Sellout crowd gave more than one standing ovation.
Mark Lovewell

John Kerry Rebuts Isolationism, Calls the Vineyard Home

<p>The former Secretary of State regaled a packed house in Edgartown with humor and gravitas in a speech that was a pointed call to activism.</p>

Former Secretary of State John F. Kerry regaled a packed house in Edgartown Thursday evening with humor and gravitas in a speech that was a pointed call to political arms and citizen activism.

It was also a spirited rebuttal of the current trend toward American isolationism, with remarks clearly aimed at President Trump.

“Many people are again drawn to the fool’s gold that tempts people with the promise that if we just retreat within our borders, loosen our ties to each other and to the rest of the world, we can actually somehow do better going it alone and focusing on our own societies,” Mr. Kerry told a sell-out crowd at the Old Whaling Church.

Former Secretary of State John F. Kerry took the stage at Old Whaling Church Thursday night.
Mark Lovewell
Former Secretary of State John F. Kerry took the stage at Old Whaling Church Thursday night.
Mark Lovewell

“History tells us starkly, that, what I just described, is not how you make America great. That is how you make America cut off, alone, and vulnerable to threats that have no respect for borders. How sad it is and disturbing it is for me to see people who know better turning their backs on the realities of what’s happening day to day in our nation’s capital. Good people are not speaking out for what they know is not normal, is not right, is not appropriate. They seem to be more concerned about power and party than they are about nation and values.”

He spoke as part of the Martha’s Vineyard Hebrew Center Summer Institute series. The event was moved to the Old Whaling Church to accommodate the large attendance. Every seat in the church was filled.

Now 73, Mr. Kerry served as Secretary of State from 2013 to 2017 under President Obama, succeeding Hillary Clinton. Prior to that he served five terms in the U.S. Senate representing Massachusetts, from 1985 to 2013, and was the unsuccessful Democratic nominee for president in the 2004 election. He was Massachusetts lieutenant governor in 1983.

Born in Colorado, he graduated from Yale University and Boston College Law School. He enlisted in the Navy and served in Viet Nam, where he earned medals for valor. He later became a noted opponent of the Viet Nam War.

He is currently affiliated with the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace as the organization’s first visiting distinguished statesman, working in the areas of conflict resolution and global environmentalism.

He is also a new homeowner the Vineyard. In March he and his wife bought a house at Seven Gates Farm in Chilmark. Mr. Kerry’s change of address was the subject of humor, applause and one of the evening’s more poignant moments.

“The great American novelist Thomas Wolfe wrote prophetically, ‘you can’t go home,’ and I’ve experienced a few moments and places where perhaps that’s proven true,” Mr. Kerry said. “But I want you to know that after four years on the road and 1.5 million miles as Secretary of State, I can tell you right here, Martha’s Vineyard, Massachusetts, it is really good to be home.”

Mr. Kerry outlined what he called interconnected global issues.
Mark Lovewell
Mr. Kerry outlined what he called interconnected global issues.
Mark Lovewell

Mr. Kerry framed his address with four global challenges which he said would shape the world for future generations. He referred to his daughter and young granddaughter sitting in the front pew of the spare old church as he outlined what he called distinctly interconnected global issues.

“The first thing we have to do is actually do a better job of organizing a global response to defeat the forces that seek to impose a radical violent extremism on people everywhere,” Mr. Kerry said. “We’re going to defeat DAESH, I’ve said that consistently. [The former Secretary of State used the Arabic acronym DAESH when referring to ISIS, the Islamic State of Syria and Iraq.]

“We can see it on the battlefield today, but there will be different kinds of DAESHs that reemerge. If we don’t do a whole bunch of other things, then fighting them is only the beginning of what we have to do. We have to strike more effectively at the root causes of extremism. People need to understand that that old song from World War I doesn’t have relevance today. It’s not over there. Over there is here, here.”

The second challenge Mr. Kerry singled out was the growing pace of technology which allows information and commerce to outpace government, leading to an oversimplified view of globalization.

