<p>As the summer season comes to a close, business owners in Oak Bluffs begin to reflect on the season, its successes and failures. And they start to plan for next season.</p> <p>Representatives of town government and the Oak Bluffs Association have also begun a discussion of the summer’s economic performance.</p>
As the summer season comes to a close, business owners in Oak Bluffs begin to reflect on the season, its successes and failures. And they start to plan for next season.
Representatives of town government and the Oak Bluffs Association have also begun a discussion of the summer’s economic performance.
“Once the season is over, after this benchmark weekend with Labor Day, we will have time and we will start thinking about how we all affect each other and we will go forward and do some projects that will help the town,” said Dennis daRosa, president of the business association.
While by some accounts August brought some of the best business the Island has seen in years, some say business in downtown Oak Bluffs suffered due to the presence of vacant buildings on Circuit avenue, the main commercial street in town. In response, town officials and business people have begun a dialogue about possible revitalization initiatives. The topic will likely make the warrant for some kind of discussion at a fall special town meeting set for Nov. 12.
“I think we are excited about an uptick in the Island’s economy this year, and we want to run with it, we want to move forward,” Mr. daRosa said.
A few prominent downtown buildings stood empty this summer, including Seasons Eatery and Pub, the former home of B. Tru, the future home of the Edgartown National Bank, the former home of Deon’s restaurant, and the two movie theatres at the foot of the avenue.
In the case of the Island theatre and the bank, construction that was slow to begin in the off-season was left unfinished when a summer construction prohibition went into effect in June. The Island theatre, built circa 1915, has stood roofless for three months awaiting repairs.
Town administrator Robert Whritenour has formed a task force of town officials, business affiliates and a representative of the Martha’s Vineyard Commission to address ways to revitalize Circuit avenue. Selectman Walter Vail, chairman of the board, suggested that the town adopt a bylaw that outlines minimum standards for maintaining buildings in town. Last week, Mr. Whritenour convened the beautification team to discuss wording for a possible bylaw. “The existence of blighted or vacant buildings impacts not only the property values of the area but also the reputation and integrity of the town and its commercial districts,” reads the purpose statement of the draft zoning bylaw. The draft bylaw goes on to outline property maintenance requirements for buildings in the commercial districts B-1 and B-2, to be enforced by town building inspector. The bylaw would create a registry of vacant buildings in order to track their maintenance, and prevent further deterioration, Mr. Whritenour said.
Mr. Vail’s particular interest is the pair of movie theatres which have not shown films throughout the summer and are in need of repairs. Mr. Vail said they were in “miserable condition.”
“From my standpoint, I would really like to see the Strand and the Island theatres reopened,” he said at a recent selectmen’s meeting. “We are going to keep working to get them open again; by golly, we are going to do it.”
In past summers the theatres brought in evening crowds in the hundreds, which increased foot traffic into stores and restaurants on Circuit avenue, Mr. daRosa said. He hopes at least one of the theatres will be reopened in time for spring.
Benjamin Hall, who manages the buildings on behalf of the Lucky Seven Realty Trust, said in June that he intends to resume work on the Island theatre when the construction ban is lifted this month. “We are hoping that it can be reconstructed and can be used as a theatre again,” he said at the time.
Mike Santoro, a selectman and member of the business association, has compared the current state of the avenue to Main street in Vineyard Haven a few years back, where some buildings stood empty during the summer months. “Just as Vineyard Haven went through it a few years ago and came out of it, Circuit avenue is going through it as well,” Mr. Santoro said at a recent selectmen’s meeting. He suggested that Oak Bluffs look to their down-Island neighbor for ideas about how to achieve revitalization.
Mr. Whritenour said state and federal money may be available to improve the appearance of Circuit avenue. For example, there are federal grants available to towns for streetscape improvements through the Department of Housing and Urban Development, he said. Alice Boyd, who administers grants for the town, has begun to put together an inventory of grants available to the town for beautification purposes.
