear Sara - that is so
Judith Mallery Philadelphiadear Sara - that is so beautiful - it speaks to so many of us who, for one reason or another, have to move in a new and unexplored
direction. That special beauty never leaves us - it does remain in our hearts forever Godspeed
Thank you for these words,
Mike N ChilmarkThank you for these words, whose beauty is matched only by the island itself, as well as the simple joys of a lively cat and a hooting owl. Thank you for being a columnist for a day. You made my day.
Thank you for all your work.
Daniel W EdgartownThank you for all your work. We have loved reading your writings in this paper. Hope they hire another young person to fill your spot as journalism is progressing forward to new technologies and the young know it best!
Brightest blessings dear Sara
Sally Apy EdgartownBrightest blessings dear Sara! Thank you for being you and changing the world.
Thank You - As a summer
Hal EdgartownThank You - As a summer "Resident" and year round subscriber to the Gazette - we will miss your stories that kept us anchored there.
A beautifully written piece.
Jay ChicagoA beautifully written piece. And the photo with Zoe is a perfect accompaniment to it. Thank you.
The Island is truly a
AliciaThe Island is truly a magical place. Beautifully written I wish you the best.
Don't be sad Sara. The
William Woolverton BostonDon't be sad Sara. The Gazette and the Vineyard live with me, and always will, from my summer as a reporter for the Gazette more than 40 years ago. My heart is stronger from that special time.
Dear Sara, despite being a
Julie Anne VH and New OrleansDear Sara, despite being a washasore, if i may be so bold, I believe you have had an profound impact here. Your voice, both written and heard via your WCAI, became a chip in the elusive mosaic bedrock here, and it will continue to be so. So many people come here and are changed, but so few actually change this place (and please forgive my use of the word “actually”). I have no idea why you are leaving, but I am saddened that we are losing you. Thank you for this and the many many pieces you have written. Wishing you well!
Thank you, Sara, for this
Luanne Johnson Oak BluffsThank you, Sara, for this beautiful parting gift and your years of service to our community. I will miss you. Wishing you many blessings!
Sara, your work as a
Matthew Stackpole West TisburySara, your work as a journalist is of the highest quality and has been a gift to all who care about and want to understand the news and issues on the island. You will be greatly missed and the good news is because of your fine work for the Gazette you too are now part of the “record” of the island. The people and place that is lucky enough to welcome you will be getting not only a talented journalist, but also a wonderful human being. Fair winds!
I’m predicting that your lead
Anne Williamson EdgartownI’m predicting that your lead sentence resonates with many of your readers. The Whaling Church bells are the heartbeat of Edgartown. Thank you for noticing and many thanks for capturing Vineyard life for the past six years through your writing.
she has broken my heart as
Elizabeth R. Weisman Philadelphia & VHshe has broken my heart as well. there’s no place like home. yes, the stars, breathtaking again and again. thank you for this beautiful piece.
That was such a lovely piece
MaryThat was such a lovely piece Sara. I wish you all the best in your future. The Vineyard, once it grabs hold of your soul it stays and never leaves.
Agreed. Heartbreaking. I miss
Tamar ShirleyAgreed. Heartbreaking. I miss it too. I was once at the sister paper for 6 years and an odd summer or two and miss it as well... it stays with you. It still feels like home.
Add new comment