“In country after country ideas are moving faster. People are moving faster, the marketplace is moving faster,” he said. “The only thing that isn’t coming at us faster is the ability of governments worldwide to respond. Our civil discourse is anything but civil. Bombastic, destructive, and destructive through the example we’ve set as a democracy in the world. It’s no wonder that so many people would like to just stop globalization, and stop the world and get off. But you can’t do it.”

The former U.S. Senator called for a laser-like focus on economic growth. He said politicians are exploiting people by making promises of a return to a manufacturing economy which they cannot keep. He advocated a shift from viewing technology as a job killer to viewing it as a way to open new fields of employment.

“Many people who were hurt in the 2008 economic implosion, particularly here in our country, they’re still feeling the pain,” Mr. Kerry said. “Here in the United States your average family suddenly found their house worth half its value. But guess what, they’re stuck with 100 per cent of a whopping mortgage. That is a pretty simple recipe for a lot of anger. Yes, technology is transformative, but if it was your job that disappeared, guess what, you’re not going to be finding much comfort in the fact that the same technology that stole your job, gives you the ability to sit at home with a smart phone and binge watch a future that’s completely out of reach of you and your children.”

After traversing the globe, former Secretary of State said it was good to call the Vineyard home.
Mark Lovewell
After traversing the globe, former Secretary of State said it was good to call the Vineyard home.
Mark Lovewell

Finally, Mr. Kerry issued a scathing denunciation of President Trump’s recent decision to abandon the Paris accords, a voluntary set of standards and goals to reduce the effect of climate change agreed to by nearly every nation in the world. His signature is on the document. He noted that though the United States is no longer part of the accord, 37 U.S. states have committed to continue meeting the environmental standards to reduce climate changing pollution.

“President Trump’s decision to withdraw from the Paris agreement is an unprecedented forfeiture of American leadership,” Mr. Kerry said. “It is not only not based on any fact or any science, it is based on a lie to the American people, that somehow Paris imposed a burden on America that was intolerable, when in fact it imposes no burden on anybody. We are already halfway to Paris. We will not only meet Paris, we will exceed the goals of Paris. Trump may pull out of Paris, but the American people will not.”

Dressed in casual blue slacks and an open-collar white linen shirt, Mr. Kerry spoke for nearly an hour, then took questions for about 30 minutes. He received multiple standing ovations.

He interspersed his address with humorous anecdotes. The one which drew the most laughter was about a climate change fact finding mission to Antarctica, also at the expense of President Trump.

“On the day of the election,” he said, “I was winging my way to Antarctica, and when the results came out the next day, I felt like staying there.”

He ended the evening with an impassioned plea for citizen activism, speaking directly and bluntly to the receptive crowd. He called “citizen” one of the most important words in our language.

“Nobody here has a right to sit on their rear end and not be engaged politically and actively as a citizen,” Mr. Kerry said.

Read an edited transcript of Mr. Kerry's remarks.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 07/29/2017 - 09:45

Permalink

robert skydell chilmark

Kerry's closing comment really resonated, especially when you stop to consider that the word 'citizen' has fallen out of fashion and been replaced by another: consumer. Sadly, our society has accepted that as our paramount role without a whimper.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 07/29/2017 - 09:57

Permalink

On the Island Martha's Vineyard MA

Someone should tell him that there is NO Martha's Vineyard Massachusetts. He lives in Chilmak Massachusetts.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 07/30/2017 - 18:02

Permalink

Doug Best VIneyard Haven

Refreshing comments from Kerry who has insight in situations many of us know nothing or very little about. At least he's thrown his hat into the game and tried to bring about positive change for all. And been doing it a long time. And here he is, recognizing the quality of life that is so unique to the Vineyard, that he relocated here like so many of us others who've travelled far and wide and want to call the island home. It is special and the calling for all is to keep it that way. It's not Newport or Nantucket, we know that and so does he. We try and keep it simple and real, and experience/enjoy all that the island and this region has to offer. In the beginning and the end it's all about family and friends. In the middle we get to meet everyone else! Welcome John, Theresa and family. Hope you become family and friends!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 07/31/2017 - 11:58

Permalink

Bob Fargo Edgartown

I'm no Trump supporter, let's get that straight right away! That said, Kerry is as total and complete fool. God save us from Trump, but also God save us from the mistakes and blunders this fool and his former boss made. Glad he's only giving speeches now instead of implementing Policy!