“We look forward to a very strong and lasting partnership between the town and the [business association],” Mr. Whritenour said. “If there is anything the town can do to bring in resources, to help promote the business community, we are going to use those to try to help beautify our town.” He is hopeful that such a collaboration will help “create partnerships and bring people together.”
Mr. daRosa echoed the sentiment. “We want to be more proactive with the selectmen, with the town, about issues of parking, issues with the sidewalks, and overall issues with Circuit avenue, to make it more of a pleasant shopping experience.”

Comments
Just a suggestion. If you
R. N. EdgartownJust a suggestion. If you want to get businesses into those vacant buildings try convincing the landlords to lower the rent. If they would offer them at an affordable rate that actually allows you to have a little money left after you pay the outrageous rent you might have more people interested in opening shop. JMO
Agreed, sir!
Tom Oak BluffsAgreed, sir!
I think it is unrealistic to
Joel Kadis EdgartownI think it is unrealistic to ask an owner to artificially reduce its rent. Instead, how about town buying building and then offering rent to uses residents want ? That's what Harvard U does in Harvard Sq.
I'm not sure if they would be
RD MVI'm not sure if they would be artificially lowering the rent. If businesses cannot make a rent, and it seems apparent that there is a problem, then perhaps the rate the landlords are asking is not sustainable, and they oftentimes lose money on it. A vacant space makes no money, and if they were to charge a more reasonable rate both the landlord and tenant win.
If that's the case though
Ken Esq Edgartown, MAIf that's the case though then the landlords would be losing money on the vacant space and would want to lower the rent in order to get tenants. Sometimes it's better to wait for a tenant that has a solid business plan and a chance of survival rather than renting to someone who most likely is going to be late with rent, and a possible eviction. In many cases a landlord won't make any money on a lease for the first year or so if they've had to do any build-out or free months rental for the tenant while they get started.
I believe that over 90% of new businesses in the US fail. Most don't fail because the rent is too high. They fail because their business plan is flawed from the start and/or they have little to no experience in running whatever business they're attempting.
It's not asking the landlord
MT O.B.It's not asking the landlord to "artificially" lower the rent. It's called charging a reasonable rent. The market will tell you what it is. If your building is vacant and others are not, you are charging too much! It's just a dumb business move to be greedy and have no rent paid rather than make a little less.
Benjamin Hall hasn't upheld a
Cara West TisburyBenjamin Hall hasn't upheld a promise for improvements on a commercial or residential front in decades. Why would we believe he would start now?
I think you are seeing the
Mr. B ChilmarkI think you are seeing the results of businesses having reached and exceeded the saturation point in Oak Bluffs. There are simply too many stores, most of which are competing for the same dollar from an relatively unchanging number of people: food, drink, souvenirs, transportation (bikes/mopeds/tour buses) and some clothing-beyond-t-shirts. None of it is inspiring nor is it meant to be. The mission is to make as much money as possible in the very short season.
And there are too many stores for all to do this successfully. So, they are abandoned as businessmen (and women) sense the impracticality. Some structures might be purchased by the town, torn down and turned into mini-parks or patios. It would make the streets look a bit better.
Less places mean more
George Stein EdgartownLess places mean more business for the other guys. Complaints about the town being dirty suggest proprietors should invest in their own external garbage cans and liners.OMG $20 for a box of lines and $30 for a container! If your customers take out give them and the others who spend money in town a sign of your business being a concerned neighbor. Section 8 is for residences not small businesses. Examine how many towns and small business owners Sandy wiped out across the Northeast and count your blessings Oak Bluffs the tourists are still coming.
Joel - that "idea" ia
Lawrence NYJoel - that "idea" ia tottally not legal at all what you suggested. That is a felony! Ha Ha
Why is not legal for a town
Joel EdgartownWhy is not legal for a town to buy real estate and lease to whoever it wants as long as use complies with zoning ? A town's goal can be different from a profit maximaion goal.
Add new comment