Shubael Weeks Road dates back to British invasion of the Vineyard during the Revolutionary War.
Mark Lovewell

Commission Takes Steps to Protect Historic West Tisbury Roads

<p>The Martha&rsquo;s Vineyard Commission has taken steps to preserve the historic character of several West Tisbury roadways. Commissioners voted to designate Pine Hill, Red Coat Hill, Mott&rsquo;s Hill and Shubael Weeks roads as special ways, affording them protections against future development.</p>

The Martha’s Vineyard Commission has taken steps to preserve the historic character of several West Tisbury roadways.

Commissioners voted unanimously Thursday to designate Pine Hill, Red Coat Hill, Mott’s Hill and Shubael Weeks roads as special ways, affording them protections against future development.

“The public’s rights on these ways have never been extinguished, but I think it’s important that those rights be acknowledged and maintained in this way,” Rez Williams, a member of the West Tisbury Byways Committee, said in an appeal for the commission’s support.

Roads and byways across the Island have enjoyed special protection since 1975, when the commission adopted an Island-wide district of critical planning concern that regulates the aesthetics and safety features of certain roads.

Under the Island Road District special ways zone, those roadways which are deemed exceptional for historic, cultural or symbolic reasons cannot be expanded beyond 12 feet or paved with impervious material. Direct vehicular access is only possible by special permit.

The four West Tisbury roads were designated for historic and cultural reasons.

According to the town planning board, Pine Hill Road was once a major route that connected Old County Road with Lambert’s Cove Road. Red Coat Hill served as a lookout over the harbor during the Revolutionary War, but during an 1778 invasion known as Grey’s Raid, Red Coats invaded the hill, leaving a garment behind. Shubael Weeks Road was named for a Tisbury selectman who served during the raid. All four roads appeared on maps dating to the 1800s, according to the town.

“Their loss would be irreplaceable,” the planning board wrote in the nomination papers.

The designations are made official with a town meeting vote; West Tisbury voters will see the article on their town meeting warrant in April.

In 2010, the roads were named special ways, but the process never advanced to town meeting for a vote because of litigation involving ancient ways in Edgartown.

The special way designation for Pine Hill Road may pose a temporary delay for a large subdivision project that hopes to use the road as the primary access for two of five lots.

A public hearing before the commission has been scheduled to take place on March 19, but commissioners will not vote until after town meeting, so as to incorporate the result of the vote. If the town backs the designation, developer Joe El-Deiry can apply for a special permit for use of the road.

Another historic route in West Tisbury is also a candidate for permanent protection.

Old Coach Road, which historically served as a public route for mail delivery, once connected Holmes Hole (Vineyard Haven) with North Tisbury, the site of a post office in the early 19th and 20th centuries, according to a history provided by the town.

Over time, two-thirds of the road were developed into a modern road which serves a subdivision and the town landfill.

On Thursday, the MVC voted to nominate the road for designation as a special way.

With an official nomination now on the books, a moratorium on any development within 20 feet of the center line goes into effect until town meeting.

Thursday’s vote to nominate Old Coach Road was also unanimous.

Growing up in West Tisbury, Commissioner Josh Goldstein rode his bike to school on the old footpath.

“It’s a beautiful piece of woods,” he said. “It’s a safe way for kids to cut through. It’s really important to the wonderful character of the town I grew up in and love.”

If the commission agrees to add Old Coach Road to the special ways district, the moratorium will be extended until a vote at the annual town meeting in April.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/25/2015 - 10:38

Permalink

J C Murphy West Tisbury

The law is very specific that you cannot make an ancient way a special way unless you first make it a Public way. It is very difficult to make an ancient way "which is a non-existent legal term" into a public way. There is a lot of litigation and due process that must be adhered to before such public use and activity can be allowed by law. Town counsel for West Tisbury was proven wrong in attempting to do this on a number of roads recently, which in the recent particular circumstances added a TAKING of 20 feet on either side of the fee of the way and were stopped and should have been and still may be sanctioned by the Board of Bar Overseers for attempting to proceed with public advertising and use without first performing due process. You cannot take the law into your own hands and make your own remedies because it suits your wants. This was also not to be within Commission's purview, but rather to be determined by Land Court, which was also abused in my opinion. If these roads have been deemed public by Land Court, that would be a different circumstance. However I believe they have not gone through "Due Process," but I could be incorrect and as a result am not sure. If they have not, the law is being abused again, and the activity should go before the courts.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/25/2015 - 19:02

Permalink

Phillip McCavity Oak BLuffs

Ugh!!! More stellar work from the Martha's Vineyard Commission. Now they are designating dirt roads and paths as special ways. Heaven forbid anyone forget about the 1778 invasion of MV by the British. Especially considering the British left behind a garmet!!!!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.