Ray Gosselin Edgartown

Finally someone with common sense. Look at the mess the former regime put us in, not to mention financially. Imagine going around the world to offer apologies for America. The greatest country in the world. Already we've seen huge progress in defeating Isis, more than in the previous 8 years.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 07/31/2017 - 22:48

Permalink

Mike Ross Edgartown

Sounds like Mr Fargo has all the answers. Maybe he should debate Mr Kerry at a future forum. Referring to a former State Senator, military veteran and Secretary of State who has dedicated his career to serving the people of this country does not fit any definition of a fool. Mr Fargo's choice of words makes him a perfect companion for our current administration.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 08/01/2017 - 01:52

Permalink

Christine Powers Waltham, MA

I wish that Mr. Kerry were our President now! We must find some strong and qualified Democrats to run for office in 2018 and 2020 to drive out Trugh!

Submitted by jaldeborgh (not verified) on Tue, 08/01/2017 - 03:15

Permalink

John Aldeborgh Edgartown, MA

I come to the Vineyard to get away from Politics and Egoists and I was raised to never say anything bad about anybody so I won't. Ronald Reagan said in 1964 during a famous speech supporting the Barry Goldwater campaign, and I'm paraphrasing here, that there shouldn't be a left or a right but rather an up or a down. This country, in almost every measurable way, has been in decline for the past 50+ years, on our slow but steady path into socialism. Trump, is a manifestation of this decline along with the toxic political world we live in today, so we have no one to blame but ourselves. Government is not the answer, never has been and never will be, the founding fathers got this exactly right 250 years ago. We have to trust that people are fundamentally good and that 350M people, each with a unique perspective and skill-set, in a competitive environment, will yield the best outcome. This is what made America the greatest country on earth for 200 years and the 545 people who comprise the Senate, House, Presidency and Supreme Court are not, and never will be, smarter than the 350M people that they supposedly serve, although you'd never know it today. I wish Mr. Kerry and his wife much happiness in their new summer home along with a long and active retirement.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 08/01/2017 - 09:12

Permalink

Barry Plunkett boston

Society has organized itself into categories and labels that pit us aginst each other in every sector of human interaction. We are not the greatest country, we are a country. We are not an enlightened nation, we are possibly slightly better than despicable, but probably not. WE don't feed and house all our people before we build 10,000 sf homes and golf courses and yachts. We think 800,00-1mm abortions a year is woman's healthcare, we poison our soil, aquifers, forest lands and air, yet we accept all under the mantra of economic growth, which only truly occurs at the top. We are sheeple. If you have an original and transformative idea in your head, you probably bury it so you get invited to the cocktail party. Anarchy should be the call, as I suspect anything less will fail for the change necessary. We might even hope to hasten the end of man to give the other species we share the planet with a chance to survive. The next masters of the earth could not do worse. Wake up people. Protect the dignity of all life first and demand the end of wealth.
Start there!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 08/01/2017 - 17:37

Permalink

Paulli D Edgartown

I held off as long as possible. Mr Kerry for the 1.5 million miles and god knows how much in taxpayer money to fund these trips we are left with North Korea, ISIS, Syria, Libya , turmoil in the Middle East, China in the South Seas, Russia and I don't mean the salad dressing. I just don't get how you can stand before a crowd and criticize anyone else.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 08/01/2017 - 19:13

Permalink

Fred Roven Edgartown

The framers unfortunately did not see the possibility of gerrymandering and voter suppression causing a situation where a plurality of 3 million votes did not lead to victory in the Electoral college.
Also I do not have any concept of what was wrong with the past 8 years. Lowest unemployment in years; highest stock market in years; foreclosures down to a trickle. I will admit I mostly stopped listening to or reading much news for 8 years except Sunday mornings because I felt safe. I sincerely wish there was a way to sit down in a gathering and have someone explain this to me.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 08/02/2017 - 21:52

Permalink

George Stein Edgartown

Disappointed appreciation of Mr Kerry's appearance turned into more soap box drama. Like him or not he served our country several ways. That he came to the Island and took question from the general public earns more respect from me than these alleged leaders who visit.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.